10 ms·
Goldman's Self-Defeating Case Against a Programmer
- neonbat 12y agoPeople here are commenting that he stole code. That that's why Goldman is prosecuting but what constitutes stealing code? I mean the definition is "loosey-goosey-bullshit" at best. I used to work building trading algorithms; there is no clear legal consensus on what constitutes "stealing" code. If I just remember all the code because I have some kind of special photographic memory is that stealing? If I created the code, it's in my mind. I mean if you hire someone from a firm where they currently are part of the reason you're hiring them is because they have a particular area of expertise and definitely know what their current employer's code in this area looks like. That's WHY you hire them, so they can do awesome stuff for you instead. The point of the article is that in doing this kind of crap Goldman makes it extremely uncertain for programmers who go to work there if they will be able to go and work somewhere else exporting the skill set and tangible knowledge of code they acquired at Goldman to a new workplace. This uncertainty makes programmers NOT want to work for Goldman and will definitely kill Goldman. Bershidsky has got it right.
- tedunangst 12y ago> what constitutes stealing code? Creating an archive of code, encrypting it, then uploading it on your last day at work.
- baldfat 12y agoAlso trying to cover your tracks by trying to clear it from history. This one was a big issue for me. It showed he knew he did something wrong and was trying to hide it.
- joshuapants 12y agoThat act doesn't affect whether the preceding act was legal or not, so that really shouldn't be the big issue.
- ape4 12y agoWell maybe. Don't you clean out your desk on your last day. Why not also clean up your history.
- neonbat 12y agoThis kind of thinking is seriously dangerous. This is why burden of proof rests on the state. What something "appears to look like" is irrelevant to the actual crime. That's like saying running from the cops proves your guilt. It doesn't prove anything. Innocent people run all the fucking time because they know the cops will try to violate their rights. Cops are scary. Some people have standard practice to wipe everything. I mean it was his last day at work right? If it was your last day at work, maybe you're just doing general log clearing, like if you were never going to use a browser again one idea might be to wipe the history on that browser, clean out the work station so to speak. Doesn't sound so menacing now does it? Now maybe Goldman has policies against this; it's just an example of how these kinds of non-evidence tangential facts can be used to obscure the reality of a case. Also It would surprise me greatly if this guy was the first guy to wipe his workstation before leaving his job at Goldman.
- tptacek 12y agoBy all direct accounts the state amply met their burden of proof in this case. The case didn't turn on the bash history; that was part of a much larger pattern of facts. Just before leaving an incredibly sensitive job in the single most competitive part of the financial sector for a job paying 3x at an arch-competitor of his current firm, a programmer cloned a huge collection of source code --- the majority of which was proprietary and not open source taken from the single most sensitive technical asset at his firm, an asset which his new 3x job at the competitor was to reproduce, and uploaded it to an offshore Subversion hosting service nobody had ever heard of before. Later, he is shown to have presented portions of that code to his new firm. The only people on HN who think this is OK have that view solely because they think it's OK to do virtually anything to Goldman Sachs, because of the abuses Goldman Sachs has inflicted on the world's giant squid population. That is a fine and intellectually coherent position to take: firms who harm giant squids do not deserve the protection of law. But people holding that position should be clearer about it, and constrain themselves to squid-based arguments.
- BlackFly 12y agoThe one point consistently being missed is that many open source licenses carry a "taint" with them that causes most commercial companies to avoid them. What does it mean to propagate a program? If an employee checks out a personal copy outside of business hours, is that propagation, or modification of the single licensed copy that the business owns? When two employees modify the code simultaneously, who owns the copies? The amount of taint is irrelevant, either one included license taints it or no included license taints it. Once a bit of copyleft code is modified and included in a binary, the legal question of whether the result is open source is not trivial and certainly open for discussion. That being said, it is certainly the intention of many people releasing the code under copyleft licenses that any modified work be open source. It is completely unfair to project the idea that all people siding with Mr. Aleynikov do so solely due to animosity towards Goldman Sachs. It is completely circumstantial that he tried to hide the fact that he made a personal copy. It is often best to avoid having a discussion. I try to hide from my parents the fact that my wife and I... well you get the idea.
- fluidcruft 12y agoBy that logic anyone using private browsing mode on a web browser should is suspect. And personally, I would delete shell history on principle when leaving a job. I also delete my browser cookies and stored passwords etc. With the big plastered on warnings everywhere that all computer activity is monitored and recorded, it should be entirely reasonable to assume that these copies are redundant and disposable. I have a lot of people I have to interact with that insist on force me to login to their stupid sftp servers using plaintext passwords and they configure their servers to force interactive mode. And I very likely have PHI in my command history, too. There's absolutely no reason to not delete shell history when leaving a job, particularly now that HITECH means that I can be personally criminally prosecuted for data breaches. Besides, what constitutes "deleting shell history"? The way bash works by default, the last closed terminal deletes all the history of the other terminals. Does Goldman Sacks require users to maintain full shell history files as a condition of employment or as part of their expected work behavior or work product? I very, very much doubt it.
