7 ms·
How the Languages in Game of Thrones, Defiance, and Thor Were Created
- knodi123 12y agoTolkien could probably have given a very similar interview. He created an ancient proto-elven language called quenya, and a modern elvish language evolved from it called sindarin. He created the language with specific goals in mind, working on it over his whole career, and the Lord of the Rings came into existence as a result, in the same way that a really nice hat rack tends to naturally accumulate hats. https://www.academia.edu/4901880/Elvish_Linguistics_The_Science_of_Sindarin https://www.academia.edu/4901880/Elvish_Linguistics_The_Scie...
- chc 12y agoHe also created the Black Speech with the goal of making an ugly and harsh language, but apparently never got that far with it because he found it unpleasant.
- jordigh 12y agoIt really bugs me that people consider some languages ugly or harsh. It seems like an extension of xenophobia and racism.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoIt might be. But then again, at least in the U.S., many of the languages we consider 'ugly' sounding are not spoken by people that we (presently) exhibit a lot of negative biases towards. (Obviously I'm thinking of German here.) It seems perfectly plausible to me that, just as there are unpleasant non-linguistic sounds, there could be languages that produce a greater number of unpleasant sounds in typical speech, to a person from any cultural background. Think: nails on a chalkboard. (I'm tempted to call these "objectively ugly" sounds, but of course having a social cause does not make something subjective.) Of course, this is not to say that racism, or xenophobia are never the causes of these judgments. And, more subtly, some of our views about what sounds are 'ugly' may also be socially constructed, at least in part. And these views could relate to longstanding racial biases, among other factors. tl;dr: Probably some of these judgments are facially racist, and others are caused by genuine assessments of the ugliness of sounds, but those judgments themselves may have social causes that include racist and xenophobic dynamics. But others still may well relate to perceptions that are hardwired, and not socially constructed. All this complexity makes me hesitate before signing on to your view, though I do sometimes lean in that direction.
- muaddirac 12y agoI always think that people dislike the sound of German because of its media representation. When it's only ever spoken like the political leaders in Triumph of the Will, it's understandably unpleasant. But I find spoken German quite beautiful (so much so I studied it throughout college). A good example of nicely spoken German is "Die Bombe die Nicht Tickt" (a reading of a short story by a German band whose name eludes me). Also the main character in Goodbye Lenin.
- jordigh 12y agoWell, it bugs me because can native speakers really believe their own language to be ugly? Has a German ever said, "how ugly German is, if only I were born speaking something beautiful like Italian?" If native speakers don't believe their own languages to be ugly, then it certainly seems like a xenophobic belief.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoThat's an interesting point. As a native speaker of English, there certainly are phrases that strike me as ugly, but usually it takes some reflection to see the ugliness. This makes me think that one's failure to see the ugliness in one's own language is just a result of being used to the way it sounds, ugly or not. (By the way: yes, I actually have heard people say that they wished that they spoke another language because it sounds nicer than theirs. English speakers say this about French all the time -- though, as always, it's hard to say whether this is because French "really is" [whatever that means] prettier sounding, or due to cultural factors. I've also heard a native speaker of Korean say she wished she was an English speaker instead, because English is nicer sounding. This is just another anecdote, though. Who knows a person's real reason for saying such a thing. That's why this whole paragraph is, I now realize, in parentheses.)
- jordigh 12y agoOne more thing: painting a language as ugly is a very broad thing to do. Is 99 Luftballons an ugly song because it's in German? Are Mussolini's speeches beautiful because they're in Italian? In the original case of the orcs' Black Speech in Tolkein, they were a race incapable of saying anything pretty because of their language. These are the broad fantastical racism undertones that really bug me about Tolkein's mythology, and they mirror a real undercurrent in people's modes of thought.
