10 ms·
Lawyers threaten researcher over key-cloning bug in high-security lock
- wglb 12y agoUnclear on the concept: Moreover, IOActive's reverse engineering process required the use of skilled technicians, sophisticated lab equipment, and other costly resources not generally available to the public This works so long as attackers have no more resources than the average guy in the street.
- istvan__ 12y agoI am wondering how can you dodge this if you are a security researcher in the US.
- smoyer 12y agoPublish the fact that it can be done without publishing how to do it (yes, you have to be reputable). I think it's interesting that the lawyer focused on the fact that they depackaged the chip when the (in my mind) bigger vulnerabilities don't require that. I think it would be interesting to sue a company like CyberLock for false advertising ... "impossible to clone keys" is clearly false.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> Publish the fact that it can be done without publishing how to do it (yes, you have to be reputable). Chances are that just changes the lawsuits to defamation ones.
- gameshot911 12y agoTruth is an absolute defense to defamation.
- ceejayoz 12y agoExpensive lawyers and extended litigation are a non-absolute but often effective defense to truth.
- dmix 12y agoIndeed, if you do so you must word your blog post very carefully not to make any claims you can't fully back-up with a PoC. Such as being very specific about what versions/configurations are vulnerable.
- smoyer 12y agoWhich might just force you to show how you cloned the key in court ... if you can actually clone the key it's not defamation.
- ceejayoz 12y agoIt'll force you to hire expensive lawyers for all the pre-court maneuvering, which tends to be a good deterrent to any small agency or freelance consultant.
- rayiner 12y agoDefamation suits are rare in the U.S. because they're so hard to win.
- ceejayoz 12y agoYou don't have to win it to bankrupt the target with pre-court maneuverings.
- rayiner 12y agoAnd what "pre-court maneuverings" would that be?
- hluska 12y agoHere is a good starting point: https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp
- ceejayoz 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawsuit#Pre-trial http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawsuit#Pre-trial See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lawsuit_against_public_participation#United_States_2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lawsuit_against_publi... for a variety of examples of such suits.
- rayiner 12y agoThat procedure starts with the pleadings, which aren't "pre-court." They are the first step in a court proceeding.
- poizan42 12y agoDepending on you purpose you could publish it anonymously - just make damn sure it can't be traced back to you. It won't help you much if your goal is to built reputation or you want to be able to talk about it.
- matheist 12y agoSo, like level 2 of microcorruption?
- makomk 12y agoNot really. Despite the name and theme, Microcorruption was about the kinds of vulnerabilities that exist in desktop and server systems; actual embedded exploration is very different. Typically there's a site key sent from the lock to the key, which authenticates itself with a second site key - often all in plaintext, on the more insecure systems. So you just sniff the communications.
- jonathanmayer 12y ago(Background: I'm a computer security researcher and lawyer at Stanford.) When a security researcher gets threatened, there's a tendency to lambast the lawyers. I think that's unfortunate. It is, very often, the client that demands an aggressive response. A lawyer should counsel against, since nastygrams to researchers tend to summon negative attention. Not being a jerk is also a plus. That said, if a client insists--and they often do--the lawyers have little choice. Professional ethics generally require following the client's direction, and there isn't sufficient time to withdraw as counsel. So, for the most part: Don't blame the lawyers, blame the DMCA. It's the law that's broken.
- click170 12y agoThat's a fair argument for not blaming the lawyers. But I don't think that line of reasoning deflects blame away from the company demanding they pursue legal action.
- shaunol 12y agoIs it generally a lawyer's job to advise a client when a case may attract negative publicity? Do they even care?
- socceroos 12y agoI'm pretty sure that 'cha-ching' is mostly what matters. Hate to be cynical but..
- imglorp 12y agoIt's a motivator. Counsel gets paid much more to bring a suit than to smack sense into in its client.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoAt some point, does counsel have enough money to choose smacking instead of more pay?
- 12y ago
- meowface 12y agoWere these vulnerabilities disclosed to CyberLock at all before the results were published? If not, I can't blame them for being angry. Not saying they shouldn't be publicly disclosed in addition to private disclosure, but you have to give a company a fair chance to review the vulnerabilities and at least respond to you before you publish.
- AngrySkillzz 12y agoThey told the company at least a day beforehand: https://t.co/dnvq8F3Ad0 https://t.co/dnvq8F3Ad0
- Anechoic 12y agoFor anyone reluctant to click on a shortened URL, the full URL is https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-BwS8oOqrxSQ/VUgoAVekqjI/AAAAAAAABAQ/0HZNy6Ma9nQ/s0-d-ip/asshat0.png https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-BwS8oOqrxSQ/VUgoAVekqjI/A...