- tptacek 12y agoI would be wary of hiring someone who told me that it was their habit upon leaving a job to erase all traces of what they'd done while working at that job. That does not seem like sound engineering practice to me.
- fluidcruft 12y agoWho said anything about erasing all traces? If you want to use keyloggers to record the minutiae your employee's behavior, by all means record them. That has nothing at all to do with sound engineering. Sound engineering is always about process and documentaion, not surveillance.
- chrisbennet 12y agoAs I understand it, if he didn't clear the history,sensitive information (password?) would be readable/available. He probably did this pretty much every day he worked at G.S. The narrative that "he tried to cover his tracks" was meant to make him look guilty.
- tedunangst 12y agoIf your subversion password is in your shell history, well... you suck at life.
- o_nate 12y agoDon't know why this is being downvoted. This is a very valid point. Stealing code seems to be like pornography, i.e, you know it when you see it. Except there are lots of grey areas. What if instead of downloading the code on his last day of work, he had downloaded it a few months earlier? What if he hadn't erased his shell history? It seems that what constitutes stealing versus valid copying depends on his intent - which is a pretty weird definition of stealing when you think about it. Whether or not I stole your wallet doesn't depend on my thought process at the time. Edit: can't seem to reply to response below, so I'll just add here, if code theft requires intent to "permanently deprive" someone of their property then you need a pretty strange definition of "permanently deprive" as well.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> It seems that what constitutes stealing versus valid copying depends on his intent - which is a pretty weird definition of stealing when you think about it. Whether or not I stole your wallet doesn't depend on my thought process at the time. Actually, it usually does: "Theft is often defined as the unauthorized taking of property from another with the intent to permanently deprive them of it." [0] (emphasis added) [0] http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/theft-overview.html http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/theft-overview....
- DanBC 12y agoWell, theft means to take something with the intention of permanently depriving its owner of it, which is why there are different crimes for TWOCing (taking without owners consent) in UK and probably similar in US, so it's not that unusual to consider the intent of the perpetrator. Mens rea or something.
- o_nate 12y agoOK, you guys got me. I'm not a lawyer. So the legal definition of theft does depend to some degree on intent. I've learned something today. In that case, allow me to reframe my argument. I'll be generous and replace the term "intent to permanently deprive" with "intent to harm". Still, proving intent to harm is (or should be) much more difficult in cases when you have only made a virtual copy of something, and I think the bar is being set too low in some of these cases. So I think there is some validity to the argument that these financial firms are shooting themselves in the foot by being too zealous in persecuting behavior that can (or should) fall into a grey area.
- tedunangst 12y ago> perhaps an immigrant like Aleynikov, unfamiliar with the intricacies of the U.S. legal system and not 100 percent confident in your English skills. ah, yes, of course. That's why Aleynikov encrypted the source code, uploaded it, then cleared his shell history to hide what he'd done. Because his English wasn't good enough to understand the U.S. legal system. The same thing almost happened to me once. We did a lot of XML parsing at company A, for which we used the open source libxml. But work there got boring, and I wanted to make a fresh start, so I went to company B, where I also knew I'd be parsing some XML. For a while I considered encrypting the libxml code and secretly uploading it on my last day so that I'd be able to use it at company B. Fortunately, I grew up in the US and am familiar with the customs here, so I decided instead to wait until I arrived at company B, and then download libxml from xmlsoft.org. To think I was >this< close to jail...
- balls2you 12y agoYes but the "Don't copy that floppy" adage is definitely an American thing. So is CFAA, which makes it easier to have prosecuted Aleynikov under CFAA instead of some other laws. It worked for Swartz.