- irishcoffee 12y agoWhy? French and Italian [0] are considered romance languages, because among other things they sound pretty. Russian [1] (and I suppose most Slavic languages) just don't generally sound pretty. For what its worth, I speak Russian; not terribly well, but I speak it. Russian really isn't a language that sounds "pretty" or "silky", or whichever adjective you'd prefer. The reason I decided to respond to you comment was a little more abstract than that though. People liking or disliking things about other kinds of people isn't racist. Some people just don't like things. I don't like black licorice (no idea who invented it, but I don't like it). I don't particularly care for traditional German food (I'll eat it, its just not my go to for food), and I don't think I'd ever wear a kilt to a wedding (I'm mostly Irish, then Italian, then Native American). I don't think those things make me racist or xenophobic. At least, I don't think less of anyone who prefers any of those things. I just don't like them for me. I think if we start claiming that not liking something like a language is racist, we're on a slippery slope indeed. For example, I don't like the color red. I don't like traditional Mexican music. Do either one of those things make me racist? I'm not trying to attack by any means, I'm sincerely curious. [0] http://www.orbilat.com/General_Survey/List_of_Romance_Languages.html http://www.orbilat.com/General_Survey/List_of_Romance_Langua... [1] http://www.russiaslam.com/2012/stories/the-russian-language-what-does-it-sounds-like.html http://www.russiaslam.com/2012/stories/the-russian-language-...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> French and Italian [0] are considered romance languages, because among other things they sound pretty. No, they (along with Spanish and others) are considered "romance languages" because they descend from Vulgar Latin, the language of the common Romans of the late Imperial period. [0] Has nothing to do with sounding pretty. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romance_languages#Origins http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romance_languages#Origins and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romance_languages#Name http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romance_languages#Name
- irishcoffee 12y agoNo comment to the rest of it?
- chc 12y agoI'm not so sure. I don't think most people are racist against Klingons, but Klingon still tends to sound harsh — again, because it was designed that way (for example, it leans heavily on stops and affricates and tends to be produced in the back of the mouth). On the other hand, a lot of Americans exhibited a strange antipathy towards the French over the past decade, but it was never considered an ugly language.
- samstave 12y agoPersonal meaningless anecdote: When I was ~11 or so and I was really into DnD - I used to exclusively create elven characters. I would spend HOURS dreaming up elvish names for them and I almost always included the 'que' in their name. I had read LoTR, and I think this might have been subconscious.
- benanne 12y agoFor those interested in constructed languages, I recommend checking out Mark Rosenfelder's website http://zompist.com/ http://zompist.com/. His Language Construction Kit in particular is a great resource: http://zompist.com/kit.html http://zompist.com/kit.html
- eykanal 12y agoI came here to recommend this exact book. I bought it on a whim and it's a fantastic read. Even if you never plan on actually making a language, it's fascinating to understand what goes into creating a complete language, from phenomes to words to phrases to a complete grammar.
- benanne 12y agoA couple of years ago there was no book version of the LCK, but a very popular book on the zompist bulletin board was "Describing Morphosyntax: A Guide for Field Linguists", by Thomas E. Payne. It's essentially an overview of all the weird morphological and syntactical features that the various languages of the world exhibit, so it can function as a great source of inspiration for conlangers as well.
- jessaustin 12y agoThat site is a time capsule: the hilariously out-of-date "EZ Home Test", the complaints about "Bob and Newt", a review of Snow Crash, references to various events that were current in the mid-90s. It's good that languages don't change very fast...
- cositarica 12y agowhat a bunch of crap
- johnchristopher 12y agoI highly recommend Carter's biography of Tolkien. I read it in my teens and thought everybody (and especially Tolkien fans) knew Tolkien started working on many of his fictional languages many years before and that both the languages and the stories evolved together.
- jinushaun 12y agoI love constructed languages. A great example of languages evolving to new technology is "internet". Composed of "inter" (Latin), "net" (English) and "work" (English). You have a culture (English) with an external influence (Latin), that sees a grouping of connected computers and decides to compare it to a fishing net. Network describes the topology, not the function. We see that we need a society that has invented fishing nets to even describe the Internet. But a different society might've called it something else. For example, the Internet is often called a web, much like a spiderweb, which also looks like a net. You can't just invent an alien language for a technologically-advanced society without thinking about how they got there.
- cousin_it 12y agoAlso, nets trap fishes, webs trap flies, and the internet traps people :-)
- Digit-Al 12y agoHa ha. Love it.
- yongjik 12y ago(Off-topic rant alert) ...And there are people who just decide they need to (and are qualified to) make new words for new technology, and make a total botch out of it. Case in point: Some Koreans decided to make "pure Korean" word for website. Nothing wrong with that in itself. But then they looked at "world wide web", and also looked at "homepage", and decided that "world" and "home" patched together makes perfect sense as a website. So was invented the word nurijip, from "nuri" (an archaic word for "world") and "jip" (house). A Korean website is thus a "world-house". WTF is it supposed to mean? Makes me twitch every time I hear it.
