6 ms·
I have loved all of the okcupid linkbait. Much of it conforms to the old wives tales or intuitions of people, but "The women who are subjectively rated the mos
by patio11 17y ago
I have loved all of the okcupid linkbait.
Much of it conforms to the old wives tales or intuitions of people, but "The women who are subjectively rated the most attractive get disproportionately less attention from men. No, really, we're not making it up, we can demonstrate this with SQL" is a whole lot more fascinating than the equivalent finding justified by, ahem, wild speculation. (Or its close cousin, "We surveyed 18 men and 22 women who happened to be enrolled in psych 101 at this campus! Sweet, sweet empiricism!")
- potatolicious 17y agoI too find statistical confirmation to be interesting, but even moreso is where OKCupid's data have contradicted common wisdom: - Women rate 80% of males as less than average looking. The graph is completely off-kilter from what you might expect (a pretty usual normal distribution around 50%-attractive) - The reply rate between sender/receiver attractive is also a really interesting social phenomenon. The unattractive recipient who gets a message from a very attractive member of the opposite sex is unlikely to respond. Self-esteem at work! I love this sort of statistical drivel (I mean that in the absolute nicest way), it certainly beats reading pop-psych books.
- patio11 17y agoTotal agreement. That's the beautiful thing about metrics. Anybody can convince you of what you already believe is true. The real value is when you can demonstrate that reality is different than what you think it is.
- alex_c 17y ago- Women rate 80% of males as less than average looking. The graph is completely off-kilter from what you might expect (a pretty usual normal distribution around 50%-attractive) This is very interesting. It's always been almost impossible to get my gf to point out other guys she finds attractive - this might point towards a reason, although it still doesn't really provide an explanation.
- potatolicious 17y agoI found this particular comment on the post to be poignant: "I love that both the males and females are completely delusional but on opposite ends of the spectrum."
- sheena 17y agoOr she doesn't want to wax eloquent about the attractiveness of other guys to her boyfriend?
- orangecat 17y agoWomen rate 80% of males as less than average looking. The graph is completely off-kilter from what you might expect It doesn't completely surprise me; it's always been my impression that the average female is more attractive to the average male than vice versa. Although I wouldn't have expected the difference to be so large. The unattractive recipient who gets a message from a very attractive member of the opposite sex is unlikely to respond. Self-esteem at work! And the effect is much stronger for males writing to females. I can believe that; an ugly guy who gets an email from a hot girl may suspect it's a setup, but is probably more willing to take the chance.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoThis would also explain why having multiple wives is much more common than having multiple husbands.
- vidarh 17y ago> It doesn't completely surprise me; it's always been my impression that the average female is more attractive to the average male than vice versa. Average looking != average attractive. If asking a woman about how attractive a man is based only on a photo you will get results like that because you've withheld most of the information she'd use to judge his attractiveness in person.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoDepends on the photo. If the photo shows him wearing his expensive watch and sitting in his expensive car, she has most of the information she needs.
- orangecat 17y agoMy anecdotal evidence is that women go for alpha-ness, not wealth. There's a strong correlation between the two, but it's quite possible to have one without the other. A pick-up artist with no money will attract women, while a well-paid but socially inept geek won't.
- ramchip 17y ago80% of males as less than average looking This could be partly due to the fact that especially good-looking men can find a mate easily, so they never get around to registering on a dating site. To the folks on HN it's probably a normal thing, but I believe dating sites still have a certain 'for losers' stigma in other social circles. And on the other side, perhaps girls that are very picky cannot find a guy to their liking so they end up on dating sites in greater numbers than the average.
- potatolicious 17y agoIf this is true - why isn't it also true in reverse? (i.e., good-looking women can find a mate just as easily, so would not be registered on a dating site).
- sgk284 17y agoBecause, with all do respect do my fellow men, most guys out there really are assholes... and unfortunately many social norms reinforce they're actions. I've spoken with quite a few females who hope to find someone who isn't an asshole through online services. To put it another way, what's the probability of a girl finding a quality guy at a bar versus finding a guy who just wants to take her to bed? I know a lot of girls who are sick of that game. As a result, you get a lot of guys who aren't attractive enough to pick up random chicks at bars and you get a lot of women who are sick of being picked up by the types of guys that make a sport out of picking up random chicks at bars. Those types of girls tend to be attractive. That's not to say that everyone in online dating services falls into one of these two buckets, but that is why you see such weird skews in the data.
- steveklabnik 17y agookcupid also has a higher than usual amount of people who are in open relationships or polyamorous, so there might be more better looking dudes than you'd expect.
- gaius 17y agoNo, that would have the opposite effect.
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoActually it's exactly what I would expect. Cue the "96% of the population is undateable" Seinfeld quote! Asking people to rate who's below average looking will generally result in the vast majority of people being rated as such. Yeah, statistically you'd expect around 50%, but once you throw human emotion into the mix all bets are off.
- bdr 17y agoOkCupid isn't a representative sample, either. Even more, you have to take into account the site mechanics: a mutual 4 or 5 star rating results in a "match event", but any other combination doesn't. So rating someone 1-3 is equivalent ("I don't want to talk to them") as is 4-5, and men and women's responses to this mechanic may influence their ratings in differing ways.
- jrockway 17y agoIndeed. 4 stars for a guy could mean "this person is average looking, but I think I might get to fuck them" rather than "this person is in the top 80% of beauty".
- silentOpen 17y ago"... top 40% of beauty."
- wgj 17y agoNo, it's only a 5 point scale.
- silentOpen 17y ago1: bottom 20%; 2: 20% - 40%; 3: 40% - 60%; 4: 60% - 80%; 5: top 20% Am I missing something?
- jim-greer 17y ago
- jmhodges 17y agoFor those who were confused by the contradiction of this comment and the actual post, it looks like "less attention from men" was probably supposed to be "more attention from men". For instance: "So basically, guys are fighting each other 2-for-1 for the absolute best-rated females, while plenty of potentially charming, even cute, girls go unwritten." (And it's doubly confusing because patio11 refers to it as an "old wive's tale".)
- throw_away 17y agoHe's talking about the dip at the extreme right of the messaging graph. The old wives' tale refers to the observation that some women on the extremely beautiful end of the scale aren't approached by very many men because they're perceived as "too" beautiful.
- barrkel 17y agoExcept that that statement is not true. They may not be approached by numbers proportionate to their beauty relative to the population, but they are still more approached than any less beautiful. Approaching extra-beautiful women in person, on the other hand, can be intimidating.
- throw_away 17y agoThe okcupid data and your last sentence contradict your first paragraph. I was over-reaching when I said "not approached by very many men", but okcupid's data implies that there exist women A and B such that beauty(A) > beauty(B) AND suitors(A) < suitors(B). This probably seems unfair to woman A, that her less attractive friend B attracts more men, due to the fact that men find A intimidating. But the fact remains that beauty and suitor count appear to be non-linear at the high-end of the scale. That said, woman A and woman B are both probably approached by more men than a majority of other women, but their relative success is non-intuitive.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- m0th87 17y agoI don't think the data indicates that at all. According to the graph, ~6% of women are considered very attractive (5) and receive ~18% of the messages. ~15% of the women are considered pretty attractive (4) and receive ~28% of the messages. That means the population considered pretty attractive is 3 times larger, but only gets ~1.5x as many messages. Thus, those considered very attractive do indeed get more messages than those considered pretty attractive. The graph is somewhat misleading in its portrayal, but I think if it did indicate your suspicions, the author would've surely said something about it.