3 ms·
Whenever you privatize a social need, you thrust the logic of capitalism upon it. However, the incentives of capitalism aren't always well paired with achievin
by kristopolous 12y ago
Whenever you privatize a social need, you thrust the logic of capitalism upon it. However, the incentives of capitalism aren't always well paired with achieving that social need.
Privatization can incorrectly incentivize an industry - look at the recent Corinthian college or the red light cameras where they reduced the duration of the yellow lights in order to induce more tickets (and thus create more accidents).
In both cases, these companies totally won at the game of capitalism but totally failed at addressing the social need that society expected of them.
The problem is that structuring these as capitalism encourages these types of activities. If we then ban the current offences but keep the profit incentives in place, the problems will only manifest in other ways. The problem IS the incompatibility of privatization with addressing a particular problem - not mitigating the natural obvious consequences and deluding ourselves into thinking it will still work.
It's also why open-source community linux has done better than privatized commercial unix: Keeping the incentives of software-making aligned with making good software ( as opposed to an artifact of monetary profit ) produces better solutions. You get better results without the neo-classical logic of capitalism in play - there's no incentive for closed ecosystems, planned obsolescense, forced horizontal integration, crippleware, releases timed with the market, information siloing, etc. All those problems just magically dissappear.
- jdreaver 12y ago> the victors are not those who best solved the problem but those who made the most profit. I would argue that most of the time those go hand in hand. If the most people freely gave you there money for a problem, then you accomplished that problem best. > red light cameras Hah! This has nothing to do with capitalism! The only reason people pay tickets is because they want their license and they don't want the government to lock them up. If a truly private institution came to you and told you to pay a ticket because they claim you did something wrong, you would tell them to pound sand. This goes for "private prisons" too. Neither of these things are capitalist at all. I'm not familiar with the Corinthian college case, but I am willing to bet they benefited from government student loans, federal education grants, and a public school system that warns children of a life of failure if they don't go to college. The higher education system in this country is propped up chiefly by government, so I hesitate to call a college failure a failure of capitalism. In fact, after reading the Wikipedia article, it looks like that college was improperly accredited. Isn't this a failure of the department of education?
- kristopolous 12y agoShould there be rewards for lying? Should there be strong encouragement to charge people for things that are effectively free? Should the winner be whoever cut the most corners, cheated the most people, had the greatest deceptions, and paid their employees the worst? Should we have a system where sending things around the world multiple times to be manufactured is seen as the best solution? Should we really exalt those who provide the cheapest service at the most unreasonable price by defrauding people? Should not taking responsibility for the consequences of ones actions be to their advantage? Should exploitation really be how one gets ahead? Should we have a system that defines success and progress by the volume and speed of such swindlers and con-men?
- MCRed 12y agoIn capitalism, every entity is kept in check by the need to keep employees coming to work, shareholders holding the stock, customers happy enough to come back, and the government off of their backs legally. These keep companies in line. If you think about it, none of these forces exist for government. Government employees often have no rights (military doesn't even follow constitution). They have little choice. The "shareholders" of government don't even get to have clean elections (not since 2001, voting fraud has not gone away, it's just no longer a big news story.) You have no choice. And of course the customers- you can't boycott he government. No matter how much you don't want to fund drones that murder teenagers for the crime of being brown and living near a desert-- you have to pay for it. IF you don't you go to jail, and if you resist, or try to escape you get shot. Can you imagine if walmart could compel people to shop there? Government doesn't even think twice about using the threat of violence for even its most insolent whims. Thus it's extremely important that government be kept in check, otherwise it will grow beyond all proportion until it undermines everything that opposes it and there's little, short of a revolution, you can do to stop it. I can think of examples for each of your points for government run services: > Should there be rewards for lying? Police want a suspect more than they want justice because, especially in high profile cases, being able to say they get to say they solved the case. There's evidence of widespread incidents of just convicting whoever they can convict of the crime without any pursuit of justice (eg: the hair forensics that the FBI was faking for decades.) >Should there be strong encouragement to charge people for things that are effectively free? Like the national parks? The massive amount of taxes people pay at all levels of government-- a charge-- for the pitiful results they get? For example, in Washington state the roads are less than %1 of the state budget, but they often increase the taxes charged by well more than %5 a decade, with repeated claims to use the money to fix the roads. How about he spectrum that he US Government claims to own and sells, even though it's free and everyone could use it at the same time (using spread spectrum technology). >Should the winner be whoever cut the most corners, cheated the most people, had the greatest deceptions, and paid their employees the worst? It is in the case of government. Poorly run services, under paid, overworked employees, entire industry of elections predicated on massive deception of the people, no real investigations when major events happen, pathological lying from the figureheads at the top, etc. etc. >Should we really exalt those who provide the cheapest service at the most unreasonable price by defrauding people? Have you ever been to a campaign rally? Seen how emotional and choked up people get about even really the most heinous examples of psychopathic politicians? Charisma is pretty much like magic. Meanwhile we pay unreasonable taxes compared to the benefits we get and the government defrauds on a massive scale-- from social security which returns less than %3 of net present value of the money taken to the welfare system which loses %75 of the money in overhead and only distributes %25 in benefits, etc. etc. If a retirement fund in the private sector or a charity were run like this, they'd be shut down for fraud. Yet government gets away with it- and people turn around and DEFEND IT! Talk about exalting those who are cheating you! > Should we have a system that defines success and progress by the volume and speed of such swindlers and con-men? You mean how politicians get re-elected by passing laws and claiming that this makes them "tough on crime" or "standing up to those moooslims in the middle east" and the like? Where success comes from backroom deals and selling access as Hillary is being alleged to have done, but as republicans and democrats have been doing since forever? You mean like the common shake down racket of threatening heinous regulations that would put whole industries out of business, yet backing off once a nice fat campaign contribution has been made? (And after you retire, don't those campaign war chests go into the politicians back pocket?)
- tzs 12y ago> Privatization can incorrectly incentivize an industry - look at the recent Corinthian college I wouldn't say it had incorrectly incentivized the industry, considering the 19 of the top 20 US universities on the latest US News rankings are private, as are 25 of the top 30. The problem with Corinthian is not that it was private. It was that it was for-profit. Those private colleges that dominate the top colleges list (Harvard, Yale, Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Princeton, yadda yadda) are all non-profit.
- kristopolous 12y agook sure. That's what I meant. Usually when people say "privatize" they mean "make it for-profit" and not "establish a separate charter and incorporate as a not-for-profit". My only claim is that the goals of the underlying impetus of the organization can be at conflict with the premise for its existence. The theory is that a large enough mismatch of these effort will only give rise to dysfunctionalism. Much of the "argument" I see is where people thing that their pet generalized economic model is clearly the best one for all of societies needs. It's a bag of hammers approach. The problems are too divergent for a unified solution to be the most efficacious. We need to stop the cheerleading and start the analysis.
- sjy 12y agoIt is difficult to see how the funding of those colleges can teach us anything about privatisation. They have endowments in the billions of dollars, and the prestige they have accumulated over centuries attracts staff and funding opportunities that will never be available to typical players in the education industry.