- viewer5 12y agoHow much do people use that new word, instead of whatever they were using before?
- panglott 12y agoI'd also recommend DJP's interview about Dothraki on the Conlangery podcast (the last half of the show, starting about 55'00"): http://conlangery.com/2012/06/25/conlangery-56-growing-a-lexicon/ http://conlangery.com/2012/06/25/conlangery-56-growing-a-lex... DJP has stuff up at dedalvs.com , dothraki.conlang.org , dedalvs.tumblr.com , twitter.com/Dedalvs, &c. &c.
- kriro 12y agoI remember the conlanging talk from Sai at one of the CCCs. Really awesome stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEKcsto7Mjk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEKcsto7Mjk
- benanne 12y agoThis is great, thanks for sharing!
- chc2149 12y agoFor all those interested, David J Peterson actually has a book coming out in September this year on how to go about constructing your own language. Loads of great resources can be found on http://conlang.org http://conlang.org, and http://dedalvs.conlang.org/ http://dedalvs.conlang.org/ (DJP's own conlang website) as well!
- e1ven 12y agoDo you know the title of the book? I looked around briefly on his site, but didn't see it. Is the idea similar to Zompist's Language Construction Kit?
- chc2149 12y agoHere it is for pre-order! http://www.amazon.com/Art-Language-Invention-Horse-Lords-World-Building/dp/0143126466/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1430935808&sr=8-2&keywords=david+j+peterson http://www.amazon.com/Art-Language-Invention-Horse-Lords-Wor... He told me it covered the essentials of language construction as far as his methodology goes, but I think it offers some insight into the development of other major and not-so-well-known conlangs as well.
- CrystalGamma 12y agoI tried to do some conlanging in my school days, but I always hit the word invention bottleneck. So I tried writing scripts to automate that. Turns out making randomized phonemes sound good was too hard for me (probably still is, haven't tried in a while). Kinda sad, really.
- meric 12y agoIt's not sad. You had fun. :)
- jordigh 12y ago> di- or tri- continental root Is that a transcription error? Surely "consonantal root", right?
- benanne 12y agoI think so.
- billforsternz 12y agoOn Game of Thrones we accept for convenience's sake that the dominant on-screen culture speak English, despite this being, you know, an alien world. That's cheating on a huge scale if you think about it a little, so why not extend the cheating a little and re-use Lithuanian (say) or some other natural language as a proxy for Dothraki rather than going to all the trouble of inventing a whole new freaking language.
- shasta 12y ago"Make the world feel big" is rule number 5 or 6. "Your audience is lazy" is rule number 2 or 3.
- mdcox 12y agoHistorical Baggage. If someone starts speaking Russian, we've got a whole cultural idea of what it means for them to be speaking that language. I expect they wouldn't want to tint character personalities with biases from reality.
- billforsternz 12y agoWhich is why you wouldn't pick Russian. You need something more obscure and exotic sounding, that the vast majority of the audience wouldn't recognize. There are a lot of such languages. Possibly Lithuanian was too conservative. Basque anyone? For Dothraki you really just need something really alien sounding. Early in Game of Thrones when Khaleesi (sp?) hooked up with the Dothraki warrior guy ("you are my moon" etc.) I would infuriate the office GoT geek by my inability to remember any of the names in general, and my humorous (to me) habit of referring to said warrior as "the Klingon dude" in particular. To me if he looks like a Klingon and sounds like a Klingon...
- benanne 12y agoUnlike Tolkien, George R.R. Martin never created full-fledged languages for his books, but he did make up a bunch of words. I guess they didn't want to replace those with different words from other real-world languages. One of the challenges for David Peterson was to 'retrofit' the languages he created to what Martin had already made up. He coined a bunch of words and phrases for the books, and those needed to make sense and be grammatically correct in the newly created languages. The phrase "valar morghulis", meaning "all men must die" in High Valyrian is a nice example. Peterson made the -ar suffix indicate the collective number. This is expressed by 'all' in English, but in many languages this is a separate number from singular and plural. He also added a paucal number (meaning "a few"). vala (man), vali (men), valun (a few men), valar (all men).