14 ms·
Cops: We Need Rights More Than You, Citizen
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoEverything he said is true, now what are we going to do about it?
- digdigdag 12y agoPer usual, not much will get done. It's your word against police unions.
- itistoday2 12y ago> Everything he said is true, now what are we going to do about it? For those of us who are illiterate when it comes to legal matters, the best we can do about it is to first fix our ignorance. When computers break, folks look for their local computer geek to fix it. When laws break, computer geeks should seek the counsel of their local law geek (or become one themselves). Now, if the law geeks say their system is so broken that there's nothing they can do to reasonably fix it, that's when the wider community can take alternative steps.
- virtuabhi 12y agoNothing. In US, people have "too much" respect for military and police. This respect has turned into an almost fanatical devotion. Say anything against these professionals and you will be branded as anti-national. Even the President cannot criticize the police. Unless US citizens realize that policemen are just professionals performing their jobs and not selfless angels, the police in US will always stay above the law.
- themartorana 12y agoI'm pretty sure the president did criticize the police. So had the mayor of NY, among others. The fact is, police have gotten so comfortable in their untouchable-ness that they've stepped over the line that defines the amount of corruption and abuse "we" are willing to look past. Apparently it is somewhere around cops straight up robbing (civil forfeiture) and killing us.
- mikeash 12y agoYour statement doesn't sound familiar to me. It does seem to be true for the military, which enjoys pretty much universal devotion from all. I think it's because we've finally figured out how to disentangle being pro-war from being pro-soldier, so that both warmongers and peaceniks can embrace members of the military. But I don't see anything remotely like it for the police. Respect is common, but far from universal. Where it exists, it tends to be mild.
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoWhy would those who oppose war embrace the agents of war? You cannot separate soldiers from the wars that they volunteer to participate in.
- mikeash 12y agoFor one thing, because many did not volunteer to participate in war. I'm sure you've heard stories about people coming home from Vietnam and being spit on. A lot of those people were drafted. In more recent history, most of the people sent to invade Afghanistan and Iraq joined a peacetime Army with no foreseeable major conflicts. Feel free to criticize the soldiers themselves, of course. I just don't see the point, and I don't think you'll get very far. Even if you vilify utterly in the public mind, you'll accomplish nothing. The people who decide where to send those soldiers are the ones who count.
- leesalminen 12y agoAccording to some comments on the article these rights apply only during "Administrative Investigations" and not "Criminal Investigations". Does anyone know if any officer involved death starts off as an administrative investigation or as a criminal one?
- desdiv 12y agoHere's a quote from Wisconsin's Law Enforcement Officers' Bill of Rights[0]: If a law enforcement officer is under investigation and is subjected to interrogation for any reason which could lead to disciplinary action, demotion, dismissal or criminal charges, the interrogation shall comply with the following requirements... That sounds broad enough to cover "Criminal Investigations". This might just be just Wisconsin though; the law might be different where that commenter lives. [0] http://www.legis.state.wi.us/statutes/1979/79Stat0164.pdf http://www.legis.state.wi.us/statutes/1979/79Stat0164.pdf
- droopyEyelids 12y agoHave I been missing stuff like this throughout the time I was growing up? This person is pretty much arguing for a legally different, privileged class of citizens to be created. The New York Times published an article by someone asking to create two classes in American society. Have power hungry nut jobs been publishing this stuff in the most respected media outlets forever? Or is this new?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- yuubi 12y agoIf it makes you feel any better, you can read some of his other stuff and see that he's arguing that such a class is on its way to bring created if not already here, and that he's against it.
- hobs 12y agoIts more like they want to codify it explicitly because the implicit understanding wasnt benefiting them enough. The rich and famous, the politicians, and the police/military already have elevated status and treatment within most societies even if it is not officially written, and this goes back to the earliest human establishments.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 12y agoIn the US there is already a separate class of people that cannot be touched. You just need money to be part of that class. The criminal system is designed such that if you have no money you'll go to jail for the smallest of the offenses. But if you have good lawyers, it is almost impossible to be convicted, because either you can pay fines and escape jail, or the prosecutors will be too afraid to go to court against you.
