3 ms·
I am surprised how nobody here seems to have drawn the obvious conclusion here which is these changes (making the test less g loaded) is a massive bias in favou
by danieltillett 12y ago
I am surprised how nobody here seems to have drawn the obvious conclusion here which is these changes (making the test less g loaded) is a massive bias in favour of the rich over the poor. Kids who are naturally smart, but who attend bad schools will struggle with any test that is not heavily g loaded.
- gwern 12y agoRich/poor is itself heavily g-loaded. What's the net effect here?
- danieltillett 12y agoIt is not that rich/poor is directly g loaded, just that g is highly correlated with income. Quality of schooling is directly related to the income. The more you make the tests reflect past education quality the more you bias it is favour of the rich and dumb against the poor and smart.
- gwern 12y ago> It is not that rich/poor is directly g loaded, just that g is highly correlated with income. What's the difference? We say an item is g-loaded when it correlates with the latent factor g; this is true whether it's an obscure vocab word on the SAT or whether it's not blowing your income and planning ahead.
- danieltillett 12y agoI was trying to make point that one of the major reasons income is so g loaded is that education allows the poor-but-smart to rise out of their poverty (and vice versa) via things like the old SAT. Block this and you end up with something like the Middle Ages where the nobility and peasants had the same mean g. I should say that changes like this are going to have most effect in the middle rather than the extremes. If you are born with a g in the 99.9 percentile band then you will still be likely to escape poverty. It is people born with a g say in the 80th percentile band that will be affected the most by these changes.