4 ms·
$4.5B Valuation for an SaaS business that doesn't charge for it's service and makes money from commissions? Did they invent something no one else can do? Why w
by sschueller 12y ago
$4.5B Valuation for an SaaS business that doesn't charge for it's service and makes money from commissions?
Did they invent something no one else can do? Why would insurance companies not just scrap the middle man and build their own thing?
- GFischer 12y agoI don't know about other insurance companies, but the ones I know are incredibly bad at building software (I don't know any in the healthcare or HR business though). Still, they're burning a very worrying amount of money.
- onion2k 12y agoZenefits are one of the few companies where the burn rate is probably inevitable. They're trying to get a secure foothold in a market that has slow-moving, largely technologically ignorant companies who are very wealthy. That wealth could be used to leverage the incumbent companies' dominant position if someone successfully starts to disrupt things. They need to get to a position where they can't be crowded out by the big players fast. That means spending a lot. Growing slowly isn't an option. Uber was the same. PayPal was the same. They were both so successful at it that the incumbents in their respective markets have just accepted the loss of market share without any return strategy. I imagine that's Zenefits aim too.
- jbob2000 12y agoUber and paypal had the advantage of offering a service that wasn't strictly specific to the USA. I can only use Zenefits in the states; the way HR works is totally different in Canada and Europe, much less India, China, etc.
- arthurcolle 12y agohey dude you're dead
- bsaul 12y agoI suppose for the same reason supermarket companies are different from food companies.
- javery 12y agoWhy would hardware companies not just build their own operating system?
- bsbechtel 12y agoLike Apple?
- prottmann 12y agoWhy apple then need foxconn ?
- myth_buster 12y agoIt's turtles all the way down.
- runako 12y ago> Why would insurance companies not just scrap the middle man and build their own thing? One of the benefits of an HR solution like Zenefits is that it lets you shop among and switch between insurance providers. A captive solution wouldn't be able to do this as well or as independently as a third-party company. Zenefits also helps companies with more than insurance, services which would presumably be less interesting for an insurance carrier to provide.
- boise 12y agoThis is also true of a PEO (e.g. Trinet). Yes, Zenefits has a gorgeous interface which feels much more modern and sleek than something like Trinet. The trade-off is that the healthcare benefits are inferior for a small company - because unlike a PEO, Zenefits is NOT pooling together tens of thousands of young, healthy employees across many companies and getting a good deal from insurance companies. Yes, as an employer, you don't play the hefty admin fee you pay Trinet - but you just don't have access to better plans for your employees. The other pain we've found is that at the end of the day Zenefits is simply a wrapper around third party services (healthcare insurance, payroll etc.). If everything is smooth sailing, there is no problem. the moment something goes wrong there's this super frustrating finger pointing session where you have to call Aetna directly, or Intuit Payroll and Zenefits blame each other, or no one wants to cop to a payroll tax filing error. If you have an employee waiting for some critical healthcare reimbursement, this he-said/she-said is the worst. Never had to deal with that with the one-stop-shop PEOs. Zenefits has great software but the customer service needs some catching up. Maybe this round of funding will do it.
- mblevin 12y agoI would argue that this is actually the fundamental innovation here - shifting of the cost from the employer to the employee. With Trinet, you get negotiated rates that are pretty fantastic - but all the employee sees is an outdated interface, and all the employer sees is the monthly overhead cost per employee draining their bank account. With Zenefits, the employee doesn't see that their health care actually costs more (the employer typically covers the same amount regardless), and the employer doesn't have that monthly fee. It's as compelling as it is accidentally insidious.
- Goronmon 12y agoDid they invent something no one else can do? Why would insurance companies not just scrap the middle man and build their own thing? I once worked for a company that built smaller products for insurance companies. No really big ones, but a decent representation of the market. We would put together an update for what was an internal application, and sometimes it would take 6-8 months or more for them to get around to deploying the new version to their users, assuming they didn't decide to just hold off for the next version for some reason or another. These companies are pretty absurd in how slowly they move with anything, especially anything technology related.
- jccodez 12y agoI think there are some big players who do daily if not weekly releases. I worked for one. It is all tenant shared and they push client specific changes on a regular basis.
- xasos 12y agoThey would probably have to build a product at least 2x better than Zenefit's current offerings to gain back market share. It looks like Zenefits is starting to be the way to do things as many smaller startups.
- BinaryIdiot 12y ago> Why would insurance companies not just scrap the middle man and build their own thing? Maybe I'm wrong (I'm a user of Zenefits but only from the employee side) but Zenefits seems to bring all of the disparate services (generic HR forms, payroll, insurance) together in a single place with flexible insurance coverage. If an insurance company did this I don't think they could offer as much unless they're going to branch services out. Plus this let's a company switch out insurance providers without changing services.
- jaredhansen 12y ago>$4.5B Valuation for an SaaS business that doesn't charge for it's service and makes money from commissions? In fairness, this is also a rough description of the business model of ebay (current market cap: 70.2B). Like Zenefits probably eventually will, ebay has added various bolt-on services, but its core business has always been, as far as I can tell, making commissions on transactions between others. See also: AirBnB. >Did they invent something no one else can do? Why would insurance companies not just scrap the middle man and build their own thing? It's not so much that the underlying technology is that mind blowing (it isn't, or at least, historically hasn't been). Indeed, I'm hoping they invest some reasonable chunk of this cash in improving ui/ux. But execution matters, and the mere fact that, like facebook, they didn't really "invent something no one else can do", doesn't mean they aren't creating a hell of a lot of value. I don't know Zenefits' market or business well enough to have any idea whether $4.5B is reasonable at their current stage, but it's not beyond the realm of possibility.
- blairanderson 12y agoNothing special. It's more a single service that handles all HR, which happens to make money from insurance commissions. Other companies should be doing this!
- cehrnrooth 12y agoCurrent valuation should be based on future revenue projections. If you assume a 10X multiple they'd need $450M ARR to justify $4.5B which implies growing 22.5X ($20M * 22.5 = $450M). Last report I saw pegged their number of customers at 10,000 which would mean a $2K average customer annual value. To get to $450M ARR they either need to grow to 225,000 customers or increase their average customer value (or a combination of both). According to the US census there's over 2M companies with more than 5 employees which means they need to capture about 10% of the market. Doesn't seem too unreasonable especially when you consider a company can stay with their platform even if they switch providers / plans every year (minimizing churn).