4 ms·
"One is domestic oil production. It may be a little early to tell, but it looks like all that money will have been wasted. So, net effect on the economy may end
by protomyth 12y ago
"One is domestic oil production. It may be a little early to tell, but it looks like all that money will have been wasted. So, net effect on the economy may end up being that we wasted time, money and natural resources in building useless machines in the middle of nowhere that added an unfathomable amount of carbon to our atmosphere."
How is the money wasted given the large production and downward price pressure on energy? This shift in price of gas at the pump has done quite a lot for the working poor in terms of cash on hand.
Also, "middle of nowhere" as a description is a bit insulting and I don't think most people in a city would like to have oil wells next door. Some things happen away from the coasts.
- throwaway9011 12y agoWe are mixing up a few things here. 1) Has the oil boom benefited anybody? Yes it has. 2) Has the oil boom benefited morally/politically sympathetic groups, such as the American poor? Yes it has. 3) Will the oil boom benefit humanity as a whole, over the medium to long term? The jury is still out on this one, and the answer may in fact be no. It is perfectly possible to do things that are beneficial in the short run but ruinous in the long run.
- cryoshon 12y agoExcellent points. Your comment does a great job of parsing the topics at hand while correctly identifying the core problems. Numbers 1 and 2 are pretty easy to see, because they've already happened. Number 3 is where you will face stiff resistance from capitalists because of their insistence bought via fake science that climate change isn't real or the consequences of fossil fuel use are ambiguous.
- maxxxxx 12y agoThe housing bubble was beneficial for a lot of people until 2008 :-)
- kolbe 12y agoThe downward pressure on oil may not have actually been caused by US oil production (though it may have). I think the bigger influence on oil prices is that gulf nations have maybe a 100 year supply of oil at their current output rates, but world reliance on fossil fuels doesn't look like it will last that long. Though, domestic production may have influenced this too. I'll grant you that as a real possibility. One thing this machinery does offer us that I didn't mention is the option to produce domestically if prices ever do rise to the point of that being profitable again. And that option isn't necessarily worthless. "Middle of nowhere" was intended to elicit imagery, not insult. Various places that are in the middle of nowhere are actually my favorite ones in the world.
- protomyth 12y ago"The downward pressure on oil may not have actually been caused by US oil production" Trouble economy and US production are the primary reasons for the decline. This has several sources in the media. "if prices ever do rise to the point of that being profitable again" The ND formations are profitable for existing wells down to $36 (multiple sources in earlier messages on HN). Further exploration won't happen until it goes about $50 or $60. The Canada oil sands are not profitable at the low end, but either is Russia or Venezuela. "but world reliance on fossil fuels doesn't look like it will last that long" It will last for a while yet, since we are still waiting on the breakthrough in energy storage to make batteries as convenient as gas at the pump.
- kolbe 12y agoI know what the media says. The funny thing about the media is that it seems to do a lot of brown nosing to US corporations. I'm telling you what I believe based on research and beliefs. And I believe Saudi Arabia isn't refusing to cut output to fuck over Russia or the US as the media posits, but instead because they want to liquidate their oil as quickly as possible based on the trajectory we are seeing in green energy technology. The tech isn't there yet, but as a betting man, I'd bet that we will make serious progress in the next 20 years to significantly marginalize oil. The numbers I've read are much higher[1] than the ones you cited. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/23/idUSL3N0SH5N220141023 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/23/idUSL3N0SH5N220141...
- derf_ 12y ago> How is the money wasted given the large production and downward price pressure on energy? The latter is exactly what causes the former to be wasted. If demand drops (or even merely does not rise as quickly as expected), then the price drops. If you were relying on high prices when you made your decision to invest more money to increase capacity, then what previously looked like a good idea may now be a bad one. When your break-even price is $60 to $65/barrel and prices fall below that, your net return is negative. But the best part is you don't even get to stop producing. The costs for most oil sources must be paid largely up-front, and your marginal cost may be only $20 to $30/barrel. So when oil drops to $50/barrel, you can choose between continuing to produce at a loss of $10 to $15/barrel over the life of the well, or stop producing and suffer a much, much larger loss. That keeps supply high and prices low. One oil source that does not have large up-front costs is fracking. Or, more exactly, fracking sites only last 18 months or so before production slows to a trickle, so you have a much smaller time horizon to recoup up-front costs. So the amount of fracking will very likely decline quickly. But viewed from an economy-wide standpoint, there was still plenty of malinvestment here: drilling equipment rental, trucking, rail, etc., require large capital outlays but carried high prices when oil prices and thus demand was high. As demand drops, they may not be worth the amount invested in them.
- protomyth 12y agoYou missed the quote from before the "last 18 months" in the story "Newly fracked wells have been known to produce over 7,000 barrels a day." or the "In Eagle Ford, operators have been able to drill wells in as little as 10 days. Within a month those wells will produce millions of barrels of oil." http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/08/shut-up-and-drill-why-fracking-could-end-the-age-of-gas-price-spikes/278494/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/08/shut-up-... They do a better job of explaining the whole thing and countering your points, but I will say oil is $60/barrel today.
- sedachv 12y ago> Also, "middle of nowhere" as a description is a bit insulting and I don't think most people in a city would like to have oil wells next door. Some things happen away from the coasts. That's what oil industry PR wants you to assume. Los Angeles has over 1,800 active oil wells, one on the grounds of a public high school, one across the street from a hospital: http://www.nileguide.com/destination/blog/los-angeles/2010/06/26/urban-oil-wells-in-los-angeles/ http://www.nileguide.com/destination/blog/los-angeles/2010/0... http://www.vice.com/video/oil-of-l-a--3 http://www.vice.com/video/oil-of-l-a--3 There are thousands more in and around residential areas in Los Angeles and Orange counties. There is even fracking and waste water dumping going on in the city: http://www.cafrackfacts.org/fracking-in-california/where-is-fracking-occurring/ http://www.cafrackfacts.org/fracking-in-california/where-is-... http://baldwinhillsoilwatch.org/ http://baldwinhillsoilwatch.org/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]