9 ms·
Is there a war instinct?
- berntb 12y ago1. The article don't really make such a hard claim as the title says. 2. It still seem to simplify a bit. Look at this quote: "We doubtless share a common ancestor with today’s chimpanzees, bonobos, gorillas, orangutans and gibbons [...] chimpanzees and bonobos are almost exactly opposed to one another: chimpanzees are known to engage in violent, group-level encounters, complete with search-and-destroy missions that conjure images of human skirmishing and outright warfare. Bonobos, on the other hand — genetically, no more distant from Homo sapiens — do nothing of the sort" We know that humans evolve the culture to a large degree. My native Scandinavia used to make today's Somalia look peaceful -- but now Sweden haven't been in a war for over 200 years. With mostly the same genes! Depending on circumstances, the culture changes to a very wide possible set of behaviours. So, at a minimum, we have instincts for creating a culture which can be warlike. It seems we are both bonobos and chimpanzees. It all depends on the social situation. (You could also note how deeply attitudes to violence changes in a culture when the local state gets a violence monopoly and creates a functioning police.)
- CodexArcanum 12y ago> we don’t have a plural form for peace Alliance, treaty, federation, united, concordate, joint, organization... And that's just the large scale things that get names. There's also friendships, marriages, corporations, cooperation's, and more. There are at least as many words for peace as for war. Sorry, pedantic nitpick anytime someone brings out the old "there are a hundred words for X but only one for X^-1"
- pistle 12y agoThat's a fair point on the use of that literary cliche. Yet, the main thrust of the idea is valid. Peace is a relief against from which special events (wars) are defined. Whether it's valid AND important to his thesis is doubtful. I argue that we don't have a war gene, but we do have genes that are related to our experience of fears, aggression, etc. and the power of these are more easily manipulated to create societies prone to war than to peace. Despite large groups of peace-loving people in most societies, violent subgroups will wage wars and turn fear into profit. You don't see the peace-lovers standing up against the war-mongers in a way which would stop the bloodshed. False binary coming... Would you spend a trillion dollars on raising the most helpless and hopeless up on a ladder of living standards or spend that same trillion stamping out shadows and bogeymen amongst the same people?
- sliverstorm 12y agoI would put it even simpler. Peace is a state of existence. War is a state of existence, and an event. State is not plural, but events can be.
- s_q_b 12y agoI look towards our closest relatives, Chimpanzees, at least one subspecies of which carries out organized troupe-based raids that echo much of what we see in human warfare. Troupes of young males patrol the perimeter of a territory by night, and periodically raid neighboring groups, killing adult males, seizing females, killing male offspring, and conquering their territory. I have a hard time believing that warfare is a pure invention, given its (near) universality across space, time, and our most closely related genetic relatives.
- danielharan 12y agoSo, you're assuming Chimpanzees are acting on instinct, rather than culture?
- verbin217 12y agoThis is the fundamental distinction every other comment here is missing.
- danieltillett 12y agoChimps have culture. The question is why have the chimps with a culture of war been so successful?
- dunmalg 12y agoThe reason chimpanzees are indicative of an inherent propensity towards warfare rather than it being a learned culture trait is that chimps do not have an observed unified learned culture. Their habitat ranges from Guinea on the west coast to Uganda, and the bahavior is observed in chimp communities that have no contact with each other.
- hitekker 12y agoDitto. Ants have also practiced warfare against one another, for perhaps a longer time than any other species: http://www.wired.com/2010/08/gallery-ant-warfare/ http://www.wired.com/2010/08/gallery-ant-warfare/ (Sorry for the wired link, I couldn't find the original primary source I read concerning the subject) On a side note: I feel like the title crosses "not too or interesting", goes past "interesting or revolutionary!", and somehow winds up in "just plain wrong/easily dismissible". His subtitle makes it even worse: "Many evolutionists believe that humans have a drive for waging war. But they are wrong and the idea is dangerous." Less an attempt to persuade, and more like preaching to the choir, who ever that maybe.
