4 ms·
"[Hurricane Katrina's] aftermath was a wake-up call for thousands of Americans. “It taught people you could go hungry, thirsty, and even die in the U.S.
by aaronbrethorst 12y ago
"[Hurricane Katrina's] aftermath was a wake-up call for thousands
of Americans. “It taught people you could go hungry, thirsty, and
even die in the U.S. before the government could save you.”
Sure, if you're poor and black[1], and the government happened to put someone profoundly unqualified in charge of FEMA[2].
"I’m a bit of a prepper. I probably have some materials and views
that could get me seriously put on a watch list."
This person sounds like a raging narcissist. In fact, everyone in this article does.
I ask Campbell if he fears the kind of lawlessness seen in post-
Katrina New Orleans or the riots in Ferguson, Missouri.
Again the comparison of the middle class (ostensibly white) narcissistic "preppers" with African-Americans in poverty-stricken areas.
Preppers emphasize certain threats and ignore others to “craft
a scenario where their preparations can be seen as both necessary
and sufficient.”
Raging narcissists.
Anyway, you could say that these people aren't doing any harm to anyone or anything besides their own bank accounts, but I disagree with that. Between fostering a greater sense of paranoia and distrust between them and their neighbors, helping them double down on a "I've got mine, so fuck you" attitude, and inspiring them to vote for fringe candidates who not only agree with them, but actively want to see the apocalypse happen[3], I'd say these people are doing real harm to the fabric of society.
[1] http://www.journalofamericanhistory.org/projects/katrina/Landphair.html http://www.journalofamericanhistory.org/projects/katrina/Lan...
[2] http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/11/03/brown.fema.emails/ http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/11/03/brown.fema.emails/
[3] http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Michele-Bachmann-Barack-Obama-Iran-Israel/2015/04/15/id/638639/ http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Michele-Bachmann-Barack-Oba...
- makeitsuckless 12y agoI suspect that there is a direct connection between this phenomenon and the US being a nation that despite all of its resources and know-how was not only unprepared but apparently fundamentally unwilling to handle a disaster like Hurricane Katrina. (Americans have apparently already forgotten, or maybe never even realised, what an enormous international embarrassment that was.)
- greedo 12y agoSure. Just like France, despite all of its resources and know how has a heatwave in 2003 that kills over 14 thousand people. Europeans have apparently already forgotten, or maybe never even realized, what an enormous embarrassment that was for a "modern" country in the 21st Century.
- FireBeyond 12y agoIt's a little more complex than that. The French (European) heatwave had a lot of long held social and family structures that contributed to it, from a tendency of the elderly to live by themselves, often disconnected to one degree or another from family, most of the country was in 'holiday' mode in August, and other things. The embarrassing thing about Katrina wasn't that it happened (though the flooding was preventable), or the deaths. It was that -the agency specifically designed to deal with the AFTERMATH, and given billions of dollars to do so- was so spectacularly incompetent, from the top down (Michael "Heck of a Job" Brown, a lawyer friend of Bush's put in charge of FEMA who by the time of Katrina had no more emergency management experience than the NIMS course you and I can take online for free), that they actively made things worse in many cases, not better.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThen they spent billions on loans to rebuild - and no rebuilding was done, and nobody paid back the loans.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWell yes, that was an embarrassment for France. The only mitigating factor was that such a heat wave was a virtually unknown phenomenon, whereas hurricanes are well-understood and by contrast.
- seizethecheese 12y agoAnyone being interviewed about their hobbies is at risk of coming off as a narcissist. Relax.
- yourapostasy 12y agoI agree with you there can be very distasteful aspects of the prepper group, but it's like that with pretty much any group of people. The value of what they do and/or the concepts they advocate can be separated from who they are. The further up the ladder of technological development you try to reproduce with prepping, and the longer the timescales of self-sufficiency you work towards, the more you are essentially engaging in an exercise to find out how to reboot civilization to a selected technology level, from another selected technology level. You also find out post-haste that this effort goes rapidly non-linear as you extend those two axes. There are related discussions floating around the Net about what it would take to establish a completely independent space habitat (or extrasolar planetary colony). Due to this dynamic, realistic rebuild-from-apocalypse prepping to current technological levels (or even 1940's levels) takes government-scale resources, and a very aggressive low-pass filter on the finances of prepping ensures the population of those preppers who alarm you will only ever be an extremely small and ineffectual group. There are way more imminent threats than this group. As groups go, politicians who vote for the Patriot Act and the increasing militarization of police represent a far more legitimate and immediate threat to you and society than these preppers ever will; anti-vaxxers against, say, polio vaccinations are also far more dangerous. But there are lessons to draw from everywhere and all experiences in life. From the preppers, learning about a measure of self-sufficiency doesn't hurt; for many working poor and middle class in the world, greater autonomy from rentier processes in our current incarnation of civilization definitely wouldn't hurt. From the politicians, learning the price of centralizing responses to risks instead of delegating responsibility to citizens can be instructive to future generations. Even from the anti-vaxxers, we can learn the value of understanding how to critically assess scientific research on our own.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoNot to be too sarcastic, but does America even have a fabric of society these days? How much of the population has to be nearly mad with paranoia, hatred, and condescension towards almost everyone around them before you stop calling it a unified society and have to call it multiple societies?
- alphapapa 12y ago> actively want to see the apocalypse happen I read the article you referred to. That's a gross misrepresentation of her comments and views. You're implying that Bachmann would do things to try to bring about economic and societal collapse, but that's completely false. Rather, the truth is that she interprets current events as being indicative of the inevitable coming of her interpretation of biblical prophecy about end times. If you don't understand the difference, then it suggests to me an anti-Christian bias on your part. Now, what is actually written in the Bible? "But concerning that day or that hour, no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father." (Mk 13:32) If Jesus didn't know, then I don't think Michele Bachmann or anyone else knows, whether or not they are or claim to be a Christian. And you know what else is doing real harm to the fabric of our society? Painting all Christians as "fringe" and "fundamentalists" who are "doing real harm to the fabric of society." Think about who the real enemy is. If you offend one group's sensibilities by ridiculing their prophet, they riot and murder people. If you offend another group the same way, they...what? Hold prayer vigils? Oh, those evil Christians! America will surely be a better place when they're all gone! Just remember that when you sweep them out, something else will take their place. And that something else has already stated its intention to subjugate all peoples under its laws, or else kill them. Be careful what you wish for.