- mikerichards 12y agoDo you have a link to that NYT article you mentioned?
- mc32 12y agoMaybe one day we'll have technology which gets embedded and self-reports us whenever we transgress whatever laws we agree to or are born into. It's all automatic and tunable in order to produce the desired result from society. It could even be 'democratic' voted upon by everyone, so there is no bootstrapping and no second guessing. I think some of Canterbury's comments speak to a population not waiting for an investigation to complete before it reacts to events which have not reached an official conclusion (just or unjust). Let's say the family of a rape or murder victim does not wait till a jury reaches a decision and vents its frustration against the accused, or in some cases unrelated bystanders -resorts to extrajudicial procedure. In reality the problem is not the speed of justice but rather the reactions and impatience is a product of lack of access to the mainstream economy, some of this is due to biases and some of it is due to socio-cultural issues (same as Appalachian whites). It's not as if some police brutality and injustice does not happen in other communities, but generally those communities don't feel disenfranchised so they don't need an outlet for their frustration. When an injustice happens they have access to the justice system to address their complaints and they have political power to bring attention to issues.
- DigitalJack 12y agoThere are so many laws and regulations, some contradictory, that at any given moment you are guaranteed to be in violation of some of them.
- dikaiosune 12y agoIt could be an opportunity to force streamlining of laws. The bigger issue in my mind is that most social change involves breaking some laws. A lot of those changes have been for the better.
- mc32 12y agoIf the laws are voted in democratically, then there would be little need to break laws, just vote to amend or void them. Of course, beware the curse of the tyranny of the majority.
- rayiner 12y ago> In other jurisdictions, those protections are a result of collective bargaining and embedded in negotiated contracts. This is the part people need to internalize. Police departments in most cities are insulated from accountability for the same reason public employees are in general--they have incredibly powerful unions that can decide elections. The recent scrutiny of police activities presents a once in a lifetime opportunity for liberals and conservatives to come together and both get something they want: Improve police accountability and take a major bite out of budget-sapping public employee benefits in one shot.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoThis creates a problem for a lot of progressives, since attacking public sector unions is a big no no. Like, a super duper colossal no no. I see it floated around every once in a while on some mainstream American lefty blogs, and it always gets shot down.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ericcumbee 12y agoConservatives also have a problem. It's called the law and order voter. Taking the side of a crook/thug/punk over the brave men and women of law enforcement is not good politics with that voting block.
- username223 12y agoLiberals can make concessions about Union bargaining power, but what can conservatives concede? Investigating and trying cops by the same rules as citizens for assault/battery/manslaughter/murder seems like a non-starter, but I can't think of what else to suggest.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 12y agoI think conflict resolution is key. Police need to concentrate on de-escalating problems whenever possible, even allowing suspects to get away when the alternative is using deadly force. (Presuming, of course, that the suspect isn't an immediate threat to the public.) Take for example the recent shooting in South Carolina, where a policeman shot a man who was running away from a traffic stop. He could have just let the guy go. Ferguson is another example. The officer said he feared for his life and that's why he shot Michael Brown. The officer was in a running police vehicle at the time. Why did he not simply drive away? A quick stab of the accelerator and you're at a safe distance where you can take a moment to figure out what to do next. There was a recent incident in Virginia where a 17-year-old refused to get out of a car during a traffic stop, believing he had the right to have his parents present before interacting with the police. The police tried to force him out, which he resisted, and now he's naturally being charged with assaulting the police. Why could they not simply either get his parents as requested, or wait him out? Take Eric Garner. He pushed away attempts to handcuff him, at which point the police put him in a choke hold and pushed him to the ground, which killed him. Why not talk to him first? It seems like almost every incident where police misconduct gets national attention could be solved if the police had been willing to simply stop and have a little patience when dealing with problems. I'm uncomfortable with things like rubber bullets and bean bags, because they perpetuate the idea that force is a reasonable first resort for the police to use when dealing with trouble. They're also not guaranteed to be non-lethal; used on the wrong person, or just get an unlucky shot, and the target can still end up dead. We're seeing the same stuff in play right now with tasers. They were supposed to be a way for police to subdue people without killing them in situations where they would have previously had to resort to a gun. Instead, they're being used to subdue people when deadly force is not at all justified, simply because it's convenient for the police to stun people into submission. Every so often they tase somebody with a heart condition or something and kill them even though they posed no threat.
