3 ms·
> asm.js represents LLVM bytecode No, emscripten compiles asm.js from LLVM IR, but asm.js itself is more like a portable bytecode for a 32-bit register machine
by TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago
> asm.js represents LLVM bytecode
No, emscripten compiles asm.js from LLVM IR, but asm.js itself is more like a portable bytecode for a 32-bit register machine.
> The programmer sees errors when generating the asm.js, not when executing it.
Why would that be the case? The point of asm.js is so browsers can optimise it. It doesn't matter what your tooling thinks, in the end what matters is whether browsers accept it.
> Whether it is then executed by a JIT or not is, in this case, irrelevant.
No, whether it is executed by a JIT is quite important. asm.js is a subset that browsers can validate and then compile ahead-of-time. If your code is failing validation and falling back to the usual JavaScript mode, there's a big performance penalty, and your code isn't asm.js-compliant!
> Nobody writes asm.js by hand, no matter how it is executed.
Actually, some people do. It's not the nicest of languages, but there are some people who do.
But even if you don't, what if you're using buggy or outdated tooling producing incorrect output? What if you're targeting a browser that doesn't support some new asm.js feature? You need to know if your code didn't validate!
- Sephr 12y ago> Actually, some people do [write asm.js code by hand] Who?
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoPeople wanting high performance. For example, Grant Galitz's IodineGBA had some portions in asm.js https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA
- Sephr 12y agoNo, it doesn't. Where in IodineGBA do you see any hand-written asm.js code? Here's are some quotes from the author of that very library: "asm.js requires a style of coding only compilers can output. A person writing actual asm.js code by hand would need to be insane as asm.js code required style of coding is horribly disorganized"[1] "Unfortunately asm.js requires one giant array to put things on. No one in their right mind codes like that by hand."[2] 1: https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA/issues/16#issuecomment-26540283 https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA/issues/16#issuecomment-2... 2: https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA/issues/16#issuecomment-26540283 https://github.com/taisel/IodineGBA/issues/16#issuecomment-2...
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThat's from 2013. There have been more recent discussions.
- s-macke 12y agoI did for my emulator jor1k. Take a look: https://github.com/s-macke/jor1k/blob/master/js/worker/or1k/fastcpu.js https://github.com/s-macke/jor1k/blob/master/js/worker/or1k/... Handwritten asm.js code. Around 10 hours or porting time.
- Sephr 12y agoThat's quite an impressive implementation! I didn't realize hand-written asm.js could be that readable.
- s-macke 12y agoYes, more or less. Every operation must be written, that the type is obvious for the compiler. And you have one array, the heap with some special index rules. For example: (r[((ins >> 9) & 0x7C)>>2]|0 The >>2 and |0 is necessary.