4 ms·
I believe the distinction suggested is not real vs imaginary, but real vs constructed. I think it's a reasonable point. One of the useful tests for "realness"
by wpietri 12y ago
I believe the distinction suggested is not real vs imaginary, but real vs constructed.
I think it's a reasonable point. One of the useful tests for "realness" is what lasts, what is sustained without human effort. Artificial environments are in some sense a fantasy made real. Sufficiently advanced technologies are indistinguishable from magic because we are always trying to construct our dreams.
Our civilization is in many ways a collective fiction. The clearest example is money, which works only as long as we believe. But there are plenty of other essentially imaginary underpinnings to our constructed world. For example, the US's national ethos, the American Dream: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Dream http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Dream
- solipsism 12y agoOne of the useful tests for "realness" is what lasts What? This ismeaningless, and obviously false if you just think about it for one second. Please see my reply to tsunamifury above.
- wpietri 12y agoIf you had said, "I don't understand this point, could you say more" I would have happily answered. But instead you give a lot of drama in reply, which makes me think there isn't much point in taking the time. But suffice it to say I thought about it for more than one second in writing it, and did so again just now. I still believe it to have meaning.
- charlysisto 12y agoAbsolutely my point, and the notion of collective fiction and how it structures communities through faith, money, democracy and what not, is very dear to me. If you look at how we speak of "the markets" today (the markets are confident, the markets are happy, the markets are scared, the market is always right) it is very close to how ancient greeks would mention their gods... speaking of greeks the gods aren't happy with them... time to kill some goats... But my main point was the widening divide between our artificial environment and our biological one, the raising concerns that the first is destroying the latter and what we can do about it! I think turning your back to civilization with the notion that it's all an illusion is a dangerous misconception.