5 ms·
Reading this, I can't help but think how much of Twitter's job has shifted from doing the work to tap-dancing about the work. So much of this is about failure t
by wpietri 12y ago
Reading this, I can't help but think how much of Twitter's job has shifted from doing the work to tap-dancing about the work. So much of this is about failure to meet "expectations", failure to meet possibly-arbitrary comparisons to possibly-relevant things.
I also hate, hate, hate the cult-of-the-CEO viewpoint here. It could be that Twitter's CEO role is so central that a) all the issues trace back to its current occupant,and b) all problems can be solved by installing a new occupant. But if that's really the case, then I'd call that a very badly designed system. In what software would replacing 1/4000th of the code solve all the performance and user interface problems? It seems like the model is less, "creative, involved, self-directed workforce" and more "3rd-world cult-of-personality banana republic".
- austenallred 12y agoI think you're underestimating the power of leadership. Of course, replacing one person in a large organization isn't going to make a huge difference statistically, but it makes an enormous difference if that person is directing all of the other people. If there are 4,000 people towing a ship, a change in the captain could change which way they're rowing.
- smitherfield 12y agoOr, to use a real-world example, does it matter who is President of the United States? The federal government employs 4 million people, and the President has far less control over them than a CEO has over their employees.
- wpietri 12y agoIf we were towing ships, that would make sense to me: the task is simple enough that one person can understand what's going on, and the 4000 people might as well be 4000 chimps or 4000 engines. But that's not Twitter's situation. Note also that there's an enormous difference between leadership and direction. MLK for example led many people but directed few of them. I think the former is important but rarely happens precisely because CEOs can just direct people and get apparent compliance.
- Pyxl101 12y agoThe assumption is that a good CEO will review his employees' performance, and ability to execute his vision, and either develop them or let them go and bring in the right people. The CEO is the person who dives into the organization to find and fix its broken pieces; he starts with his direct reports, who then audit and fix their organizations, and so on, until the company gets where it needs to be. He doesn't do it all personally, and can rely on divide-and-conquer, but the CEO is the one leading change in the company.
- wpietri 12y agoYes, and I think that top-down paradigm is fundamentally ridiculous at this scale. That we are expecting one person to do all that is a sign of a problem. This might have made sense in a 1950s corporation, where the work was relatively stable and manual, where you needed armies of people to perform repetitive actions. But most of Twitter's people are engaged in what is essentially creative work. When I talk to friends at large software companies, I hear a lot about top-down reorgs and other central-planning issues. Given that primates are always looking for dominance hierarchies, maybe we really can't do much better than organizations where replacing the CEO is the main way to solve problems. But I hope for something better.