6 ms·
What about 'privatizing' a police force, with the correct incentives (not perverse incentives, as we see in the correctional sector)? I can see the bad aspects
by mc32 12y ago
What about 'privatizing' a police force, with the correct incentives (not perverse incentives, as we see in the correctional sector)? I can see the bad aspects of this, as well the good ones.
One of the main issues, in poor neighborhoods is the government of these places invest very little in them and typically the only governmental presence is the police, which is the last line of governmental assertion (via show of force), and provide little else to get the community going strong. That is to say, there is little put into resources for 'community building', yes, some people in those communities are less cooperative than people of more affluent communities --by cooperative I mean working together to improve and build on their vision.
In these cases, one can hardly fault the police for complaining that they feel the brunt of the frustration of a population while politicians politick and like Janus, speak from two mouths and their only policy to address issues is to send in the police to stabilize a place instead of engaging the community and establishing enhancement programs.
- jdreaver 12y agoIf anyone reading this is genuinely interested in a perspective on how many core government functions (law, police, defense, roads, etc) could work in a society without government, check out The Machinery of Freedom [1] by David Friedman. Even if you don't agree with removing government 100%, it gives you a new way of thinking about these services. There are a lot of fascinating examples of societies in history where many of these systems were not primarily controlled by the state. It is also a great mind-bending thought game to try and figure out how you would structure, say, a defense organization or a road company if the government disappeared tomorrow. I had a lot of fun reading this book, and I think it provides a lot of useful ideas for thinking about how government should function. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Machinery-Freedom-Guide-Radical-Capitalism/dp/1507785607/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1430618682&sr=8-1&keywords=machinery+of+freedom http://www.amazon.com/Machinery-Freedom-Guide-Radical-Capita...
- afarrell 12y agoWithout violating the 1st amendment, how would you prevent the company you've subcontracted to from lobbying legislators for perverse incentives?
- mc32 12y agoCan't you just establish the parameters in the legal contract between the jurisdiction and the service company? Just like it's my constitutional right to express myself as I please, my employer could decide to fire me for voicing something either they disagree with or something their customers disagree with and reflects badly upon them.
- afarrell 12y agoBut your employer cannot contribute to your political campaign.
- Retric 12y agoLocal police are locally funded which creates huge issues even for private companies. IMO, removing all local police funding would 'solve' most of these issues much more directly. PS: Ditto schools. Also, this is about funding nothing says control can't remain at the local level, but traffic ticket revenue for example should not end up in a small towns budget.
- minot 12y agoAt the risk of sounding like I'm overgeneralizing, fines and tickets should not go into the budget at all. Things like sin taxes make me uneasy. I cant believe people arent up in arms against civil forfeiture. The problem is... Where does this money go?
- Intermernet 12y agoThis is idealistic of me, but I always think that this money should be exclusively earmarked for public education and health purposes. It's a fairly reliable way of getting something positive from the "wages of sin".
- thaumasiotes 12y agoIf you believe naive statistics, giving US public schools extra money makes the students perform worse. (Obviously, what's going on is that extra money is being given to the schools with the worst students. But it's not at all obvious that spending extra money at a school makes the education any better than it was.)
- hibikir 12y agoIt doesn't matter exactly where you put it, but who happens to be one level above that. Imagine I am in charge of a budget for two departments. One I really like, and want to give it as much money as possible, and the other I do not, so I want to give them the smallest budget possible that keeps them running. Imagine you do not like that, and start giving X amount money to that department. When the next budget comes along, I'll just lower their budget by X, and give it to another department. The end result is that all you did was let me give more money to the department I like. You can tell yourself your money really helped your favorite department though, but unless you gave them more money than their old budget, you didn't help them at all.
