6 ms·
> This was super distressing for a lot of people, as those belongings usually included wallet, phone, and keys. So after you are done at Central Booking, you ar
by mschuster91 12y ago
> This was super distressing for a lot of people, as those belongings usually included wallet, phone, and keys. So after you are done at Central Booking, you are basically left with no possessions or money, and no way to get into your home or contact anyone.
Please, someone tell me this is fucking illegal.
- task_queue 12y agoThis is standard fare for any police department ever. It took me about 4 months to get my phone back from the NYPD, which was fun. I love it when white people are shocked by their first arrest, because it (unfortunately) means something might get done. The system sucks. Now please scare other white people about it.
- ryanmarsh 12y ago> I love it when white people are shocked by their first arrest This. My arrest taught me that there is zero humanity and zero fucks given in "the system".
- mgraczyk 12y ago"I love it when white people ..." It's unclear to me why race has anything to do with this. Are you implying that you expect non-white people to handle "their first arrest" more casually, as if it is something they are familiar with and know will happen? If we really want things to improve, we need to stop complaining about how "white people don't see how bad it is for the rest of us." Focus on what we have in common, not what you arbitrarily perceive as what makes us different. The system is shitty for everybody. Your argument would have been just as informative and a lot more pleasant to read if it didn't begin by partitioning your readers by race.
- themartorana 12y agoI don't think it's entirely unfair. I'd venture that in the US, black people (and likely other minorities) are much more likely to have heard about and clearly understand what's in store for them if they get arrested. Most probably have a family member or close friend that has dealt with this injustice. Almost none of my white friends understand the terrible truths in the system beyond reading accounts like this in the media. I include myself among them. Part of it is probably population realities - when a minority segment of the population suffers the majority of indignities, it's more likely to hit close to home. Yeah, I'd like to remove black and white from many conversations. White guilt feels almost vogue, I have to hear about it so often from white friends and colleagues. But when it comes to the criminal justice system...
- drabbiticus 12y agoThe system is shitty for everybody and an appeal to a common humanity is absolutely critical for any reasonable expectation of humane social structures. However, to suggest that the experience of the system is the same for everybody is naive at best. I read task_queue's comment more as the following: "Societal structures do not change until those with more (social, political, economic, etc) power experience the inconvenience and injustice that people without the power to effect change experience on a more regular basis. That this is true is unfortunate."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- task_queue 12y agoI'm white. Systematic injustice has a funny way of being swept under the rug for years, decades and centuries when it doesn't inconvenience us or when powerful people of our race benefit from it. Swaths of people go through this regularly or are targeted and treated, much, much worse than this guy for the sole virtue of being the wrong race. Somehow, many white people, especially those in the upper class, never have to see this injustice ever. There's a reason MLK's strategy during the civil rights movement worked. It inconvenienced or scared white people into seeing the injustice of the system they are a part of and control. Police brutality and injustice is a side of America we are privileged to be mostly excluded from. When it becomes our problem, the system at least attempts to correct itself. As an aside, for many people I know, the whole police brutality meme really started brewing when it became common knowledge that cops can come into your house and shoot your dogs. It doesn't and didn't matter that has been going on for decades to those of the wrong race or religion, often with deadly consequences.
- slapresta 12y ago> It's unclear to me why race has anything to do with this. Because you're white. > If we really want things to improve, we need to stop complaining about how "white people don't see how bad it is for the rest of us." Oh god, I'm so glad the white savior told me how to Fix All The Things. So fucking glad. If we want things to improve, you need to get out of your posh white i-dont-see-color bubble and into the real world. People are dying, enabled by your "It's unclear to me why race has anything to do with this" and "The system is shitty for everybody" and your misplaced white pride. Partitioning readers by race is not meant to keep white people out. It's meant to keep people like you out.
- davidgerard 12y ago1791: Haitian slaves ask very nicely to be freed and are immediately liberated by all those reasonable white people. https://thenib.com/great-moments-in-peaceful-protest-history-44bdadb44cf https://thenib.com/great-moments-in-peaceful-protest-history...
- tomjen3 12y agoHn has no place for racists. Go somewhere else if you want to blame any racial group.
- task_queue 12y agoTell me more about how I'm the real racist for pointing out that the system is intractably racist. If this makes you uncomfortable, you need to come to terms with history and the present reality. We (white people) have been at the reigns and designed the legal system from the start to give us an advantage. I'd say we have to hold some accountability for maintaining a system we knew was broken for too long. I'd also go as far as to say those with power (in America, well-endowed white people), who have worked hard to change the the legal system such that they get a Fast Pass through it, have a responsibility to fix that system.
