3 ms·
This expectation largely derives from II Thessalonians 3:10--"The one who is unwilling to work, let him not eat"--and it comes from an era of civilization where
by logfromblammo 12y ago
This expectation largely derives from II Thessalonians 3:10--"The one who is unwilling to work, let him not eat"--and it comes from an era of civilization where the majority of the populace was employed as agricultural laborers, by necessity.
Now we have robotic tractors that can operate with a tiny amount of human supervision. The Industrial Revolution made it possible for children and elders to not work. We do not begrudge them their allowance, because their labor was no longer needed. Female integration into the workforce further lessened the need for the marginal laborers.
Computerized automation has further lessened the demand for unskilled labor to such an extent that the equilibrium market rate is likely below subsistence level. Minimum wage laws transform that into unemployment. People want to work, but cannot find enough to pay for their consumption.
You are demanding that people work, but you are not explicitly making the inchoate demand that someone be forced to buy their labor. It is not needed. We have enough bullshit jobs already. It may be time to end the charade and find more reasons for people to choose to exit the labor pool. Lower the retirement age. Guarantee living expenses for both graduate and undergraduate students. Extend maternity/paternity leave out to a whole year. Simplify disability payments such that everyone who cannot lift a 15kg mass from the floor and move it 20m is exempted from work that may require it.
I would very much prefer that the people doing work be both competent and motivated to do the work, rather than grudgingly present as the means to pay their bills.
The minimum I expect is zero. I don't want anyone to create more bullshit jobs that occupy people with busy work. Let them pursue their vocations instead.
- nosuchthing 12y agoFair enough, but I have seen the effects of people and kids in living conditions where all basic necessities are provided and they're quiet often completely unmotivated and stagnate. It might be great to let the robots do everything though.
- logfromblammo 12y agoWere there conditions attached to the provision of those necessities? Would they be reduced or revoked if the recipients earned any income on their own initiative? Would your observations be explained by removal of the implicit requirement that one must do work of a particular type to survive, or could they also be explained by conditioned helplessness, where people receive negative stimuli in response to attempts to change their own lifestyle? The welfare system in many US states is not a great model for predicting human behavior in an environment where the basic needs are not particularly scarce. In any case, an unmotivated, stagnating person is preferable to someone who becomes violent and destructive. I'll take 1000 couches filled with 1000 semi-professional marijuanologists over one angry arsonist any day of the week, and twice on Fridays.
- nosuchthing 12y agoWhat I meant by unmotivated people with all basic necessities met being unmotivated - I was speaking of middle class suburbanites I know, who's goals and accomplishments hardly exceed watching full seasons of television shows. A civilization of couch potatoes just reminds me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qkPGlVqqEP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qkPGlVqqEP0 As for any reform that would help treat, rehabilitate, and employ [1] former convects (or differ to rehabilitation programs instead of the money sink hell hole of the prison system) - that would bring a welcome and significant impact to all the millions of dollars, lives, time and resources wasted on for profit prisons and the vicious cycle of convicts with no where to turn. [1] http://www.triplepundit.com/2014/07/3p-weekend-10-companies-hire-formerly-incarcerated/ http://www.triplepundit.com/2014/07/3p-weekend-10-companies-...