3 ms·
I ran across this story over a decade ago. See http://forum.iwethey.org/forum/post/151431/ http://forum.iwethey.org/forum/post/151431/ for my thoughts then. M
by btilly 12y ago
I ran across this story over a decade ago. See http://forum.iwethey.org/forum/post/151431/ http://forum.iwethey.org/forum/post/151431/ for my thoughts then.
My conclusion then was that this is a case of conflict between two paradigms. Until believers in the hypothesis that beta-amyloid is critical run into crisis, alternate theories will have a hard time being funded and heard. No matter what the facts may be.
Sadly there is a history in science of people who were right being marginalized for decades before anyone else noticed. To name an example, Barbara McClintock in the 1930s managed to prove that genes can move around in the genome. She stopped publishing her work in the 1950s because it was too hard to convince other scientists to pay attention to her apparently impossible results. In the late 60s and 70s many other researchers replicated her results in different organisms and biology was finally able to figure out the mechanism. She began to get awards at that point, finally resulting in the Nobel in 1983.