- tomjen3 12y ago>We (white people) have been at the reigns That is the racists part. Some people are in power, they are white but that doesn't mean you get to slam white people anymore than you get to slam all black people for being criminals. Downvoting me won't make the former any less racists than the last.
- task_queue 12y agoShow me where I slammed white people. No where did I slam white people. I'm sorry if having to take responsibility for the system we've been handed and benefit from makes you uncomfortable. But since mentioning race is inherently racist, we can go back to not mentioning race and pretending we're a post-racial society while the boys in blue continue to knock down doors and arrest every black person on the street corner because, by cop heuristics, they're all guilty. It's almost as if being asked to acknowledge the racism of the system bothers you in some way. A way to get rid of that bad feeling is to put your color-blinders on and pretend society is race-blind as well. I can do that, too, and never once have to face the injustice of or account for the system I maintain. PS I can't downvote.
- 12y ago
- wozniacki 12y agoPlease, someone tell me this is fucking illegal. I find these outbursts of genuine surprise and bewilderment amusing, in the best possible way. What I'm about to suggest is not meant to remedy or suggest alternate remedies to the workings of the criminal justice system as it currently operates. I'm merely expressing amusement at the colossal unfamiliarity of most of the generally law-abiding public (Black, White, Hispanic or otherwise) at how poorly our system works, even with the best intentions of the law makers and policy wonks. I can't but find people who expect an uniform carriage of justice, across all wealth levels, across all demographics and in all instances of law-breaking, to be nothing short of, deranged. Not so long ago, I held such similar delusions of equality and fairness, albeit not to the same degree as some here on HN. I always knew there was more than a little truth to the adage that it is far better to be wealthy and guilty than poor and innocent, in America. Any speck of doubt cleared up after I sat in a courtroom to witness the pre-trial consultations of a high profile defendant in SF. In a criminal case. It was a farce, to put it mildly. Just the resources available to the prosecutor on one side and the defendant with his high powered legal team -- which came with their own personal scribe to document the exchanges in the court, a videographer and the partner of the law firm among others -- on the other side, settled the matter for me. I don't quite know if its standard courtroom protocol to call both the parties - the prosecutor and the defendant's attorney - into recess to discuss matters in the judge's quarters but I counted 7 such times they just left to talk behind closed doors. I was floored at the deference with which the judge spoke to the defendant. The whole thing seemed like some closed door Congressional testimony with ranking members. I've never seen anything like it although I've seen the inside of a courtroom in unrelated matters before. I've seen common folk arraigned before. This was something else. And mind you this was in proletariat-loving SF not some courthouse in Montgomery, Alabama or Angola, Louisiana. I don't know what one should expect in those places. Try it sometime. Go to a courthouse and sit in one of the air-conditioned courtrooms and observe the proceedings. Edit: see comment below. Thx refurb.
- eru 12y ago> I can't but find people who expect an uniform carriage of justice, across all wealth levels, across all demographics and in all instances of law-breaking, to be nothing short of deranged. To be honest, the US is particularly bad in that regard.
- crimsoneer 12y agoFrom a UK law enforcement perspective - completely illegal if it were over here. Not only can you only keep property being used as evidence - which your mobile phone could be - but a risk assessment is conducted at the end of detention to make sure the detainee can get home safe, which would definitely include making sure they have cash/medication/etc, and making sure they're not suicidal. But yeah, coming from the UK, this whole thing strikes me as a little mad. But I suspect the author is omitting some details for dramatic effect. It would very much surprise me if it wasn't made very clear what she was being arrested for, and the officer explained her rights etc. I'm also sceptical about the "u turns to show off" - in the UK, all police vehicles have incident recorders, so showing off for shits and giggles is dangerous and likely to get you fired. It#s I'd be surprised if there weren't similar devices. It's also made exceedingly clear you don't post pictures on duty in social media unless it's approved etc. Nonetheless, sounds all very horrible, and it shouldn't be. I like to think we do it a lot better.
- herbig 12y agoThis happened to me as well when I was arrested for running a red light on my bike. I had to walk from downtown Brooklyn back to the precinct that had my stuff because I didn't have any money or keys into my apartment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7233730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7233730