3 ms·
I had the most humiliating experience of my life interviewing with AirBnb couple of years ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5300104 https://news.ycombi
by dominotw 12y ago
I had the most humiliating experience of my life interviewing with AirBnb couple of years ago.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5300104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5300104
- trimble-alum 12y ago1. Don't pay for anything out-of-pocket for a fly-in interview without solid assurances you won't be screwed (What assurances do I have your accounting people won't give me the indefinite run-around?) or disbursement delays forever (When can I count on being repaid?). Expense reimbursements normally requires receipts, prior approval (specific person in HR or hiring mgr) and talking to accounting to submit the right forms. 2. Don't do a fly-in interview without the following minimums: a phone screen with HR, hiring manager and a video call or two with someone on the team, otherwise they don't have enough invested because they've not qualified you enough to not waste your time and money. Or: find another or start your own company where people's time and money are not abused. (There's always some time / money invested on both sides of the table, and it's mostly wasted... The wise move is to reduce it as much as possible while still giving people enough of a chance.)
- contingencies 12y agoIt's like you're saying "it's your fault, here's what you should have done". Someone came up with a good term for this sort of HN answer the other day, "hindsight snark" or similar. In fact, any way you look at it a company with decent cash and an ounce of self respect should not be out there screwing industry peers over for time and chump change when it wants to expand. Disclaimer: I've had similar experiences with Google... outright missing interviews, saying one thing and doing another, failing to communicate entirely. Most of my own career has been at smaller companies or starting them myself. That's my resolution... just avoid big companies!
- trimble-alum 12y agoMost interviewing are wasted time and money, on both sides of the table, that is the presumption, it's a numbers game, also on both sides. It's when a pattern of excess accumulates which builds resentment: candidates just gauging their market worth OR employers being too picky about the wrong things OR not following up to make things right. How are accounting people supposed to know a reimbursement needs to happen if former candidates and/or hiring managers do not let them know? They're not mind readers. Hiring managers should be clear about whom pays for what and how to recoup any out of pocket, or resentment will spread. Also, it does show lack of professionalism on the company's part if they do indeed seem to screw candidates, even if it were an actual innocent oversight. It would be titanically stupid to habitually, intentionally cheat unselected candidates in the modern world, for the ensuing exposure risks deterring good candidates at least and risks lawsuits at work. Furthermore, on the candidate side of the table, it signals wisdom on behalf of a candidate if they socially-appropriately limit themselves to risks of screwed. This is a hiring signal of value, whereas someone that hasn't a clue is usually not respected as seriously. (To be fair, many of the best employees in their fields can seem shy, humble and odd to most. This is why it's crucial for astute interviewers to be non-threatening and mutually explore 1. how good will this person be on our actual work and 2. will they not mess up the shop's mojo... Hazing doesn't overcome current business problems, it guards incumbents' sense of in-group entitlement) PS: I've interviewed as an SRE manager at GOOG before and helped others with their projects there, but I've decided to stay "executing" (bizword bingo) independently on something else. The issue at GOOG is that their interviewing process is somewhat more pragmatic than most but still doesn't go far enough and is too ad-hoc/ineffective. Really though, I just don't respect their products enough to commit the emotional energy into someone else's ship. The advantage of small shops are like small towns: less chance of Tragedy of the Commons because there is nowhere to hide. Unlike most small towns, everyone in small shops must be able to pull their own weight.
- crdb 12y agoI know where you're coming from but I think this advice ignores the truth of such positions: that they are prestigious/well-paying/otherwise attractive enough to cause candidates to invest time and money into pursuing them. For example, why does Google sometimes take close to a year to make a decision on a candidate? Because they can afford to, with a pipeline of thousands of qualified candidates enough of whom will be OK playing along with Google's timeline in exchange for the significant CV boost, higher salary, prestige, experience, etc. The same applies to university applications - a lot of people will spend fortunes in time and money to try and get into Harvard, Stanford or MIT because the upside of having these schools on the CV is so high. Both prestigious jobs and universities (whether or not they should) do open doors, allow you to raise more funding and faster, to get higher positions all things being equal, to get your CV read in a pile of 200... So it comes down to valuing each position's Net Present Value (NPV) and the probability of it being a success, and deciding whether this is the most attractive use of your time and money. Let's say AirBNB has an NPV of (an additional) $3 million over the next 10 years thanks to the network and career boost, and you have a 5% change of getting it, the value of taking the interview is still $150k. Assuming you weigh negatives 9x as high as positives (can't remember where I read about this cognitive bias), if the interview has a total cost (including opportunity cost) of under $16k it is worth doing. Of course, at 5% chance of success per position, it's probably worth applying to more than just AirBNB.
- ma2rten 12y agoDid you at least get reimbursed eventually?
- lzecon 12y agoYour experience (and others like it) is the reason Airbnb decided to redo recruiting from the ground up. Almost the entire recruiting team has been hired in the last 2.5 years. Clearly it needed to happen.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoWhat he's describing there isn't a recruiting problem. It's a douchebag culture problem. I doubt you can fix that just by redoing the recruitment process.
- collyw 12y agoThere is definitely a trend towards crapper recruiting practices. I have been looking for jobs recently, and while nowhere near as extreme a scenario as that case, a lot of companies expect me to speak with the HR person for 20 minutes on skype, followed by a timed online coding test, despite knowing nothing about the job. You can ask the HR person, but usually they know next to nothing. Timed coding tests are stupid. That's not how I work on a day to day basis. "Weeks of coding can save hours of planning" is something I believe, and that planning is where my 12 years of experience in the industry makes a difference.