- themartorana 12y agoThat's a significantly short amount of time to be able to address an issue before knowledge of the vulnerability becomes public knowledge. I'm all for releasing a vulnerability after it a) is mitigated or b) becomes clear the responsible party has no plans to address the vulnerability in a timely fashion. One day is in no way responsible unless the researchers were told pointedly that there was no plan to address the issues. IMHO.
- masklinn 12y agoThey (claim they) gave the company 30 days, and assert they could have extended it if it seemed a fix was upcoming and a few more days were necessary, but they only ever got ignored or lawyer-threatened over it.
- Terr_ 12y agoIn a later PDF, the lawyer complains about IOActive wanting access to company engineers on "a few days notice". I really don't support people throwing around the DMCA, but if the company's lawyer's complaints are accurate (if) then IOActive sounds like they prioritized having a quasi-journalistic "scoop" over professionalism. https://plus.google.com/118103547235676487972/posts/Sot7Tp1CLGX?pid=6145192951509500834&oid=118103547235676487972 https://plus.google.com/118103547235676487972/posts/Sot7Tp1C...
- javajosh 12y agoIOActive's findings enable a very difficult but devastating man-in-the-middle attack against anyone buying or storing these locks. It's really hard to clone a key to these locks, but once that's done the lock can be reassembled, and the attacker can use the copy to open it. It's NOT like you can walk up to one with a thumb drive and pwn it.
- copsarebastards 12y agoIOActive's findings allow an attack where you can obtain one sample of the lock and gain the master key for the entire lock system. So you walk up to the unguarded bike shed, take your time chopping off the lock with a hacksaw, and now you have access to the storage area. Normally the guard would come around before you'd be able to cut off that lock, but since you now have a key it's much quicker, and you wouldn't look suspicious to the guard anyway.
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> The advisory went on to say that "site keys" are stored in unencrypted, "cleartext" form that can be recovered from the lock cylinders. Why do developers keep doing this? As a programmer, I've never worked with crypto implementation and I don't really know much about it on a practical level, but the one thing I do know is that you never store anything sensitive in plaintext. Ever! So how do so many devs who have, at the very least, spent far more time than I have Googling about crypto implementation, keep missing this? It's as if there was an epidemic of wet kitchen floors sweeping the nation because thousands of plumbers, working independently, all repeatedly forgot to install traps under their sinks. Why does this one rank-amateur mistake keep happening?
- madez 12y agoIf you knew how cars are made...
- swamp40 12y agoWhen you start decapping chips and hitting them with lasers, there are all sorts of "cleartext" data you will be able to obtain.
- hvidgaard 12y agoThat is true, but considering that this isn't your average website, but high security certified products there should have been security trained professionals working on the hardware, at the very least when they got the notice - they have no excuse.
- Pyxl101 12y agoI don't see how this is an amateur mistake. Presumably the key material on the device needs to be available to its onboard computer. So, the computer needs to load it or work with it. You could encrypt it, sure, but with what key? Another key stored locally in plaintext? Could you explain what alternative should be used in this case?
- poizan42 12y ago
- dzhiurgis 12y agoWouldn't it be easier to just cut off the lock and replace with fake imitation that accept any key?
- Sanddancer 12y agoThat'll just get you unrestricted access to that one area. This flaw lets you get the master key, and with that, you have unrestricted access to every locked room in the facility.
- swamp40 12y ago>> An IOActive spokesman said the company has no indication CyberLock will take any legal action. Well, IANAL, but I can pretty much guarantee they are going to get sued. As many people say, you only get one reputation, and you must defend it vigorously. And as many other people say, don't piss into the wind and expect not to get wet...
- tehwalrus 12y agoSlander/Libel, in the UK where this isn't, has to contain falsehoods. Can people in the US really sue each other for reputational damage even for saying only true things? If so, that is bizarre IMO.
- cbd1984 12y agoPeople can launch all kinds of suits which can't possibly result in victory. The courts won't try a case before they try it to see if the plaintiff would win.
- JupiterMoon 12y ago> Slander/Libel, in the UK where this isn't, has to contain falsehoods. Be careful this is a dangerous interpretation of UK law. Slander/Libel must contain some element that the person doing the saying/publishing cannot prove in court. Note the burden of proof lies on the person saying/writing rather than the person sueing. (I am not a lawyer and this post does not constitute legal advice.)
- tehwalrus 12y agosorry, yes, I am aware that the burden of proof is on the accused slanderer, since these are civil rather than criminal cases. I appreciate that that wasn't clear from my original comment.
- blueskin_ 12y ago>'Cyber' Literally laughed out loud. It's just become too much of a joke now.