6 ms·
Surprised does not come close - the list of deeply connected investors is long (AndresseenHorowitz, GoogleVentures) and yet the phrase "MoneyServiceBusiness" di
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
Surprised does not come close - the list of deeply connected investors is long (AndresseenHorowitz, GoogleVentures) and yet the phrase "MoneyServiceBusiness" did not cross anyone's mind?
Is this CEO ignoring good advice or fire and forget investors ? Or perhaps even more worryingly, a disconnect between Silicon Valley investors and the FinTech regulators in the East Coast - those three thousand miles will take a lot of bridging.
A bit of history on this ruling will be interesting.
- wmf 12y agoWe are now in a "post-Uber" world where regulatory arbitrage is considered just another business strategy.
- rizwank 12y agoYou make it sound like it wasn't a standard Business practice before Uber.
- reviseddamage 12y agoits a dangerous position, if people start to find courage from Uber...You don't go to jail for decades for exercising regulatory arbitrage when taking paid rides in your car.
- cms07 12y agoToo bad people aren't going to jail for openly flouting regulations. That would probably stop a lot of it.
- rtpg 12y agoI don't think throwing people in jail accomplishes much of anything. The US has enough control over the banking system to just shut down companies if they misbehave enough, and freeze/reclaim assets if the company was "willfully negligent"
- dmichulke 12y agoAssuming that for all regulations the regulator is the good guy you're totally right. But these days there are people who'd disagree with that assumption.
- Frondo 12y agoThen the place to discuss that is in the political arena. Violating regulations because you think the regulations stink, the regulators are wrong, they shouldn't apply to you, whatever, is wrong. We probably all agree here that dumping mad pollution into the air is a bad thing, and that regulation should be obeyed, but all it takes is one factory owner deciding that that regulation sucks, and the air's unbreathable again.
- fleitz 12y agoWrong is a question of morality/ethics, however it most certainly is illegal.
- Natanael_L 12y agoDepends entirely on the effect of the regulations. You could describe the divisive racism laws of the past in USA as regulations, wouldn't it be better to break them anyway? Do no harm, law or not.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoStill, if you break a law, you should face consequences, whether you're doing right or wrong. That's the point of civil disobedience - willing to accept the punishment for going with your conscience. Then there's a difference between breaking the law out for moral reasons and breaking them because they're inconvenient and you could profit more by ignoring them.
- dmichulke 12y agoAbout "profit by ignoring them": - Is food profit? - When I'm hungry -is food profit? - When my family is hungry and I don't pay taxes in order to buy food today - is it profit? - What if I don't pay taxes in order to send my kid to a school? - What if I don't pay taxes in order to send my kid to a good school? - What if I collect taxes from people who could otherwise send their kids to school? There are a million possible definitions of profit and I bet that to each of them I can invent a scenario where it's simply unjust.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoStartups start to run out of things to "disrupt", so they're now starting to disrupt the very fabric of society itself. What could possibly go wrong.
- danuker 12y agoYou mean state, not society.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNo, I mean what I wrote. Laws are coordination mechanisms and exist for a reason. Good or bad, they're needed or the community destabilizes as bad actors start to abuse the rest. Not every law is good and while there are mechanisms to realign them with the needs of a community, ignoring the law just because you can get more profit by doing so is not a way to go, it's a fraud and a malicious action towards your community. Doubly so if you're such an asshole about it as Uber is.
- mike_hearn 12y agoWhy are bad laws needed? Surely that's the problem. And what mechanisms for "realignment" do you have in mind? The relevant money transmitter laws in the USA take at minimum several years and millions of dollars to comply with, without any really good reason. The evidence that they achieve anything is minimal (try finding good academic studies of this - it's an exercise in frustration). There is NO way to reform them because the laws are highly open to interpretation, and the regulators who apply them freely admit that they pretty much do whatever they want with applicants: http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/178_151/how-california-law-put-a-hot-payments-innovator-on-ice-1061147-1.html?pg=2 http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/178_151/how-california-... US money transmitter laws have created a kind of death spiral where regulators see startups as dangerous (they explicitly say that in the article), make it difficult for them to get licenses, and so the entire market ends up owned by stagnant incumbents. There is then nobody left to lobby for changes to the laws, and big entrenched interests who don't want competition, thus it's impossible to get reform.