- emgee3 12y agoI wish I could upvote this more. Compare and contrast this protest in South Korea https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kMi7Jkay0fY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kMi7Jkay0fY
- mikerichards 12y agoGreat article. But this a symptom of the bigger problem of government workers wanting extra rights above and beyond what a normal citizen has. This will only get worse as governments (local, state, federal) grab more power over the people.
- paulhauggis 12y agoI find it odd that there is all these hate for cops (we can't trust them, etc)..yet, allowing citizens to own guns for their own protection is frowned upon by those same people.
- ori_b 12y agoWell, the thing is that guns aren't a very effective means of protection -- especially not from cops, who have more guns, more manpower, and tend to frown upon being shot at. And considering that one of the few times I'd consider lethal force justified would be when someone actually pulls a gun on a cop, that makes them especially useless. I mean, what scenarios do you see guns being a good solution for, compared to nonlethal self defense tools like pepper spray?
- wavefunction 12y agoI hate to say this, as someone who is pretty incensed by police brutality yet also believes in the right to responsible gun ownership in the US, that it is often better to kill an intruder to your house than wound or "incapacitate" them, as there is a precedent of criminals who have invaded homes and been wounded by the owners suing and winning financial judgements against the owners of the property.
- izacus 12y agoYou know what's even better (and for example, what local law here demands you to do)? Not HURTING anyone. It's just a damn TV.
- hga 12y agoI find it strange how you can know ahead of time the intentions and potentials of home invaders. What I call "strong Castle Doctrine" laws, in effect in many states, allow residents to use lethal force without warning, let along divining the intent of an intruder, because it can be presupposed in the US that someone invading an occupied dwelling is willing to kill anyone he come across, which happens all too often.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoI don't understand the lack of accountability issue, but perhaps it is because I live in Ontario. Sure, there are any number of abuses, but as soon as anything crosses a certain threshold, it is investigated by the provincial SIU (Special Investigations Unit). I may be very much mistaken, but fire a gun in the line, the SIU investigates. Someone dies in custody, the SIU investigates. Perhaps it is because Canadian municipalities - and their police services - are subordinate to the provinces - and to the provincial service. (The SIU is part of the OPP, the Ontario Provincial Police.) I'd be very curious to learn more from those more in the know.
- GigabyteCoin 12y ago> the SIU investigates. Someone dies in custody, the SIU investigates. You forgot to add "and nothing ever happens"... Remember Sammy Yatim? The teenager who was begging for the cop to shoot him that was posted to youtube in 2013? Well, the cop shot him to death, and then another cop ran on the ttc car to taser him (trying to cover up the fact that his buddy shot and killed him at point blank range with no provocation), and even more cops were filmed kicking away shell casings (in an attempt to make it look as though fewer bullets had been fired?? I don't know...) That's destruction of evidence. There still isn't even a trial date set almost 2 years later now. [0] Forcillo is still working in law enforcement with Crime Stoppers. And when the trial does finally occur, the entire thing is under a publication ban, so nobody will even hear about it. It will be on page 7 of the toronto star that James Forcillo was found not guilty and is now working for another police division. If he does get 10 years in prison I would be incredibly surprised. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Sammy_Yatim https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Sammy_Yatim
- mdpopescu 12y agoWhy only "he"? You are also pointing out that there were a bunch of accomplices - why shouldn't they be treated as such? If a "mundane" were to shoot someone and his friends tried to cover it up, wouldn't they also be charged?
