5 ms·
What Two Programmers Have Revealed About Seattle Police Officers
- kelukelugames 12y agoThis is incredible. Imagine if you can see local cops' complaint records just like your neighbor's arrest records. Downside is this might encourage more fake and petty complaints.
- Zigurd 12y agoEveryone who sells products or interacts with the public has to deal with "fake" and "petty." Cops don't need exceptional treatment.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSure because cops don't deal with the public in the same way as, say, an Avon representative. Attempts to blur this are doing cops an injustice. They are a special case in almost every way.
- angersock 12y agoI absolutely agree. And that's why they should have fewer rights and more oversight than the Avon lady. The Avon lady has never burned an infant with a flashbang. Or shot a dog. Or shot an owner. Or shot a homeless person. Or shot another Avon lady.
- JoeAltmaier 12y ago...or had to deal with violent offenders on a daily basis. Yes, different in every way. It doesn't work to cherry-pick examples, you don't draw very good conclusions from that.
- rmxt 12y agoDo you think your median cop in the US actually deals with "violent offenders" on a daily basis? If so, who defines what a "violent offender" is? (Hint: it's probably the police officer him/herself, a pretty self-serving situation.) The point in all of this is that we no longer have to rely on such inconsistent and inaccurate first-hand definitions: body-cams, dash-cams and public access records would allow for a re-evaluation of all such interactions. If only police departments actually had the public's best interest in mind...
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI live in a college town, so maybe I have a biased sample. But yes, I do believe so. A suggestion: could you do what you need to do, if someone were looking over your shoulder at all times? There is a chilling effect on good cops too - if anything at all they say and do results in a personal lawsuit, they stop being effective at all. A ride-along some Friday night has been known to change the opinion of many a critic. See what a cop has to deal with, no room for preconceived notions or idealistic predictions. As for the public interest - we don't want to live in a world without policemen. There is a wide literature on that subject.
- VLM 12y ago"we don't want to live in a world without policemen" No need for binary thinking. We already no longer have policemen, we have infantry soldiers trained in urban combat with "shoot first ask questions later" rules of engagement and military weapons, deployed with an us vs them attitude, considerable deeply embedded racism issues, and a strong organizational opposition to respecting the occupied area's resident's civil rights. Or, in summary, it sucks. I agree with you, in part, its not as bad as having no order at all, which is hardly the only alternative to what we have now. I'd like living in an area with a police force. Military occupation force, not so good. But "real cops" would be OK.
- rmxt 12y agoI don't do my job with a gun or a mandate to maintain law and order. To reiterate your earlier point: any comparison to any other job is an unfair one. It doesn't matter how I would behave if someone were looking over my shoulder, it only matters how much more insight and oversight the general public would have into those who supposedly serve them. To be cliche: "With great power comes great responsibility." We don't need to go on an in-person ride along on Friday night: we can put cameras on them and let the whole of posterity go on every ride-along. Your point about a chilling effect on good cops due to lawsuits seems flimsy. Potentially frivolous lawsuits won't be resource intensive because they would have hard and fast evidence (video) for a prosecutor or jury to make a decision on. Good cops that know they are good cops could act confidently, reassured that their protocol-following actions are recorded. Citizens that might otherwise be mouthy, physically resistant, or whatever else might behave better knowing that the camera is watching. It really seems like a win-win for all parties involved, except for the "bad apples" and their supporters. Also, I don't suggest that we disband police forces. I do believe that policing in the United States needs to be more "peace officer"-like rather than SWAT-like. I feel that we are trending towards the latter.
- jrs235 12y agoThere's a civil and criminal procedure for making and filing false claims.
- Bill_Dimm 12y agoDid you perhaps mean "penalty" rather than "procedure"?
- anonbanker 12y agoI understood what he said. Do you?
- alexqgb 12y agoThere's no downside if the complaints come from real people. An individual filing a series of spurious and unsubstantiated claims can be charged with libel, or safely disregarded. After all, problem cops tend to be systematic about their abuse. The red-flag pattern you want to watch out for is lots of otherwise unconnected individuals all registering similar complaints about the same person. Also, an effective rating system doesn't need to contain every unsubstantiated mark against a cop. It can aggregate results and compare them against an acceptable baseline and / or a rolling average. The real point of accountability rests with their superiors, who should be dismissed from their positions if they persist in putting cops with bad records out on the street. In essence, they're placing the public in harms way, which is diametrically opposed to their official role as senior public safety officers. If that's not a firing offense, I can't imagine what would be.
- paulhauggis 12y ago"In 569 allegations of excessive or inappropriate use of force (arising from 363 incidents), only seven were sustained—meaning 99 percent of cases were dismissed" Anyone getting arrested and resisting will complain that it's "excessive force" when the police use any sort of force to arrest them. If you talk to any cop working right now, they will tell you this. This is why 99% don't see the light of day. "The two Seattle residents are now the closest thing the city has to a civilian police-oversight board" If this is even close to the truth, it's scary. They see numbers and text on a report. Nothing is in context to the situation that happened. This is why there are professional police review boards dedicated to investigating these matters...and we don't have armchair/twitter warriors making important decisions like this. "Then, in February 2011, Rachner met Mocek at an SPD town hall meeting. Mocek had had his own run-in with police. In 2009, security agents at Albuquerque Airport threw him in a jail cell for lacking identification and causing a disturbance. Mocek challenged the misdemeanor charges against him and, like Rachner, won. Their run-ins and legal battles with security agencies galvanized them, they said, to hold police accountable for mistakes and abuses." So how is upholding the law, "abuse"???? "the largest public union in the state" This entire article is about railing against the police, yet the unions are never mentioned as part of the problem. Very interesting indeed.
