23 ms·
The state does its job http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToReportViolationtoBOFE.htm http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToReportViolationtoBOFE.htm What makes you think
by prostoalex 12y ago
The state does its job http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToReportViolationtoBOFE.htm http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToReportViolationtoBOFE.htm
What makes you think the cosmetologists are not owners themselves (and hence self-employed, exempt from minimum wage), 1099 independent contractors (and hence exempt) or simply undocumented in the United States?
- Retric 12y agoIt is very unlikely the IRS would qualify them as 1099 independent. Undocumented workers still qualify for minimum wage laws even if their unlikely to fight the issue. As to the owner issue, that's possible, but everyone would need a near equil share or minimum wage laws still apply. AKA giving someone 0.1% generally does not let you dodge minimum wage laws.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> It's vary unlikly the IRS would qualify them as 1099 independent. As I understand it, they often set their own hours, supply their own equipment, control how they do their job, and rent space in which to do it from the establishment in which they do it, which provides services like centralized collection and distribution of customer payments. I'd like to see the argument as to why, using the actual criteria used to define contractor vs. employee relations, they wouldn't be classed as contractors.
- Retric 12y agoOddly enough an extended period without any pay is not really a direct issue in terms of minimum wage. But, is a vary strong suggestion that someone is an employee. From the IRS list the examples given seem clear cut. http://www.careerusa.org/resources/career-files/100-resources/career-files/12g3-w2-or-1099/281-1099-vs-w-2-an-irs-checklist-.html http://www.careerusa.org/resources/career-files/100-resource... 1. Fails location test, likely others. 2. A no pay period fails this test. 3. Fails 4. Fails 5. likely fails 6. Fails 7. likely fails. A predefined time to show up counts as set hours. 8. likely fails. 9. Fails 10. (case by case basis) 11. No reports, but direct supervision likely fails. 12. likely fails. 13. likely pass. 14. likely pass. 15. Fail 16. ? depends 17. likely fails. 18. likely fails. 19. Fails 20. Fails
- Domenic_S 12y agoEh, IT consulting fails a whole bunch of those too but we still do 1099. The 20-point test is a guideline, not hard and fast law. (Aside: That's probably why BigCos hire contractors by making them go W2 with a staffing agency and contracting the staffing agency to make you available full time.)
- whyaduck 12y agoWhat I got from the article was that they did NOT set their hours, train themselves, etc. Workers are picked up in vans by their employers, are trained by their employers, directly supervised (very closely) by their employers, etc. About as cut and dried as it gets.
- prostoalex 12y ago> It is very unlikely the IRS would qualify them as 1099 independent. How come? The setup with most hair cutting salons is that you "rent" a station from the owner, and then arrange your own clientele and participate in some kind of rotation of walk-in customers. Most non-corporate hair cutting places don't have any employees (and the need for higher-level client management led to startups like StyleSeat). I believe the set-up is similar with non-corporate professional massage therapists as well - the "table space" is rented out, the therapist is then responsible for booking clients.
- panzagl 12y agoIt sounds like the fee goes to the salon owner, not the nail tech.
- prostoalex 12y agoThe transaction occurs on the owner's cash register, as credit cards need to be processed and receipts handed out, but we have no visibility into actual money flows. That's not to say it has to be that way - Square, Styleseat, Mytime are all targeting this, but we still have cash customers, check customers, etc.