- tptacek 12y agoTaking the source code driving a 9-figure financial services practice at one of the world's largest investment banks, one that happens to pay you a salary that is notably generous even for tech, and relaying it to your new employer, a competitive firm that happens to have just 3x'd your salary, is simply not analogous to "don't copy that floppy". This wasn't King's Quest.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- egwor 12y agoA lot of the other points in the article are "headline grabbing". That's a rather disappointing article. I'd have liked to have seen a deeper analysis of the arguments used. It seems to be a skim-read summary of all of the articles I've already read on this, but with less actual substance/no new content. From the article: "Imagine you're a highly skilled programmer, perhaps an immigrant like Aleynikov, unfamiliar with the intricacies of the U.S. legal system and not 100 percent confident in your English skills. You're probably more at ease dealing with machines and the abstract tasks they solve when interpreting code than with people -- otherwise you'd do something else for a living. " What the heck?! What kind of professional writer writes something so child-like/troll-like? Another: "Traditional banks tend not to be such smart employers." We're talking about Goldman Sachs here. You know, the guys who employ people in tech (their CEO even referred to them as a Tech company) to keep ahead of the curve and who regularly make some serious profit. Yahoo, https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=GS https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=GS , shows I think 2 billion USD net profit per quarter. And another: "Goldman may be hoping Aleynikov's case will set an example to others like him, teach them to respect the bank's rules. Instead, it will tell good programmers to go elsewhere and perhaps, sooner than necessary, make Goldman obsolete." Perhaps this has changed GS, I don't know. Look at GSCollections (https://github.com/goldmansachs/gs-collections https://github.com/goldmansachs/gs-collections), something internal that they've open sourced and is now used by a fair few projects including spring. [edit: better layout/formatting/grammar]
- tptacek 12y agoIn his capacity as a columnist for Bloomberg View, he's no kind of reporter; that's literally not his job. He's a pundit. Some BV writers (most notably Matt Levine) do a fair amount of reporting for their columns, but many of them do nothing but digest other news sources and then opine on them. That seems to be what happened in this piece, which betrays no evidence of being informed by any of the court filings.
- cm2187 12y agoAgree. And I find the idea of the poor immigrant who doesn't speak english and didn't know it was bad to steal intellectual property very amusing. I have not followed the case but I think I remember that Goldman caught him because he was trying to temper with the logs on his machine to cover his tracks!
- tptacek 12y agoHe is encouraged to use open-source code to achieve results faster, but he's not allowed to give anything back to the community that developed it. His grander ideas are shelved, because the bank just wants quick fixes to its old, messy platform. When someone offers him a better job, free of the legacy system's constraints -- one that pays four times as much, as Aleynikov's new job with Teza Technologies did -- the bank enlists the FBI's help in going after him for saving some code on an outside server. One reason that this is an outcome of the Aleynikov case is that Michael Lewis made it so, despite the fact that it does not appear to be true: in both the Second Circuit review of original federal case and according to his own lawyer's stipulations in the new state case, the finding of fact is that the majority of the code he took was not, in fact, open source. In fact, his own expert witness in the first case was (according to filings, which may be missing context or additional facts) only able to conclusively identify a few files of open source code. The idea that Aleynikov was victimized by Goldman's unwillingness to cooperate with open source projects is a hacker-friendly narrative. We should generally be wary of hacker-friendly narratives, like the FBI dragnetting Google searches of pressure cookers; they tend to turn our brains off. Corrections welcome; I've read some of the filings in this case, but not all of them, and on this issue I am allergic to Lewis' reporting, which I believe to be uncharacteristically and dramatically shoddy.
- 1971genocide 12y agoI know this is the law of the land but - Any programmer's own code is open to whatever they want to do with it. I want to put my code on pirate bay ? I should legally be allowed to do so. The question that needs to asked is how is it allowed for companies to prevent the author of a codebase from using it on their own disgression ? There is a price to pay for this - we do not allow those poor multinational to profit massively. Programming in 2015 is socialism at its finest. How many programmers do you know who work on isolated codebases ? We live on the shoulder's of giants. Allowing companies to force programmers to hide or take ownership from their own code is bad practice, and harms human innovation. It also allows companies to force modern day serfdom on their knowledge employee.
- rayiner 12y ago
- Retric 12y agoAleynikov is hardly free of guilt. However, Goldman Sachs really dropped the ball on this one. Personally, due to many such issues, I am not willing to work with or for them in any capacity. That’s the kind of reputation effects large company’s need to be careful of.
- anonu 12y agoI've read quite a bit about this story so this article doesn't really add much that is new. However, there is an interesting note towards the end that fintech is a $12bn market. They link this Accenture report: http://fsblog.accenture.com/capital-markets/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2015/04/Accenture-The-Future-of-Fintech-and-Banking.pdf http://fsblog.accenture.com/capital-markets/wp-content/uploa...
- anonu 12y agoI've read quite a bit about this story so this article doesn't really add much that is new. However, there is an interesting note towards the end that fintech is a $12bn market. They link this Accenture report: http://fsblog.accenture.com/capital-markets/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2015/04/Accenture-The-Future-of-Fintech-and-Banking.pdf http://fsblog.accenture.com/capital-markets/wp-content/uploa...
- tsotha 12y ago>When someone offers him a better job, free of the legacy system's constraints -- one that pays four times as much, as Aleynikov's new job with Teza Technologies did -- the bank enlists the FBI's help in going after him for saving some code on an outside server. This is where the entire article just falls apart. They're trying to imply people will be afraid to work for Goldman because they might get sued if the work for someone else in the same industry. But if you're actually taking code a former employer paid to develop to another company it's perfectly reasonable for that former employer to seek some kind of redress. Most people understand this.