2 ms·
Maybe one day we'll have technology which gets embedded and self-reports us whenever we transgress whatever laws we agree to or are born into. It's all automat
by mc32 12y ago
Maybe one day we'll have technology which gets embedded and self-reports us whenever we transgress whatever laws we agree to or are born into. It's all automatic and tunable in order to produce the desired result from society. It could even be 'democratic' voted upon by everyone, so there is no bootstrapping and no second guessing.
I think some of Canterbury's comments speak to a population not waiting for an investigation to complete before it reacts to events which have not reached an official conclusion (just or unjust). Let's say the family of a rape or murder victim does not wait till a jury reaches a decision and vents its frustration against the accused, or in some cases unrelated bystanders -resorts to extrajudicial procedure.
In reality the problem is not the speed of justice but rather the reactions and impatience is a product of lack of access to the mainstream economy, some of this is due to biases and some of it is due to socio-cultural issues (same as Appalachian whites). It's not as if some police brutality and injustice does not happen in other communities, but generally those communities don't feel disenfranchised so they don't need an outlet for their frustration. When an injustice happens they have access to the justice system to address their complaints and they have political power to bring attention to issues.
- DigitalJack 12y agoThere are so many laws and regulations, some contradictory, that at any given moment you are guaranteed to be in violation of some of them.
- dikaiosune 12y agoIt could be an opportunity to force streamlining of laws. The bigger issue in my mind is that most social change involves breaking some laws. A lot of those changes have been for the better.
- mc32 12y agoIf the laws are voted in democratically, then there would be little need to break laws, just vote to amend or void them. Of course, beware the curse of the tyranny of the majority.
- CamperBob2 12y agoIf the laws are voted in democratically, then there would be little need to break laws, just vote to amend of void them. Of course, beware the curse of the tyranny of the majority. Which is it? Your two sentences stand diametrically opposed to each other. The history of civil rights in the US suggests that your first sentence is absurd, and your second dead on.
- mc32 12y agoIt's hard to reconcile, yes, so typically one relies on 'basic laws'. In the end, however, it falls on the majority, strictly speaking. If 95% of the voting public wanted to they certainly could change the Us constitution, and there is very little the dissenting 5% could do about it.
- dikaiosune 12y agoSure, but the way that historically the 5% has grown to 50%+ has involved a bunch of people willfully breaking laws. They can't just be static standards. Society changes, and for the laws to reflect that there has to be some wiggle room. If we just say "any time that 90% or more of society agrees on a law right now, it will be that way forever," we will stagnate.
- mikerichards 12y agoMaybe one day we'll have technology which gets embedded and self-reports us whenever we transgress whatever laws we agree to or are born into. Say what? You really want some kind of robocop-chip embedded in you that reports you?
- mc32 12y agoNo, I don't. At fist blush it seems dystopian, but any other system brings in 'judgement' which is imperfect. It's more a mental exercise.
- perlgeek 12y agoTechnology can only help us with data collection (and that is a double-edged sword as well), not with moral judgement. And that seems to be the much harder problem.
- clusterfoo 12y agoAnd who would you trust with manufacturing and programming such a chip?