- samstave 12y ago"Oh look! Archaic municiple rules is attempting to block us! This must mean we are disrupting them, and the fact we have users shows that all these evil municipal rules should be ignored!" --- AirBnB, Uber, Ripple, etc....
- Animats 12y agoUber has already been shut down in France, Germany, South Korea, India, Spain, Nevada, South Carolina, Florida, and Kansas. California will require Uber to get commercial insurance, and probably commercial plates, effective July 1. Uber in New York City was forced to comply with NYC's regular taxi and limousine rules. Uber's "we're just a data service" claim did not work for them. They're just another car service now, better organized than most.
- wmf 12y agoBut they got to a $40B valuation or whatever. I see a very similar thing in the Bitcoin world. Build something, ignore all regulations, get VC, get big, then write your own regulations that advantage you relative to "legacy" businesses.
- robwilliams 12y agoIt doesn't sound like Uber is "writing their own regulations" in the above examples...
- Animats 12y ago"But they got to a $40B valuation or whatever." One analyst makes a good argument for a $3.2 billion valuation for Uber.[1] [1] http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/uber-isnt-worth-17-billion/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/uber-isnt-worth-17-billi... "I see a very similar thing in the Bitcoin world. Build something, ignore all regulations, get VC, get big, then write your own regulations that advantage you relative to "legacy" businesses." Bitcoin business strategies run more to "take the money and run". Running a honest exchange isn't very profitable, because you're in competition with no-fee crooks. Coinbase doesn't charge merchants until they do at least $1M in business, and few merchants have reached that level. NewEgg and Overstock reported that their Bitcoin business was much lower than expected, and have backed off on promoting Bitcoin.
- unclesaamm 12y agoOf regulators though, FinCen has more presence than most on the West Coast. It's not a foreign concept, especially once you realize how Visa et al. are headquarted in SF as well.
- tomasien 12y agoIt crossed their mind quite a bit. Constant topic of conversation - the implication here that it's "easy" to file as an MSB is ridiculous. It's easy to file, harder to "be".
- ethanbond 12y agoIs this distinct from a money transmitter? I know transmitters must be registered in each state that a user might originate from, and each registration costs around $50,000.
- Animats 12y agoYes, it's distinct. FinCen is only about money laundering. Money transfer licensing is about the money transfer firm not stealing your money. California is particularly strict about this, because so many people in California are sending money home to Mexico, and there have been some bad actors. If any of these Bitcoin operators were serious, they'd register with the SEC as broker/dealers and as exchanges. That covers the whole US; no need to deal with individual states. Every stock broker does this. Customers then get investor protection - SIPC insurance up to $500,000 if the broker goes bust. That works quite well. Even Madoff's investors got everything back up to $500K, and slowly, the SIPC has clawed money back from the "winners" of Madoff's Ponzi, Overall, Madoff investors now have about 50% of their money back. Investor protection doesn't mean you can't lose money through investment risk, but it means that you're protected from theft by the broker, for both cash and securities held by the broker. So why don't Bitcoin startups do that? 1) The broker has to pass background checks (Roger Ver has a criminal conviction and would fail.) 2) There are financial strength requirements (if you're handling millions of other people's money, you need to have a few yourself). 3) There are detailed accounting, audit, and reporting requirements. 4) FINRA can fine brokers for violating the rules for brokers. About once a day, FINRA takes disciplinary action against some broker. 5) There are exams to work in a brokerage. Individual brokers must pass the FINRA Series 7 set of exams. There are exams for top management, for inside auditors, and even for customer service reps. (Customer service reps have to know what they are and are not allowed to do.) 6) Segregation of customer funds from brokerage funds is required. (MF Global didn't do that and went bust. The case against their CEO is still in discovery and he may yet go to jail.) Until Bitcoin startups start doing this, it's still amateur hour.