- ISL 12y agoSebastian Junger might disagree: https://medium.com/war-is-boring/sebastian-junger-knows-why-young-men-go-to-war-f163804cbf6 https://medium.com/war-is-boring/sebastian-junger-knows-why-...
- hitekker 12y agoRight. Specific quote that highly relates to the OP: "He tells me about a primatologist friend of his who studies chimpanzees. He began to study how chimpanzees wage war. “He was literally told by a fellow academic, ‘You’re undermining the cause of peace,’” Junger recounts."
- asgard1024 12y agoThanks, that was an interesting article. Yet, in the light of the OP, it also seems to be tied to specific American culture. It seems that there are societies (like in Europe) where going to war doesn't have so much that connotation of "being a man". Maybe they just do the ritual differently, for example, in Nordic countries, by trekking and hill-climbing. Now that I think about it, I am not sure this article is in disagreement with OP. The OP argues that war is a capacity, not some given natural trait. This article claims that people have need for "the ritual of manhood", whatever that is, but doesn't claim it has to be "going to a war". So even Junger may consider the war to be a capacity.
- joshuapants 12y ago> Maybe they just do the ritual differently, for example, in Nordic countries, by trekking and hill-climbing. ... or by compulsory military service
- s_q_b 12y agoNordic cultures have quite the history of the passage to manhood being warfare...
- gyardley 12y agoIt's odd that the page title is 'Human beings do not have an instinct for war', while the article title itself seems to be the far more representative 'Is there a war instinct?' The author is only arguing that we don't know if human beings are instinctually predisposed to war - as a counter to other writers who've been assuming that we are.
- dang 12y ago"Human beings do not have an instinct for war" is the doc title as well as the url, so the submitter didn't make anything up. But since the question is more neutral, we'll change it.
- kstenerud 12y agoI'm rather surprised that he has made no mention of Marvin Harris, who has studied culture and war extensively, including the case of the Yanomamo. Their way is warlike because they have their roots as "foot" indians, and over-hunted animals in the forest, and their farming practices are primitive and very deficient in protein. The resulting collapse of animal protein sources created a longstanding ecological pressure leading to the cycle of high female infanticide and war. And since they've already passed beyond the point of ecological replenishment, they can't break out of it. They actually have two words for hunger: One denotes an empty stomach, and the other a full stomach that craves meat.
- aaron695 12y ago> It is said that the Bedouin have nearly 100 different words for camels So the myth of Eskimos having 100 words for snow is now Bedouins and camels.... I'd argue sport is just war but with a lot less people being killed. Or war is just sport with a lot more people being killed. We love going to battle against 'others' > Many evolutionists believe that humans have a drive for waging war. But they are wrong and the idea is dangerous To make statements like this, they really need a much better argument.
- danieltillett 12y agoWho needs evidence? If the meme feels right then that is all that matters.
- venomsnake 12y agoStarship troopers - 1959: … I was not making fun of you personally; I was heaping scorn on an inexcusably silly idea — a practice I shall always follow. Anyone who clings to the historically untrue and thoroughly immoral doctrine that violence never settles anything I would advise to conjure up the ghosts of Napoleon Bonaparte and the Duke of Wellington and let them debate it. The ghost of Hitler could referee and the jury might well be the Dodo, the Great Auk, and the Passenger Pigeon. Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor, and the contrary opinion is wishful thinking at its worst. Breeds that forget this basic truth have always paid for it with their lives and their freedoms." He sighed. "Another year, another class — and for me another failure. One can lead a child to knowledge but one cannot make him think. I personally am with Kissinger and Metternich on that subject - wars are unavoidable, so it is better to have a system that limits their scope and regularity.
- digi_owl 12y agoI don't think there is a war instinct directly. But when you mesh self preservation with social status you get weird interactions where you end up being compelled to attack so as to not lose face with your in group. Damn it, the cold war almost went hot as much because neither side wanted to be the "weak man" and bend as it was because of a overt threat.