2 ms·
The problem is the operator is trying to unnerve you and embarrass you, specifically to fluster you. They don't just just ask you the questions they're interest
by moron4hire 12y ago
The problem is the operator is trying to unnerve you and embarrass you, specifically to fluster you. They don't just just ask you the questions they're interested in. They ask you about your personal sexual habits and other things designed to trigger an emotional response. It's all just a sham. The more honest of a person you are, the less likely you are to pass the polygraph on your first try. And the only way the polygraph works to catch out liars is to use the shame of the situation to coerce a confession out of the person.
Say they ask you "have you engaged in homosexual behavior, especially under the age of 14?" Most people I know, given the situation, will blush. And blushing is basically all a polygraph can actually measure. So now they start berating you that you lied, and if you continue to insist you didn't lie about that particular question, they say it means you lied about a previous one.
The only way to pass a polygraph is to know what they are like and just get through it. Honest people and liars both just need to stick to their stories, regardless of what the polygraph is saying, because eventually they will just fail you and schedule you for another one. Repeat until you've been through it so many times it doesn't phase you anymore. Then their job is done, their job being, "it wasn't my fault if you turn out to be a spy."
- tptacek 12y agoSure! But there are lots of situations in which a counterparty in a discussion has an off-putting advantage (see: every job interview), and yet we don't generally offer advice to candidates along the lines of "tense and relax your anal sphincter repeatedly" or "visualize your happy place on target questions and your worst nightmare on control questions". Is where I'm going with this clear? I feel like I'm just confusing everyone with this line of questions. I'm literally just asking: If I was given a polygraph tomorrow, knowing what I know now (in fact having conviction about what I know about polygraphs), wouldn't a reasonable strategy be to ignore any polygraph-specific advice, and manage the process the same way I would if there was a Magic 8 Ball adjudicating it? I know there are differences between the plastic toy and the fortune-telling billiard-ball, but are they meaningful?
- moron4hire 12y agoA magic 8 ball would be just as effective of a prop in the play that polygraph operators play.