4 ms·
That would make NYC 5x as dense as SF. But your numbers are wrong. San Francisco's land area is 46.9 square miles. New York's land area is 304 square miles. New
by wpietri 12y ago
That would make NYC 5x as dense as SF. But your numbers are wrong. San Francisco's land area is 46.9 square miles. New York's land area is 304 square miles. New York's density is about 50% higher.
But it's not clear that New York shows any a path forward. They did build up, and prices are still high. Maybe that's a sign that blindly increasing housing supply doesn't actually solve the problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sadface 12y agoYes, in some parts of NYC (Manhattan, cool parts of Brooklyn) prices are indeed very high, but there are plenty of parts of NYC where you can find fairly affordable housing while still being in public transit range of the things that make NYC a major "World City". My friend is paying <1500/mo for a 1 bedroom in a good part of Astoria that's about 35 mins by foot + subway from times square. He only moved there a few years ago so it's not like he's taking advantage of some crazy rent control either. You'd never find something equivalent in the bay area, so overall I think the "density argument" has some validity. Even more so if there would be willingness to expand the public transit infrastructure.
- santaclaus 12y agoAstoria is probably next up on neighborhoods to explode in rent. Hell, LIC of all places is starting to look like parts of Williamsburg.
- wpietri 12y agoOne guy finding a decent apartment still doesn't demonstrate that increasing density does much to solve problems. Also, I question your definition of affordable. $1500/month is 36% of the US median wage. People making less need to live somewhere too. It also looks like you can find equivalent things in the Bay Area: http://sfbay.craigslist.org/search/apa?maxAsk=1500&bedrooms=1&bathrooms=1 http://sfbay.craigslist.org/search/apa?maxAsk=1500&bedrooms=... I am definitely in favor of expanding public transit, though. I think that's a much better way to increase network effects.