4 ms·
The $10 per transaction stuff is totally ridiculous and seems to be just a way for people who don't like bitcoin to throw out a scary number which comes from VE
by CyberDildonics 12y ago
The $10 per transaction stuff is totally ridiculous and seems to be just a way for people who don't like bitcoin to throw out a scary number which comes from VERY distorted math.
I have the whole blockchain on SSD. It's on a smaller drive that I would have trouble making much use of anyway. The bandwidth is basically nothing compared to even watching a youtube video every day. So the whole idea has not basis in a pragmatic reality. The financial industry is 8% of US the entire GDP. There are real inefficiencies out there but bitcoin isn't among them. The incentives are lined up correctly.
It also seems that as bitcoin grows, the possibility for centralization is there but outweighed by the increased number of people participating as well as their investment. That is good, because even now there is a web of competing incentives so that it is increasingly unlikely the system won't work as people expect.
Miners if anyone have somewhat cloudy incentives, but ultimately if transactions per block are a problem, it is likely that not all miners will agree that they want transaction fees to rise when it is trivial for them to process many more transactions. This is combined with the fact that like the internet itself, if transaction fees grow to something non-trivial for the majority of cases, off blockchain transactions will increase while growing more mature similar to the dynamic of high gas prices have an effect on consumption (or any commodity).
When the price went down some people proclaimed that it would be inefficient to mine. The results weren't even noticeable to a casual observer, miners with less efficient mining hardware shut it off, which made mining more efficient for the ones that stayed, and the equilibrium happens organically.
Really the blockchain size is a hurdle, but not a technical one. The broad scale incentives are set, they work, and the system is long past the point of fragility.
- danbruc 12y agoThe $10 per transaction was at least a good estimate of the costs per transaction about four months ago. Electricity costs for miners were at least $6 per transaction, a very rough estimate of hardware and other costs came out on the same order. But feel free to do the math yourself with the current numbers. The last time I did it the numbers were as follows - hash rate 250 PHash/s, mining efficiency 1 GHash/J, energy costs 100 $/MWh and transaction volume 100k transactions per day. Or in short $6 per transaction, electricity for mining hardware only.
- mrb 12y agoThe $10/tx number is very misleading, because you present it as an inherent cost ("Bitcoin is by its very nature an expensive"). But you are dividing the global mining operational cost with the network capacity utilization rate. Consider this: by your logic if there was only 1 transaction/day you would claim a cost 100 000 times higher, or $1 million per transaction. But the fact is not only the block chain is underutilized (average block size is 0.35 MB so the network could sustain 2.8 times more tx, or 300k/day), but also the block size limit can and will be increased at least 10x without the miners needing to increase their operational cost. Taken together, this means the network will be able to handle 3 million tx/day (30 times more than today). This a number closer to what you should base your math on if you are trying to calculate the minimum cost of a Bitcoin tx, which would be approximately $0.30/tx. PS: in 2011 I had less than 20 kW of GPUs and I bothered moving half my farm to a location where I was paying $20/MWh. So you can be sure the commercial miners (who are doing the bulk of the mining these days) are paying less than $100/MWh.
- danbruc 12y agoI am not trying to calculate the theoretical minimum costs but the actual costs. Nobody cares if a transaction could theoretically cost $0.30 if right now someone pays those $10.00 for each and every of the 100,000 transaction on every single day. If the Bitcoin network at some point in the future processes 3 million transactions per day fine, but it does not right now and it honestly does not like this is going to happen anytime soon. The transaction volume is at best stable since more than one year and to me it actually looks more like it is slightly declining. And even if you get your electricity for free there is still the other half of the costs, the largest part being hardware. It doesn't really matter for me if it is $10 or $5 per transaction, it is not cheap. And even those theoretical $0.30 are still a lot. Real micro payments could be a killer application. Pay $0.05 or $0.10 to read a news article. If one hour of your time is worth $50 that is the equivalent 3.6 respectively 7.2 seconds of your time. Thinking a couple of seconds whether you should buy the article or not makes almost no sense at that price level. Just charge those few cents. But $0.30 per transaction is like a factor 100 to expensive for this. And with expensive by nature I meant that the security of the system depends on that. The Bitcoin network will never be able to spend less money on running the system because that is what it is protected by, the money spend on hardware and electricity. You can't even keep using your hardware for a long time because technological advances will make an attack cheaper and cheaper and therefore lower the security level your old hardware can provide. The Bitcoin network is doomed to throw money out of the window, hundreds of millions every year for processing not even enough transaction to make a Raspberry Pi sweat. To me this seems a pretty hefty tax for being distributed and trustless, especially because no one cares about those features.