- douche 12y agoI'm really waiting for some piece of white trash to get into one of these COPS-style police brutality cases, just to see what the reaction would be. My guess is, a whole lot of silence.
- tzs 12y agoYou don't have to guess. While unarmed blacks have been killed by police at a disproportionate rate, in absolute numbers more unarmed white people are killed by police in the US. These are indeed largely ignored outside of local news, after perhaps one or two brief mentions nationally. What seems to generally happen then is that they are investigated, and the killing is found to be somewhere between clearly justified and criminal, so there are no criminal charges but a good chance of a successful civil suit for wrongful death. That will often get a brief mention in the national news. Another large group of deaths that doesn't get a lot of attention, in either the press or on the streets, are the ~20 mostly young blacks killed per day by homicide. While some of these are due to criminal gangs attacking other criminal gangs, many are innocent people killed by mistake. It's sad that they are largely overlooked.
- T3RMINATED 12y agoCops are crooks !
- delinka 12y agoPerhaps we should become educated in how such protections are used locally and insist on the same treatment when "interacting" with the cops.
- teammatters 12y agoIm here in Baltimore and the guy who the cops supposedly roughed up so bad that he died had a rap sheet crazy long. He was a thug. Basically, all the thugs in Baltimore were the rioters.. the ones really lost at the birth lottery. But, you can get out of the ghetto .. though it I am sure it is not easy. It's all you know .. are surrounded by, but people do get out of the ghetto. Same thing with the kid in Ferguson who was shot by a police officer. He was a thug ... ten minutes before he was shot you see him on cam roughing up a store clerk who tried to stop him from stealing. Do you think ten minutes later he wasn't acting the same way towards Johnny Law and worse? Now that cop who shot a suspect in the back in South Carolina .. while running away from him is messed up. It's clear he wasnt a threat to the cop. Cop is at fault there. Overall I don't see this as black and white, rather a class war .. where the lower class are fed up living in the ghetto. Though what can be done ... as won't in a capitalistic society there will always be a poor people? I'm all up for hearing solutions to this huge social issue .. I miss going into Baltimore City. It's a nice city for all walks of life/classes and we usually live in harmony.
- venomsnake 12y ago> He was a thug ... ten minutes before he was shot you see him on cam roughing up a store clerk who tried to stop him from stealing. > Im here in Baltimore and the guy who the cops supposedly roughed up so bad that he died had a rap sheet crazy long. He was a thug. Thugs also have the same rights as the other people. Like getting alive to the court room, where to be judged by a jury of your peers. Police have manpower, training and hardware. They just prefer to put their lives above that of civilians.
- madaxe_again 12y agoOne day I sincerely hope a cop decides you looked at him wrong. Also, I know what you did in tenth grade, so you have it coming. You don't deserve a jury. You're a n*gger. Sorry, thug, that's the new word, right? Feels good, yeah? You don't understand the issue at all. You think it's about the people rioting. It isn't.
- teammatters 12y ago
- gremlinsinc 12y agoHow about we the people demand the same bill of rights as police. It's only right and fair.
- krylon 12y agoIn Germany, we do not have any "Police Bill of Rights", as far as I know, but in practice, it works out quite similarly in cases of police misconduct or outright brutality. The DA's office, which depends on the police to perform investigations for them, is quite reluctant to investigate police officers in the first place. And when they do, the police force will behave quite uncooperatively, testify only in favor of the accused police officer, evidence will get "lost" mysteriously, and so forth. Plus, if somebody sues a police officer for brutality, the usual reaction is to counter-sue for slander or false accusation (falsely accusing somebody of a crime is itself a crime under German law). In these cases, the best one can hope for is that the police drops its charges if you drop yours. I remember a case from a few years back that exemplifies the problem over here quite well: The police had a warrant so search the home of somebody accused of drug trafficking. They did however, by accident, drive to the wrong address and - because of alleged "imminent danger" - kick down the door. They did not find any drugs or other illegal stuff at the place (because it was the wrong place). But the person whose appartment they searched wanted the police to pay for his door. The police refused, so he sued. The judge's statement when he dismissed the case came down to "Tough luck, dude, deal with it". I find the very idea of a "Police Bill of Rights" repulsive. The police's job - formally speaking - is to enforce the law; as such, the law should be applied to them the same as to everybody else. If anything, the police - precisely because they are allowed, under certain circumstances, to beat and kill people - should be held to a stricter standard. It is also interesting that the police union here in Germany rarely if ever does what a union is supposed to do, namely to work towards better working conditions - better pay, shorter hours, and so forth - for their members, instead they mainly seem to advocate for more surveillance and against police accountability.
