5 ms·
I think the only reason is luck really. Stalin died shortly after the Soviet Union became a nuclear power. I read an interview of Beria's son explaining that S
by cm2187 12y ago
I think the only reason is luck really.
Stalin died shortly after the Soviet Union became a nuclear power. I read an interview of Beria's son explaining that Stalin was planning an all-out nuclear war. Given that killing a few dozen million people wasn't really a big deal to Stalin, there was a real risk he would have gone ahead.
McNamara in the excellent Fog of War also mentioned that Kennedy was extremely close to giving the order to bomb Cuba, I think he even mentioned that at one point the order had been signed, ready to go.
The Cold War is gone, but I think we have another danger. Drones and Robots have made it much cheaper for big powers to be more aggressive militarily. And the US is working actively on shields that could shoot down ICBMs. If the US can attack cheaply on the ground (as in with no US casualty) and not be deterred by a nuclear response, war is just bound to happen.
- darkmighty 12y agoYes, it's a diabolical situation that a good defense system actually increases the risks, that is, a defense system promotes war. It's a risk-vs-return situation: the nuclear standoff brings the risk of complete destruction, but that has low probability; while conventional weapons make mutual obliteration harder, but increase the likelihood of some war.
- arethuza 12y ago"Stalin was planning an all-out nuclear war" It seems unlikely that Stalin would have planned a war which would have been so completely one-sided. The Soviets didn't really achieve any kind of parity with US strategic weapons until well into the 1970s. Starting an "all out" war with the US with LeMay in command of SAC would have been national suicide - and the Soviets knew they were at a huge disadvantage. Stalin was lots of things but I don't think he could ever be accused of being stupid. Edit: Mind you I suppose it was possible that the Soviets thought they could invade Western Europe and survive the inevitable US and UK attack - but the US would have been untouched in such a scenario which probably wouldn't be a good idea...
- cm2187 12y agoI think the point was rather that Stalin was happy to use nuclear weapons casually, as just another weapon in the arsenal. We tend to forget that all sides in WW2 happily carpet bombed cities and civilians. Using nuclear weapons to achieve the same result more efficiently would have been only a logical evolution. In a way we are lucky that nuclear weapons only arrived late in the game and that after the war all sides preferred a status quo.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoDuring the Korean war Douglas MacArthur lobbied to use tactical nukes on the Chinese forces over the border.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y ago> If the US can attack cheaply on the ground (as in with no US casualty) and not be deterred by a nuclear response, war is just bound to happen. This gets at the real reason there have ever been some long spans without huge wars: stable balance of power. Usually in world history when the World Order changed much there were big wars involved. In the 20th century the USSR and China and NATO formed a relatively stable set of opposing forces.
- ethbro 12y agoAlso, the adage that democracies are disinclined to [suddenly] go to war. Which builds in a moderating effect to the calculus when at least one side has democratic government.
- gshubert17 12y agoWhat about coups such as the US overthrow of Iran in 1953? [1][2] Both seemed to be democracies at the time. A coup is not a war, but it isn't peace either. Is it the lack of a big shooting war? Or the power imbalance between the overthrower and the overthrowee? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_regime_change_actions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_re...
- ethbro 12y agoThe caveat would probably be that democracies only avoid wars which require democratic decisions to set in motion. I would say that most covert US meddling in foreign governments was covert for exactly that reason. .. probably some of the anti-Communist actions were the closest thing to democratically-approved intervention. And a lot of that was still covert.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Also, the adage that democracies are disinclined to [suddenly] go to war. The usual form of that is that no two democracies have ever gone to war with each other, and even then it requires such an excessively restrictive definition of "democracy" and/or "war" to be true that the statistically expected number of inter-democracy wars would be (to the nearest whole integer), given the number of wars over time and the number of democracies and the periods for which they have existed, would be zero. Its not even usually claimed that democracies are less prone than non-democracies to going to war with non-democracies.