2 ms·
I don't defend asset forfeiture for simply making large cash deposits, but on the other hand there is no way a guy selling sandwiches for $2.75 is taking in mor
by ams6110 12y ago
I don't defend asset forfeiture for simply making large cash deposits, but on the other hand there is no way a guy selling sandwiches for $2.75 is taking in more than $10,000/day in cash. We aren't getting the full story here.
Making a daily bank deposit is not "structuring" it's a common (and a best) practice. So if he was accumulating cash for a week or more and making large deposits, he was being stupid. Not that it justifies forfeiture, if that's all it was. But something isn't making sense here.
- pmorici 12y agoThat's the point. The guy _didn't_ make more than $10k in cash /day. His deposits each day were for less than $10k they said that because of that he was trying to evade the 10k reporting limit since he made regular deposits under the limit. ie: they are claiming if you made a daily deposit of say $3,000 that is suspicious and are seizing your money for structuring.
- ams6110 12y agoStill not buying. Every fast food restaurant makes at least one, if not several <$5,000 deposits every day of the week. It's completely normal for that type of business. He got flagged for some other reason that is not being disclosed.
- function_seven 12y agoWell for some truly bizarre reason, the government is keeping that "other reason" a secret, and not charging them with anything at all. That is not something the government should ever be allowed to do, at all, under any circumstance.
- appleflaxen 12y ago> But something isn't making sense here. So maybe the government should prove it. Like beyond a reasonable doubt or something.
- rosser 12y agoUnfortunately, you're perfectly parroting the State's position that assets somehow don't have the presumption of innocence that persons do in the US legal system. The state should have to prove that the assets are the proceeds of criminality in order to seize them, rather than their owner having to prove otherwise once they've been seized.