4 ms·
> you can't deny that drivers get absolutely shafted Actually you can. I think the simplest argument is the best one: They choose to do this voluntarily, ever
by BurningFrog 12y ago
> you can't deny that drivers get absolutely shafted
Actually you can.
I think the simplest argument is the best one: They choose to do this voluntarily, every single day they drive.
- zorpner 12y agoThe idea of "choice" is significantly more complex than you present it to be, particularly within the context of people providing for themselves and their families, and the information asymmetry Uber leverages in order to convince people to work for them.
- jasonisalive 12y agoSo what, some people have urgent needs, different parties in economic transactions have access to different information. Welcome to the free market. They're still choosing to work for Uber. No one is forcing them. Uber isn't forcing them. Uber is just offering an opportunity that they are deciding to accept.
- s73v3r 12y agoDoesn't mean they aren't shafting their drivers.
- specialist 12y agoPlease tell me more about this free market. Can you point to an example?
- pmorici 12y agoI disagree. Uber employs extremely deceptive advertising to recruit drivers and encourages them to do things like buy new cars then turns around and cuts the amount drivers get paid. This has the effect of totally screwing them over. It's a pretty exploitative situation for people who actually rely on it for income to pay their living expenses.
- branchless 12y agoI think people need to ask themselves - if it's half the price of a regular cab how can this be? Either tax drivers are being exploited by their employers who are pocketing most of the wealth generated, or uber drivers are underpaid. Or taxi firms are insanely inefficient and uber has undercut them with their web 3.0 brilliance.
- khuey 12y agoThe correct answer is "all of the above".
- vacri 12y agoMost people have no business training, and don't know about how to look for hidden costs. It's easy enough to think that taxis are that expensive solely due to the overpriced medallion system, which crops up in newspapers every now and again. Most people wouldn't understand that Uber's profit largely comes from shifting the risk from themselves to the drivers.
- BurningFrog 12y agoCan you show some examples of this advertising?
- DigitalSea 12y agoJust like workers in sweatshops and factories in countries like Indonesia and China have a choice to not work for a few dollars per day in dangerous conditions producing textiles for your $200 sneakers and smartphone components for your $1000 iPhone or Android device? The people working in those deplorable conditions are doing so voluntarily, right? Just like the homeless guy digging through the trash on Market St in San Francisco has the choice to not be homeless even though his area is being gentrified and even people on six figure salaries cannot afford to live in a lot of areas of San Francisco. I cannot get on-board with the view that everyone has a choice.
- BurningFrog 12y ago> The people working in those deplorable conditions are doing so voluntarily, right? They actually are, and if you ask them then can explain why they chose it. These factory jobs are usually very sought after, and has lifted millions from extreme poverty. I suspect you have little idea how harsh third world poverty actually is. This is a good overview: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/15/opinion/15kristof.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/15/opinion/15kristof.html?_r=... > Just like the homeless guy digging through the trash on Market St in San Francisco has the choice to not be homeless That's very different. He can choose whether to dig for trash, but not directly whether to be homeless. You can choose your actions, but not end results. He is also fairly likely to be mentally incapable to make rational decisions. Meanwhile, the Asian factory workers you mention are quite capable and responsible adults. As are the vast majority of American Uber drivers.
- stickfigure 12y agoAnother great overview is NPR Planet Money's series on how tshirts are made: http://apps.npr.org/tshirt/ http://apps.npr.org/tshirt/ It includes quite a bit about the lives of people working in the garment factories in Bangladesh. Sweatshops are a major step up from the alternatives - especially for women.
- vacri 12y agoChoosing the frying pan instead of the fire isn't much of an argument in favour of 'choosing voluntarily to work at X'. Besides, having no better options absolutely does not mean that you're not getting shafted.
- s73v3r 12y agoYour argument is completely irrelevant. The "its voluntary" thing means absolutely nothing.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIt's not really voluntary if you can either accept a crappy, abusive job or starve to death. People purposefully creating such conditions are doing something incredibly evil to other human beings. Having to "choose" at a gunpoint would probably be more humane.
- icebraining 12y agoSo Uber came to give them an option beyond "starve to death"? Seems like they should be praised even more.