8 ms·
Shotspotter CEO Answers Questions on Gunshot Detectors in Cities
- TruthSHIFT 12y agoDoes this technology have a slippery slope? Assuming that the technology isn't useful for recording conversations, what's the worst that could happen by implementing this in residential neighborhoods?
- jagermo 12y agoAs far as I see it you waste money that could be better used in staffing police, implementing social programs etc - this thing is a solution to a very tiny problem: gunshots that are not reported via emergency calls. As far as I can see this does not help with robberies, burglaries, attacks with fists/knives/bats etc. Even if its not a slippery slope - I'd imagine there are several better alternatives where you can spend the money.
- detaro 12y ago> this thing is a solution to a very tiny problem: gunshots that are not reported via emergency calls I wondered how big a problem this is, but the only number I quickly could find is annoyingly from their advertising material and claims that in some areas only 10 % of shots were reported, which is not really the relevant number. Does anyone have a number on how many people die of gunshot injuries that either weren't reported or reported to late?
- CHY872 12y agoThat's also not the relevant number. In places like Chicago, what you end up with is a tiny proportion of the population (say 2000) that is perhaps 100 times more likely to be murdered and is a major drain on your city's image. This is fuelled by revenge killings; someone gets shot or shot at, their family/friends round up the posse. So what you want to do is get people off the street before they start shooting, or if that fails, you get them off the street as soon as they start shooting in order to break the cycle. At the moment, with the dispatching of officers etc, you find that it takes about 2 minutes from receiving a call to an officer being dispatched (that's from the London Ambulance Service). A lot of this is just the time between the call arriving and the operator working out where the person is. Before the call, there are perhaps 15 seconds where the bystander who calls up is getting their phone out and dialing. In this case, with the new system you can in principle have two squad cars each half a mile away knowing where the gunshot is to a reasonable level of accuracy, perhaps within a couple of seconds of the shot itself. Within a minute of the first shot, the police can be on the scene. In this case, the suspects have only just jumped into their cars, and so are picked up easily. There's no opportunity for any kind of revenge, because the suspects are in a cell. Of course it's not a fantastic idea for every city; but if you're a company that focuses on military hardware, filtering off into LA, Chicago and NY can easily be an advantage for all.
- breischl 12y ago>>this thing is a solution to a very tiny problem: gunshots that are not reported via emergency calls. That's not exactly true. When people call in gunshots they frequently have at best a vague idea where the shots came from. If you're sitting in your house with the window open, the shots will most likely sound as if they came from that direction - even if they were actually in the opposite direction. So you could be sending the police to a place 6 blocks away, which in a dense urban environment is quite a long ways indeed. Being able to reliably figure out the actual location has value. source: we have lots of gunshots in our neighborhood. Police response and ability to actually catch people has gone up since the spotter was installed.
- aorloff 12y agoI'm not an expert, or even a layman in audio encoding, but it seems to me that a solution could be found that couples an open source capture program with their backend. The open source (audited and only updated from the open source branch) capture program filters the audio stream down to something that only contains a gunshot signature, and nothing else. If the motivation is there a solution is certainly possible.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoIt could be done, similar to this lightning detection project: http://www.lightningmaps.org/realtime http://www.lightningmaps.org/realtime http://www.blitzortung.org/Webpages/index.php?lang=en&page=3 http://www.blitzortung.org/Webpages/index.php?lang=en&page=3 TL;DR They do triangulated time of flight for EM emissions from lightning strikes.
- CHY872 12y agoThing is, with lightning it is dead easy because you're talking about what is essentially a straight line through the atmosphere. In a city, you get more issues: double datapoints from the gun and the bullet, multipath effects, etc etc etc.
- joosters 12y agoBut as the article says, they need the original audio in order to improve the gunshot detection - for example, if a gunshot is reported elsewhere but the detector doesn't classify it, they can grab the audio from the record to train the detector and hopefully improve it. If you never capture the raw audio, you won't be able to train the system to better detect the gunshots and to reduce false positives.
- jagermo 12y agoWait - what? There are so many guns fired in US cities that a company can build a sustainable business creating a system that spots these gunshots?
- dntrkv 12y agoI've lived in Sacramento, Portland, and now San Francisco and I have yet to hear a gunshot in any of these cities.
- batbomb 12y agoI've heard gunshots in SF more than a few times. Several times in the mission, once in the tenderloin, and once was a half block away from my house in the Richmond. I walked over right as EMS got there and saw them trying to stabilize a neighbor in a pool of blood. I also made the dumb mistake of tapping on a window sitting on my couch once when I saw a bunch of funny dudes with helmets just outside it. When they looked in the window I realized it was actually SWAT, right before they raided the house two doors down.
