5 ms·
It's an interesting article and I unfortunately don't know diddly-poop about neuroscience, but this statement: "Yet, some researchers attempting to replicate R
by mcguire 12y ago
It's an interesting article and I unfortunately don't know diddly-poop about neuroscience, but this statement:
"Yet, some researchers attempting to replicate Roses’ work have failed to find an association between TOMM40 and the age of Alzheimer’s onset. Roses has countered that these groups aren’t performing his research correctly and that the work involves complicated diagnostic methods. 'Because TOMM40 [research] is not as easy to replicate as ApoE4 [research] was,' Roses says, 'the first thing they say again is the data is wrong.'"
sets off my kook detector rather strongly. That is exactly the situation that many false claims find themselves in, and it's exactly the response that the investigators make just before the wheels start coming off.
From other parts of the article, I don't know or even believe strongly that Roses is wrong, but if you're a future scientist in an experimental field, be very cautious about saying things like that.