4 ms·
I don't think you've seen the systems they use in developing countries. Phone networks are almost a century behind the internet. It's not something that's easy
by ryanlol 12y ago
I don't think you've seen the systems they use in developing countries. Phone networks are almost a century behind the internet. It's not something that's easy to fix, nor are there too many situations where you would need to rely on the CID to identify the caller.
- wtallis 12y agoYou're still using the circular logic of insisting that caller ID can't be trusted because it shouldn't be trusted because it can't be trusted. I and most people who want to not get robocalls want a caller ID system that is trustworthy, and the first-world telcos we're doing business with are totally capable of providing a service that is at least partly trustworthy. I'm not interested in receiving calls from third-world countries and would be perfectly happy only getting calls from those using providers that provide for trustworthy caller ID, but nobody's even offering to sell me such a service.
- ryanlol 12y agoYou're not talking about Caller IDs here though, you're talking about some completely new technology that'd require a complete rework of current telephony systems. If you're worried about someone spoofing the source of their call you should probably consider using SIP over TCP, although it is unlikely that rest of the world is going to follow suit any time soon. And no, first-world telcos wouldn't be capable of providing what you want without massive overhauls either... Nor would they want to since there's a plenty of business critical applications that depend on this behavior.
- wtallis 12y agoCaller ID is what describes what I want, and the current methods for delivering caller ID info to the recipient of a call would not need to change. The telcos may have to invent a new term for how they handle things behind the scenes, but it would be transparent to me except that I'd now have a way to stop the robocalls. I highly doubt that it would be hard for telcos to implement such a system. I have no doubt that they don't want to, as evidenced by their decision not to in the face of strong demand. I can certainly understand that they might have lots of businesses interested in preventing such a change, but I'm not aware of how legitimate businesses would be harmed. All they need to do is ensure that when they call me they deliver caller ID information that corresponds to a real number that can be used to identify them to the FTC when I file my complaints.