3 ms·
Why the hell is this case still going? Put these guys in jail and take away all their money already!
by chris_wot 12y ago
Why the hell is this case still going? Put these guys in jail and take away all their money already!
- anseljh 12y agoThe gears of the judiciary grind slowly, but grind they do. They're grinding these Prenda guys down to their component atoms. That can take a while.
- chris_wot 12y agoAnd in the meantime, it slows up the system for everyone else. The grinding can go both ways you know.
- untothebreach 12y agothe system is "slow" by design. The ability to appeal means that a potentially wrongly-accused person has a second chance for justice. I'm not saying it's not frustrating; I am definitely frustrated with it at times as well. But this part of the system, at least, is attempting to maximize "justice" (at the very least, to counteract the parts of the system that do not attempt it)
- anseljh 12y agoThis is why there are turtles at the base of the columns at the Supreme Court. https://www.flickr.com/photos/morgonmae/2437913438 https://www.flickr.com/photos/morgonmae/2437913438
- narrator 12y agoWhat's interesting about the civil litigation system is that it is used to dealing with sociopaths and narcissists. After all, they are the ones most likely to wind up in civil litigation. Most people can be deceived by a sociopath's slick manipulations and lies because they naively believe that all people are generally good. Judges in the civil litigation arena are under no such illusions.
- Sacho 12y agoIf the case would just "stop", they wouldn't go to jail - all Judge Wright imposed were monetary sanctions(he only threatened incarceration). Furthermore, the monetary sanctions aren't even that big(compared to the claims of the money they made). But specifically to answer your question, the reason is that there's an appellate system. And unless you want to argue that the appellate system shouldn't exist, "bad guys" get to use it to argue their case, just like "good guys". Furthermore, as Pietz points out in his oral argument, Judge Wright was exasperated at how much the justice system constrains punishing bad actors abusing the system. This is a core issue, and it's not as easily solved as waving a wand around.
- venomsnake 12y agoDo we have supreme court worthy case on our hands?
- Someone1234 12y agoI highly doubt it. They could try to appeal when they lose this case, but I highly doubt any higher court is going to pick it up as it doesn't really deal with any new matters of law.
- bradleyjg 12y agoWhat I want to know is where are the state bar associations in all of this. I seem to recall several referrals from federal judges, which are generally treated with some dispatch. The fact that they are still being allowed to operate (albeit now using the ADA to extort rather than the copyright law) is a travesty. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150104/12002529596/john-steele-looking-to-join-former-prenda-lawyer-paul-hansmeier-ada-lawsuit-shakedown-business.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150104/12002529596/john-...