3 ms·
"Shit" and "science" derive from the same proto-Indo-European root. Does it then follow that I can use both words interchangeably?
by emodendroket 12y ago
"Shit" and "science" derive from the same proto-Indo-European root. Does it then follow that I can use both words interchangeably?
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoWhen you go as far as Proto-Indo-European roots you're in linguistic fantasy territory, but anyway, I was talking about "a word coming straight from the Latin root". It's a clear evolution from the Latin "niger" to Spanish "negro" and illiterate English colonist "nigger". And it kept its meaning of "black" all this time. Since we're talking etymology in the grayed out bottom of a HN thread, did you know that the word "slave" comes from the Latin "sclavus" that means "Slav" and is therefore offensive to people of Slavic ancestry? Will you stop using it now that you know? I hope not, but it goes to show the absurdity of putting hurt feelings before reason.
- emodendroket 12y ago> Since we're talking etymology in the grayed out bottom of a HN thread, did you know that the word "slave" comes from the Latin "sclavus" that means "Slav" and is therefore offensive to people of Slavic ancestry? Will you stop using it now that you know? I hope not, but it goes to show the absurdity of putting hurt feelings before reason. You're literally arguing against your own reasoning.
- stefantalpalaru 12y ago"Nigger" is not a terrible word because it means "black" as it always did. "Slave" is not a terrible word because it means "a person that is the property of another" now, even though it meant "Slav" at some point in the past. BTW, since "literally" became the synonym of its antonym what's the point in using it any more?
- emodendroket 12y agoNo, I mean, you are quite literally, in the traditional sense of that word, arguing that etymology is more important when the modern meaning of the word is offensive, and that the modern meaning of the word is more important when the etymology is offensive. No, that word is not offensive because of the etymology meaning "black;" consider that using the term "black" is not at all offensive.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoYou seem to believe that "nigger" means something different than "black" nowadays. What's this new meaning?
- emodendroket 12y agoThey're certainly not interchangeable, but you don't really believe they are anyway.