3 ms·
The ability to freely set prices is no doubt a cornerstone of capitalism and there would certainly be significant inefficiencies introduced by any "fair pricing
by zaroth 12y ago
The ability to freely set prices is no doubt a cornerstone of capitalism and there would certainly be significant inefficiencies introduced by any "fair pricing" regulations.
That said, we're just at the tip of the iceberg for variable service and variable pricing based on expected customer value and expected customer elasticity. As more of our purchases are made programmatically. and as our identities, purchase patterns, credit records, even personal environmental factors can be taken into account in real-time, free market economics will force companies to adapt pricing models that can effectively exploit each customer's individual maximum utility.
Sometimes the "optimal" economic outcome is not the moral outcome. I'm not sure I like the idea of a world where the price of a Big Mac changes as each personal steps up to the counter and their iris is scanned to determine what they can afford. I think there's some reasonable expectation of privacy to our purchasing history which will work itself out over the next couple decade as the technology gets more advanced, sees more widespread adoption, is rallied against, and eventually regulated to some extent.
Part of the problem is that bad behavior is't often punished by the market to the full extent of the damage it causes. For example, with credit cards, some cards started changing terms so that payments were applied to the lowest interest rate balance versus the highest. It's clearly an "unfair" practice but because most customers of credit card companies don't have a clue about how interest is specifically calculated, the companies that adopted the practice were rewarded with higher profit at the expense of uneducated customers. Soon it became practically necessary for all credit cards to apply payments to lowest interest rate balances first, because they couldn't compete in the market if they didn't. I think this is a great example where regulation can enforce good behavior aka "fair dealing" while ensuring there's a level playing field so good actors aren't at a disadvantage competing with bad actors.
I think so-called bad actors will take variable pricing a "step too far". At some point it crosses an ethical line and becomes predatory. We haven't exactly seen where that line is drawn, but certainly user-agent sniffing is just the beginning. The airlines can afford millions in R&D to develop the algorithms to exploit maximum utility, but who is there who can monetize the algorithms which shield customers against these pricing attacks? When the most popular browser is made by an advertising company whose existence depends on collecting these metrics, it does make you wonder.
- notahacker 12y agoSure, creative pricing strategies aren't always in the interest of the consumer, but purely hypothetical suggestions of possibilities to personalise prices to a maximal extent is not a justification for eviscerating marginal airline routes by forcing the airlines to price weekly. As for user-agent sniffing, I suspect it's less prevalent in the airline industry than most other areas of e-commerce, since nearly everyone comparison shops, most airlines' tickets are available from multiple vendors at prices fixed at a given time by a purchaser-agnostic GDS, and the meta-search sites sometimes accused of agent-sniffing not only don't control the prices but often have to rely on outdated caches to actually display them at all...