4 ms·
Yet this deal likely has little to do with reaching consumers, but rather tapping into the state’s vast supply of auto parts suppliers. They're indirectly maki
by onion2k 12y ago
Yet this deal likely has little to do with reaching consumers, but rather tapping into the state’s vast supply of auto parts suppliers.
They're indirectly making a link between Michigan jobs and Tesla's success. As Tesla gets bigger it'll make that law look like it's holding Michigan's manufacturing industry back rather than helping the state's car sellers defend their businesses. People care about manufacturing jobs a lot more than retailers.
- jobu 12y agoHopefully that's true, but auto dealers are huge contributors to elections (even bigger than auto manufacturers - https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/indus.php?ind=T2300 https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/indus.php?ind=T2300 )
- fleitz 12y agoImagine there was a law where the big 3 couldn't sell cars online in CA, and they bought a company that puts internet into cars in SF... It's probably because they want internet in their cars... not because they are trying to put the state legislature on the arm.
- bsdetector 12y agoSo why would Tesla even care about sales in Michigan? Musk always implies that Tesla is production constrained (again just two days ago in Q1 earnings call), and Michigan isn't one of the states with ZEV program, so a sale in Michigan earns Tesla $30k less than a sale in California or Massachusetts or the other 8 ZEV states. Selling in Michigan costs Tesla money. And why is Tesla so against dealers? As long as Tesla is showing the "internet price" then customers can see exactly how much the dealer is higher so buying from a dealer wouldn't even be a bad experience. A Tesla dealer would be more like CarMax, or at worst a Saturn dealership. I think it's worth considering that Tesla may in fact be demand constrained not production constrained, and that's why they need to sell in these states where they earn less. And they don't want dealers because they are much more transparent about demand.
- rosser 12y agoTesla isn't only selling in ZEV states. Are they also losing money to "prop up" numbers in the non-ZEV states they are selling in?
- bsdetector 12y agoIf Tesla is production constrained then they can sell the same unit in Michigan and get $100k income, or they can sell it in California and get $130k income then use that extra $30k to increase production. So why sell in Michigan?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoBecause everyone's money is green.
- wlesieutre 12y agoIf they're production constrained, they can't do both. Sell one car and make $130k or sell one car and make $100k. Not sell two cars and make $230k.
- NathanKP 12y ago> And why is Tesla so against dealers? I'm not a representative of Tesla, but if I was Elon Musk I wouldn't want my product being sold by dealerships either. The dealership industry is an outdated, parasitic system that has nothing to offer Tesla. It is little more than a middleman which saps away profit that could be going to Tesla itself. On the other hand Tesla has everything to gain in revenue, image, brand value, and consumer experience by running their own boutique stores. The dealerships have also gone way too far trying to get legislation passed to stop Tesla and protect their parasitic business model rather than adding any real value that makes them useful to Tesla. That in my opinion turns this into something more personal, a battle in which Tesla wins more respect the more they fight back. By refusing to sell the vehicle entirely they actually gain in status (the more difficult to obtain good gains value) and they progress toward the longer term goal of making profit free of parasitic middlemen. The alternative would be to make a few more dollars in the short term by using dealerships but lose in the long term. The Elon Musk suite of companies has always been very long term focused so I'm not surprised to see them working toward long term vision rather than giving in on a short term battle. Basically to Tesla the future is selling their goods (not only cars but also Powerwalls, and whatever else they have in development) directly to customers in order to improve profit margin, and they aren't going to give in on the road to making that happen. A boutique store for selling vehicles today can sell Powerwalls the next year. This makes Tesla much more robust instead of being reliant on a middleman.