- jagermo 12y agoRight? I thought that was just something from TV/Movies - this looks more like they are selling fear than something real. Why would a city invest in something like this? Especially if you get the information via emergency calls?
- vernie 12y agoGun violence is made up.
- saynay 12y agoI happened to start working with a similar system today. For our customer there are several factors they are interested in: # Mapping gunshots in both time and space. These types of sensors can attempt to classify the type of weapon used based on the audio signature. If there are are several shots from similar-sounding sources moving through the city at a certain, or in a certain area over the period of days (or month), this can tell you more than you could determine from just emergency calls. # Tieing the gunshot sensors in with other input devices, like cameras. You can reduce the time spent looking through, say, traffic camera recordings that happened in the vicinity of the gunshot looking for related video. # Automatically pointing moveable cameras to look in the direction of a gunshot. Means you don't need as many camera for the same effective coverage.
- admax88q 12y agoThe privacy concerns with systems like these is not what they currently do, but what they are capable of. It doesn't matter what your privacy policy says, and it doesn't matter if the default configuration is to only download the audio near the time of a possible gunshot. The important part is that these devices can stream audio to remote servers. The NSA or anybody who finds or can coerce accesses to the system could use them to eavesdrop on everything within range. No amount of "privacy policy" is going to prevent it.
- wl 12y agoThat's assuming that audio from these sensors is at all useful for eavesdropping on people. Try a speakerphone lately? Even with higher quality codecs than we got in the POTS days and things like beamforming, the result is pretty terrible in decent sized conference rooms. Now try this outdoors, further away from people, with the noise floor of a city instead of a quiet room. The cases people point to where ShotSpotter has picked up understandable words have been people very close to sensors who were shouting immediately before, during, or after gunfire the system picked up. But at that point, it's unreasonable to claim some sort of violation of privacy when people are screaming for all to hear.
- Animats 12y agoRedwood City, CA had the first system. It was much simpler than this. They had analog microphones on phone poles, connected to a logarithmic amplifier which traded dynamic range for bandwidth. Phone audio is 8 bits at 8KHz; think of this as remapping to 16 bits at 4Khz, although it was done with analog hardware. They needed the dynamic range to see the full risetime of a gunshot, and gave up a big chunk of the voice spectrum to get it. Each microphone had a wired phone line connection to the central system at the police station, which was a PC with a data collection card running LabView. A LabView program turned gunshot information into map plots. It was a simple, local system. The new systems are much fancier. They're "cloud-based", which means the data goes first to ShotSpotter's HQ. They have synchronized clocks (probably from GPS), so they can send in timed audio snippets to be matched at the analysis center. It's a service now, rather than just hardware. Not clear what kind of data connection they have; probably cellular data.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoIs it possible to create a (cheap) non-firearm device that mimics gunshots closely enough to fool the system? Would be fun to put dozens up all around, on slow timers.
- hga 12y agoDepends on the sophistication of the system, and how many microphones it has. The vast majority, if not pretty much all of this class of gunshots, are going to start with the bullet being supersonic, the shock wave of which contributes to the signature (in the case of sniper fire I mentioned elsewhere in this discussion, it will tend to fool people into thinking the source is as much as 90 degrees from where the rifle actually is). I'm having difficultly coming up with anything that isn't essentially a blank firing gun, and I'll note those are deadly really close up.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoSo, a firecracker won't do the trick? I realize that's still explosive, but unless you're stuffing them up a nostril first they're pretty safe.
- hga 12y agoTo my thoroughly trained ears they sound very different. Thinking about it, to avoid false positives, companies doing this need to filter out fireworks, the proverbial car backfire (do they do that any more???), etc.
- 15155 12y agoA blanks don't have a projectile that breaks the speed of sound. Not sure that that would work.
- jbob2000 12y agoBut why? Why do you want to know when a gunshot happens? By the time you've heard it, it's already too late. “You were so focused on whether you could do it, you never stopped to ask whether you should.” - Jurassic Park
- OnlineRevenge 12y agoOnline Revenge on Ex, Get Exlover Back Online watsap:+2347030759636
- OnlineRevenge 12y agoI was looking for powerful magic spells for love. I was upset and depressed. Dr PayBack helped me finding my true love. I will never go to any other spell caster except Dr PayBack. quickrevengespell@yahoo.com, John (San Antonio TX)