5 ms·
When I see programmers add useless things that do nothing I wonder about their level of knowledge. Do they know it does nothing and are adding it for looks? Or
by ars 12y ago
When I see programmers add useless things that do nothing I wonder about their level of knowledge. Do they know it does nothing and are adding it for looks? Or are they poor programmers who can only program by copy paste?
Some things are obviously looks (useful looks, but still not required) - indents in C, or semi-colon in Javascript.
Other things are not. You say that the slash is just for the look, but since that's a rare position, I would advise not doing that - it makes you look bad to other programmers. Especially because unlike my other examples the slash has no useful purpose at all.
- aorloff 12y agoOr, are they programmers who have been burned by the arcane few instances where the absence of those relics can still bite you ? (as yet a third, very small distinct class)
- sirrocco 12y agoReally? Is that what you judge a programmer by? I might be annoyed if I see something like what you're talking about, but I'll just point it out and forget about it. PS: I too am from the XHTML era :)
- ars 12y ago> Really? Is that what you judge a programmer by? If all I have is the HTML source code to go by, then yes, that's one of the things. If I see useless self-closing tags then that starts them at a lower caliber of programmer, and the rest of the code better be really good to raise them back up. This is because I assume that if they are closing the tags they never bothered to learn html properly, and are just copying online tutorials. Sure, not are all like that, but in absence of other information, I have to use what's in front of me. > PS: I too am from the XHTML era :) It's time to stop. People who learned Javascript 20 years ago also had to eventually learn to stop wrapping the scripts in HTML comments. Things change.
- EpicEng 12y agoThe fact that you think semicolons in js are "for looks only" says a lot, and this is from someone who simply doesn't write js, but knows enough to know that it can bite you. And if you think white space in C is unnecessary then, well, you've never worked on a non-trivial C code base. You know what, to me, is a telltale sign that someone isn't as good as they think they are? They make snap judgements about a person based upon perceived code quality. That tells me that you're in that dangerous "advanced beginner who thinks s/he knows everything" stage.
- ars 12y agoI didn't say any of those things. You simply misread what I said. I said they (semi-colons, white space) were not required, but had a useful purpose (i.e. you should use them). Unlike self closing tags which are not required, but additionally serve no purpose whatsoever (i.e. why are you using them?) I'm not judging a person, I'm judging their ability to program. If you use a feature that does nothing at all it tells me you don't understand the item at hand, you are just copying from other places. Or that you have not updated your knowledge from when those things had a purpose. Either one of those is not a sign of a good programmer.
- marktangotango 12y ago>> Either one of those is not a sign of a good programmer. Yes I've encountered your type before. I take great delight in watching you fail. What you're saying is completely arbitrary, yet you hold the opinion dearly. That's the thing when you're a dick, people don't help you, and they love to see you fail. Life IS easier if you're kind to others.
- escape_goat 12y ago>> Life IS easier if you're kind to others. The inference one draws from this is that one should not take delight in watching others fail.
- Swizec 12y ago> semi-colon in Javascript. Nitpick, but that is required. The heuristic that places it for you is meant as an aide if you accidentally forget to add it. And it's not always right. Linters will also flag your code when you don't include semicolons. As for <br> vs. <br/>. I personally prefer <br/> because of consistency. Just like I'd write <img .. />, <link .. /> and so on.
- ars 12y agoYou should not write <img /> or <link /> either - so yes consistency, just not in the way you said. And the one tag that has to be closed with no content: <script type=".." src=".."></script> can't be self closed anyway. Self closing tags have no place in HTML.
- cardiffspaceman 12y agoThe HTML5 spec has two things: an XML serialization specification, and a detailed non-XML parsing specification that makes the parser safely accept the evil slash on void elements like BR and IMG. Bonus: it also accepts the alternate spelling of the name of the IMG element. A style guide, of course, could ban using IMAGE as the name of the IMG element or any other infelicity, whether it is legal or merely tolerated.
- userbinator 12y agothe alternate spelling of the name of the IMG element I remember that jumped out at me when I read the HTML5 parsing spec, and I had no success whatsoever finding more information about it (try Googling "<image>"); do you have any links on how it came into existence? Or even better, a site that actually does this?
- fhars 12y agoIt is right there in the spec: <dt>A start tag whose tag name is "image"</dt> <dd> <!-- As of 2005-12, studies showed that around 0.2% of pages used the <image> element. --> <p><a href="#parse-error">Parse error</a>. Change the token's tag name to "img" and reprocess it. (Don't ask.)</p> </dd>
- lmm 12y agoI self-close out of XML habit. I think you're detecting nothing more than which programmers have written more XML than HTML. If anything I'd think the kind of programmer who likes to close every tag would be better at e.g. always freeing resources correctly.