7 ms·
However, with the abysmal standards of hiring, I'm sure a lot of companies would pass on very good candidates because they won't write FizzBuzz on the board for
by raverbashing 12y ago
However, with the abysmal standards of hiring, I'm sure a lot of companies would pass on very good candidates because they won't write FizzBuzz on the board for you, or companies would pass on Peter Norvig because his code is not Pep8 compliant
- rifung 12y agoNot sure if you're being serious but are you sure they would even care whether these kinds of candidates could program? I am skeptical they hired them to code; I imagine they mostly spend their time doing research and then have the SDEs implement things.
- jsweojtj 12y agoIt happens all the time, and it comes from a mix of things. One way it happens is that you get a PhD in astrophysics with years of data analysis experience in for a data science job. Have a software engineer interview her and he might find that she doesn't know a number of basic computer sciences concepts [traversing a linked list, tail recursion, implement breadth-first-search]. His knowledge background says these basic ideas are fundamental, there are therefore serious questions about the technical ability of the interviewee.
- raverbashing 12y agoThis is a good example. At the same time this CS interviewer may not know what's the second central moment of a probability density function.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoUhhh... the variance?
- kriro 12y agoI have no idea how hiring in this field works but I'd expect a data scientist to have a pretty good (algorithmic) programming background in this day and age. You pretty much have to "play with the data" and get a good intuition for it when it comes to gigantic data sets and programming is how you accomplish that. Or in other words...I'd be skeptical if a candidate hadn't learned programming on their own even if it wasn't required because it's pretty much impossible to get any practical experience otherwise.
- mhuffman 12y agoI think often then have experience in programming, but in languages that don't map well to the "real world" of programming -- R, octave, matlab, etc. Those languages are also usually loaded with very helpful libraries to avoid having to do any nitty-gritty programming.
- SilasX 12y agoBut there would still need to be a fizzbuzz style filter for AI jobs to keep out the people who overstate their abilities. Is there a good test for basic AI job capability?
- raverbashing 12y agoYou just interview people. Ask them to explain what a SVM is. Ask them to explain how training a linear perceptron works. This kind of stuff.
- SilasX 12y agoThat tests book knowledge, not actual understanding of how to think about AI, and leaves itself open to interviewer bias, the very things fizzbuzz avoids.
- raverbashing 12y agoThe idea that FizzBuzz has no interviewer bias is laughable at best. I can guarantee some will pick and reject people because they did things in a way they didn't like
- sigsergv 12y agoNo it does not. Without practical experience one just cannot discuss these things freely, and pure-book knowledge is clearly visible instantly.
- CHY872 12y agoSketchy, but in the other direction. In high school I did a project that involved a support vector machine, and over the course of this I learnt how they worked to a reasonable level of detail. Two years later, I interviewed at a large SV company, and they asked what projects I'd been working on. I gave a description of this project (2 years prior) and my explanation was phenomenal; in order to understand SVMs two years prior (without the 'necessary' mathematical background) I needed to develop all of the intuition (up to 'is kinda a high pass filter' etc) (which you might not ordinarily do at a time-pressured university course). The interviewer was correspondingly impressed, and the SV company gave me an internship almost directly off the back of this interview. The kicker is that at this point, I had a rudimentary knowledge of linear algebra, and absolutely no knowledge of any other machine learning; I had no business interning in their data science team. My point being that even as a first pass, the bookwork questions don't work fantastically. FizzBuzz is no better, but a data science alternative would have weeded me out pretty quickly.