3 ms·
It may end up being a non issue, but not because of moore's law. It may come down to whether chip fabs decide to become miners or sell mining chips. That may
by CyberDildonics 12y ago
It may end up being a non issue, but not because of moore's law. It may come down to whether chip fabs decide to become miners or sell mining chips. That may come down to how much risk they want to take on.
Transaction fees are necessary for the same fundamental reason why bitcoin works at all - proper incentives. If there were no incentive to mine, miners wouldn't do it. The block reward will gradually step to 0, and won't be the primary source of mining income long before that. Transaction fees are the long term solution for miners to get paid. They also create a disincentive for people to create unnecessary transactions which would bloat the blockchain.
- bunderbunder 12y agoThough, speaking of incentives, this may point to an interesting market failure that lies at the very core of the Bitcoin economy: There's a relatively inflexible cost to processing transactions that's built into the Bitcoin protocol. It's possible for an individual to bring down the cost of processing with better hardware, but in order to bring down the cost of processing transactions by making the underlying process more efficient you need to get miners to go along with it. They've got reasons to oppose doing anything of the sort, though, because they want to keep the cost of entry high for any new competitors. They're essentially an informal cartel of players with a strong incentive to engage in rent-seeking behavior.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThat's an interesting point that definitely has some degree of validity. So far I don't think there has been anything that makes actually processing transactions cheaper (maybe moving to levelDB from berkelyDB would count), but I think that part is essentially trivial anyway. If there were high bandwidth costs for mining that would work in the favor of centralization, but I don't think the cost of processing a transaction or the bandwidth are anywhere near being a bottleneck. Processing transactions seems likely to never be more than trivial but I don't know that much about it.