2 ms·
Seems like we've moved from calling out companies for long standing bad practises to some kind of tribal behaviour where people are almost looking for a reason
by Someone1234 12y ago
Seems like we've moved from calling out companies for long standing bad practises to some kind of tribal behaviour where people are almost looking for a reason to call a company out for "bad security."
Let me be clear: Phone passwords are superior to phone pins, phone secret question/answers are superior to both, and the agent needs to be able to verify the secret question/answer set, and also the password. You CAN design it so the agent cannot see the whole password, but that means the agent cannot use common sense to account for differences in spelling, or interpretation e.g. "to" as 2, to, two, and too (plus "the third digit of your password" is hard for humans, we aren't designed that way).
People saying things like: "an agent cannot be trusted!" Are missing the point, that the entire system is built on agent trust. When you call you're purposely giving this agent access to your account, making the password useless, there's no proof they logged off when you hang up, there's also no proof that they aren't writing down your responses and will then relay it to another agent later.
A lot of people who whine about plain text in particular don't really seem to understand what it is that hashing even does. They seem to think things like: "if you get hacked, someone cannot steal passwords" (nope) or "then someone cannot sniff your password over free wifi" (nope). All hashing does is add time between the hack, and when the hacker can start using the stolen credentials, that's it. It is there to give the company time to detect the leak and to notify/reset, if the company fails to detect then it has done absolutely nothing of worth.
To be honest I find "HTTP offenders" (e.g. HTTP web-sites that redirect to HTTPS login forms, essentially breaking HTTPS's MitM protections) far worse than "plain text offenders." But none of this has anything to do with calling out security issues at this point. A bunch of people who don't seem to understand the technicals here feel like they're doing "good" by calling out companies for things that don't even make sense.