- scarmig 12y agoI wonder if there's a way to decouple the role of prosecutional evidence gathering from the role of public security that the police play. Basically having two departments with an iron wall of separation between them, so they're effectively neutral toward each other, if not adversarial. I'm not sure, though, how it even currently works in most places. Does anywhere do it like that?
- 12y ago
- downandout 12y agoThis is disgusting, and will only lead to more incidents like this [1]. Cops have too much protection as it is - they are essentially impossible to sue. They are fortunately being charged criminally on occasion, but not nearly enough. Unfortunately the kinds of people that will take a high risk job for low pay tend to be seeking the only other "benefit" of the job: power over others, that they are likely missing in their own lives (or they wouldn't have pursued the job). Many of them take joy in others' misery, and they have guns and handcuffs. It's a bad combination. [1] http://www.8newsnow.com/story/21557505/cover-up-alleged-in-clark-clark-family-court http://www.8newsnow.com/story/21557505/cover-up-alleged-in-c... - A woman was sexually assaulted by a police officer during an alleged "search for drugs," walked back into the family court she had just come from to tell the judge about it, and was arrested in front of her daughter for "making a false accusation against a police officer" (which, it turns out, isn't actually a crime in Nevada where this took place). The cop and the judge that watched her get arrested and refused to intervene while playing with the woman's daughter were both eventually fired but not criminally charged.
- RexRollman 12y agoTo quote KRS-One (Boogie Down Productions): "The police department is like a crew, it does whatever it wants to do."
- kefs 12y agoTake the word "overseer," like a sample Repeat it very quickly in a crew, for example Overseer, overseer, overseer, overseer Officer, officer, officer, officer Yeah, officer from overseer You need a little clarity, check the similarity http://genius.com/Krs-one-sound-of-da-police-lyrics http://genius.com/Krs-one-sound-of-da-police-lyrics
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joesmo 12y agoMight as well make this bill of rights complete and add the right to murder non-whites without consequences to it since that's already a given. I will never understand how anyone can defend or support or even respect the police in the US when they are nothing more than the most powerful, most corrupt, most violent, and most murderous (we think since most figures are suppressed) gang in the country. Fear, yes. It seems to me that at least in other countries, people are less deluded about their police situation (which is generally similar, though the details may be different). What we need are much higher standards for police conduct and independent investigation and prosecutorial forces that are strictly separated from the regular police force / prosecutors (and closely monitored for corruption) to investigate police abuses. There will be plenty of work for such full-time, permanent positions in every single jurisdiction given the amount of corruption and violence police cause. This idea that a police officer's testimony is somehow impervious to scrutiny, so much so that it will be accepted even when the judge knows the officer is lying needs to end. Basically, we have set up a huge, elitist "society" of cops, prosecutors, judges, and the rich people who support them who are beyond the law, not to mention justice. Of course we then get pissed off when these people talk about justice and even more so when they are either acquitted or not even charged with the serious crimes they commit, up to and including murder. Atrocious indeed. Fixing this situation seems rather tricky since the layperson only has the power to vote and there are no candidates who are willing to address this problem at any level. Fixing other laws that criminalize everyday activity, while incredibly difficult, seems to be the only way to try to go about at least reducing the ability of police to insert themselves into everyday situations they have no business inserting themselves in the first place. Still, at best, it's a workaround to reduce abuse, not one to actually eliminate it or deal out justice after the fact. In the case of police, the criminals (police) always get away with it.