- kristopolous 12y agoWhenever you privatize a social need, you thrust the logic of capitalism upon it. However, the incentives of capitalism aren't always well paired with achieving that social need. Privatization can incorrectly incentivize an industry - look at the recent Corinthian college or the red light cameras where they reduced the duration of the yellow lights in order to induce more tickets (and thus create more accidents). In both cases, these companies totally won at the game of capitalism but totally failed at addressing the social need that society expected of them. The problem is that structuring these as capitalism encourages these types of activities. If we then ban the current offences but keep the profit incentives in place, the problems will only manifest in other ways. The problem IS the incompatibility of privatization with addressing a particular problem - not mitigating the natural obvious consequences and deluding ourselves into thinking it will still work. It's also why open-source community linux has done better than privatized commercial unix: Keeping the incentives of software-making aligned with making good software ( as opposed to an artifact of monetary profit ) produces better solutions. You get better results without the neo-classical logic of capitalism in play - there's no incentive for closed ecosystems, planned obsolescense, forced horizontal integration, crippleware, releases timed with the market, information siloing, etc. All those problems just magically dissappear.
- jdreaver 12y ago> the victors are not those who best solved the problem but those who made the most profit. I would argue that most of the time those go hand in hand. If the most people freely gave you there money for a problem, then you accomplished that problem best. > red light cameras Hah! This has nothing to do with capitalism! The only reason people pay tickets is because they want their license and they don't want the government to lock them up. If a truly private institution came to you and told you to pay a ticket because they claim you did something wrong, you would tell them to pound sand. This goes for "private prisons" too. Neither of these things are capitalist at all. I'm not familiar with the Corinthian college case, but I am willing to bet they benefited from government student loans, federal education grants, and a public school system that warns children of a life of failure if they don't go to college. The higher education system in this country is propped up chiefly by government, so I hesitate to call a college failure a failure of capitalism. In fact, after reading the Wikipedia article, it looks like that college was improperly accredited. Isn't this a failure of the department of education?
- tzs 12y ago> One of the main issues, in poor neighborhoods is the government of these places invest very little in them and typically the only governmental presence is the police One of the reasons they often invest very little in those places is because they have very little...local services like police and public schools are often largely funded out of local budgets, which come largely out of local taxes. I think things would be a lot better if public services were locally administered but funded entirely from the state budget, with a large fraction of the allocation determined by the number of relevant people in the district of the service.
- mc32 12y agoIt's true that this is an issue. But social cohesion and cooperation can mitigate some of issues that exist with respect to funding. Yes, it would be better if there were at least something like 50/50 local to state funding for gov't services. However, the transient aspect of some of the residents don't allow the community building which helps other neighborhoods with more stable residents. however, we do have the example of poor immigrant communities (even African) which because of the tight cohesion, can overcome the funding issue. It takes energy and cooperation and dedication. To be sure, this exists in poor white areas too --again, they suffer from lack of 'community' and cooperation. And I wish local government would step in and intervene instead of just having the police deal with the symptoms --it's the quick fix, the bandage. Teach people and support their efforts to build their neighborhoods, give them opportunities to advance and join in on the rest of society rather than keep them at the periphery. Instill the importance of education. Make education "cool", not something to look down upon. I grew up in a mixed neighborhood with UMC, middle class and poor kids. Poor kids had a pernicious tendency to want to avoid learning and actually made fun and put down kids who attempted to get serious about studying. It was a kind of bullying. Fortunately, I got along with them so they did not bother me, except rib me about being the 'kid who studied and did homework.'
- cgriswald 12y agoI'm generally opposed to funding coming from outside a local community for something like law enforcement. This makes them a de facto branch of the state police rather than servants of the local community. Many local communities do not have local law enforcement and rely on the county Sheriff's Department anyway. But I think the GP was referring to poor neighborhoods within larger cities.
- dragontamer 12y ago> What about 'privatizing' a police force, with the correct incentives (not perverse incentives, as we see in the correctional sector)? I can see the bad aspects of this, as well the good ones. Privatizing the prison force has led to an influx of prisoners, as well as for-profit wardens colluding with judges to increase the prisoner count (ie: profits) for their prison. Privatizing colleges into for-profit colleges led to rampant abuse of education loans, rampant lies from recruiters, and hundreds of thousands of dollars of debt for hundreds of thousands of people. Until Obama cracked down on the practice and regulated the heck out of them. I don't understand why libertarians take various institutions, slap "privatize" on them and then assume that things will work out in the end.