3 ms·
The AML laws require that you be a licensed MSB in each state that you operate in though (in the USA). Filing with FinCEN is indeed easy, however, it doesn't re
by mike_hearn 12y ago
The AML laws require that you be a licensed MSB in each state that you operate in though (in the USA). Filing with FinCEN is indeed easy, however, it doesn't really accomplish anything. The requirements themselves are entirely subjective and almost impossible to comply with if the regulators in question decide they don't like you.
For instance: take the requirement to report "suspicious" transactions. What does suspicious mean? It's left undefined. In practice, suspicious means any transaction the government doesn't like, and if it decides that retroactively ...... well, now you have a pickle on your hands. It doesn't matter if you genuinely didn't think it was suspicious at the time because it's not you who get to decide.
So complying with this requirement effectively means an unlimited investment into analysts and risk managers (detectives) who try and spot anything that might be suspicious, and enforce US foreign policy via sanctions.
Coinbase are doing this. But they have tens of millions of dollars in venture capital to spend, and even then, I expect them to get fined/prosecuted/both at some point, simply because it appears to be impossible to run a financial institution in the USA without that happening.
- Animats 12y agoIf you just send the transaction and customer data for every transaction over $2000 to FinCen, you're good. Now that they accept this as a data file (they were accepting paper until a few years ago), there's no problem doing that.
- mike_hearn 12y agoThat's not correct. You are expected to file SARs, but only for suspicious transactions (you have to specify why they are suspicious on the form). You can't just blindly upload every transaction to FinCEN and have discharged your responsibilities. The laws are much, much more complicated than that.