3 ms·
However, biology is chock full of exception cases. The 'Central Dogma' of DNA -> RNA -> Proteins is still largely true for most cases. However, we discover all
by Balgair 12y ago
However, biology is chock full of exception cases. The 'Central Dogma' of DNA -> RNA -> Proteins is still largely true for most cases. However, we discover all the time exceptions to this rule. Same here for the different 'tags' you can give DNA bases. Yes, you can teach the undergrads this, but then you'd have to teach them all the edge cases and other tiny things we don't even really know exist but one study from 1987 in the GDR said that..... You get the idea.
You only have so much time in the class and you have to hit all the big points of the field in an intro class like this hypothetical one. DNA tagging is not important if you are going to have to take time away from the different amino acids and what the importance of serine is for folding, or some other part of it. Saying that you can just explain away the other edge cases, a part of science that is still highly variable is just throwing away the pedagogy and hard earned years of teaching the instructor already possesses.
Also, just getting those core concepts into the heads of most undergrads is tough enough already. Half of them don't come to class as is on a Friday afternoon, let alone the other classes they take and the lives they have to live. Depending on the class, many of them may not even be at all interested in the material as the class is just a GE or something. And don't get me started on pre-med majors....
At the end of the course, you want them to be able to just think that they can read an article like the OP and say to themselves: 'Yeah, ok, thats not what I learned in school, lets click on it.'
- anigbrowl 12y agoSaying that you can just explain away the other edge cases I am not saying that. I'm just suggesting that it would be a good thing to allude to the fact of their existence in order to provide a glimpse of the wider context in which the basic concepts are introduced.
- ghshephard 12y agoPerhaps in an advanced biology course. But, given that you have limited time in class, and DNA is just one tiny, tiny component of a Bio 101 course, just getting across the concept of DNA, RNA, CGTA, Inheritance, and the implications to cell division is a victory. Trying to teach, "Hey, there are four bases, but no, not really, you can also have methylated cytosines, What is methylation you ask...." And then 25% of the class doesn't even grok the four bases concept because you got side tracked on a detail that is not relevant to baseline understanding. Admittedly, you can be too simple. When I took grade 11/12 chemistry in 1986/1987 in British Columbia, Canada - they did not teach chirality, and I didn't hear about it until watching an episode of Breaking Bad. So I see how one can feel cheated out of some pretty core concepts...