- ta37805 12y ago> This entire article is about railing against the police, yet the unions are never mentioned as part of the problem. Very interesting indeed. For context, The Stranger is Seattle's free alt-weekly. They have a very strong leftist bent, consistently endorse pro-union politicians while calling them "independent" without a hint of irony, and are unlikely to press this issue very much if at all.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoDo you read the same free alt-weekly as I do? The Stranger criticizes the Seattle Police Officers Guild (or SPOG) quite regularly. See http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archives/2014/12/22/spog-is-still-an-obstacle-to-reform-at-the-seattle-police-department http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archives/2014/12/22/spog-is... and http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/reform-in-reverse/Content?oid=19281433 http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/reform-in-reverse/Content... for examples.
- rmason 12y agoWhy shouldn't these records be available for free, even better yet accessible thru an API? Would the 'bad apples' still be able to operate in any area of government if there was true transparency?
- jbattle 12y agoI'm guessing because the records aren't all digital and there's some clerical work needed to either digitize them or maybe do some redaction or editing to make them suitable for release (e.g. I'd hope they would strip out social security numbers if collected)
- cmdrfred 12y agoThere should be a way to do that automagicly no? Anytime you see a grouping of digits like ###-###-#### black it out? I guess it all depends on how good the OCR software is.
- jdmichal 12y agoI'm not convinced. All it would take is OCR to read one of the zeroes as the letter 'O' instead, and suddenly there's your SSN out in the open. That's at least a civil lawsuit, maybe a criminal one, depending on context. (Healthcare, banking, etc. have strict laws in the US regarding the release of personal information.) In other words, the risks avoided by paying the best heuristic computer known to man -- a human -- far outweighs the cost of the resource.
- omg_ketchup 12y agoShouldn't the office releasing the SSNs (the police department) to a member of the general public (programmers in question) be held accountable for releasing sensitive information, not the person that bought it?
- jdmichal 12y ago
- suprgeek 12y agoThis is a perfect example of setting up a small community open source project that helps. Dump a lot of the info on github/etc (since it is public info) Ask people's help with OCR & Digitization (as needed) Get the community involved to find instances of Abuse etc Hold the buggers accountable - A large portion of Cops are power tripping bullies who think they are above the law
- ryanolsonx 12y agoI would definitely contribute to this cause.
- munificent 12y ago> Dump a lot of the info on github/etc (since it is public info) This is a perfect example of needing to actually read the linked to article: > COP considered dumping the raw data online for anyone to view, but decided against it because it would involve the publication of sensitive personal details—things like mental illness, drug addiction, or cases involving minors.
- Raphmedia 12y ago"How did two nerds come to hold SPD accountable?" Could we stop calling qualified professionals "nerds"? One of them is an independent cyber-security expert. I find it insulting. To me, nerd comes with this definition: "an unstylish, unattractive, or socially inept person". The journalist should be ashamed. What is this, high school? Edit: I find very interesting that this post was upvoted to 20, downvoted to 10 and is now back to 15. It seem that not everyone is insulted by the term "nerd" !
- kiba 12y agoNerd is a badge of pride. Nerd is less cooler than Geek. Nerd is more cooler than Geeks. Nerd can mean any social rank you want. Just let it go.
- Hobotron1 12y agoIt seems indicative of hostility and disdain- an unsubstantiated dismissal. And regardless of how you see it, plenty of people associate it with being mercilessly bullied. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJyMT4ZVQEc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJyMT4ZVQEc
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 12y agoI often hear that people should treat slurs as badges of pride, like "bastard" in Game of Thrones. Is that strategy ever successful? Can you name any group in history that managed to reclaim a slur? I can't, so that seems like a losing strategy. The winning strategy is to come up with a better sounding name for the group, and then marginalize anyone who keeps using the slur.
- jessaustin 12y agoI think "queer" has been claimed. I haven't heard it used offensively in a long time. [EDIT: I'm not in that group, so perhaps my impressions are skewed, but twenty years ago I heard it all the time.]
- omg_ketchup 12y agoThese guys don't even have a website! I instantly wanted to apply for a job. This is the kind of work I love to see. Using public records to improve the quality of life for people in their area, awesome.
- pmocek 12y agoWe do, but all that is there now is a single blog post: http://seacop.org/on-the-occasional-difference-between-police-statements-and-reality/ http://seacop.org/on-the-occasional-difference-between-polic...
- jqm 12y agoRegardless of police motivation, ethics or behavior, citizen oversight of police activities just makes sense. In my opinion there should be an officially instituted oversight board with open meetings and elections in every municipality and county in the US. I'm betting we would see a dramatic reduction in the problems caused by police and might just see a drop in crime as well. The average citizen certainly doesn't want police to be unable to do their jobs. But the concerns on accountability and how the jobs are being done is growing.