4 ms·
I think people like to listen to economists because they see them as some kind of scientists and because when facing uncertainty, most people like someone who c
by cm2187 12y ago
I think people like to listen to economists because they see them as some kind of scientists and because when facing uncertainty, most people like someone who confidently predicts the future, whether it is an economist or a fortune teller. The reality is that one can't reduce our complex human societies to an excel formula, and economists are not scientists: they have no way to absolutely prove or refute any theory. They can only express an opinion in which one can believe or or not, and which are most of the time based on a massive over-simplification.
I don't think bubbles need a complex financial system to form (the famous example of the tulips). And a society can sustain any bubble. A bubble only really hurts if it is combined with high leverage, as it was in 1929 and as it was in 2007.
The mechanism by which this leverage is achieved doesn't really matter, it is the over-reliance on debt we should focus on. That people leveraged themselves through mortgages financed by CDO^2, by a shadow banking system (p2p loans) like in China, or by good old banking loans is a technicality.
One can blame the financial industry but the problem is really the addiction of society to leverage. Banks are merely the drug dealer.
I live in the UK and I am always perplex when I see how natural it is for people here to mobilise all their financial resources, bury themselves into debt through all the means possible in order to bid as much as they physically can on a house. And this is encouraged by the government who pushes for 100% LTV loans. And when confronted they always respond "it is fine, the property market only goes up, we just need to get on the ladder". Sure...
Governments are doing exactly the same. The rise of public debt since the 60s should be absolutely alarming. We have reached war time levels of indebtedness. How will this not result in a financial collapse?
One can blame bankers and speculators but I think this is missing the big picture here.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>I don't think bubbles need a complex financial system to form (the famous example of the tulips). And a society can sustain any bubble. The tulip bubble was small and did not have knock on effects for the Dutch economy, and for what it's worth, there was a futures market for tulips in 1637. Complex financial systems are not new. >I live in the UK and I am always perplex when I see how natural it is for people here to mobilise all their financial resources, bury themselves into debt through all the means possible in order to bid as much as they physically can on a house. And this is encouraged by the government who pushes for 100% LTV loans. Guess who gets the government to push loans on people? People take loans and buy a house because they're told by those above them that it's "the responsible thing to do". This message is echoed around the media as well. >One can blame bankers and speculators but I think this is missing the big picture here. No, that is the big picture. They are the ones who benefit from an over-leveraged economy and they are the ones who are pushing for it. Ordinary people certainly aren't dying to drown themselves in debt, just as they weren't the ones pushing for student loans. In five years time they won't be the ones pushing for the student loan book to be privatized either, but guess what? Someone out there is salivating over it.
- walshemj 12y agoBecause they see that paying a similar amount of money to a landlord plus all the extra fees renting requires - is not a sensible use of income/capital
- notahacker 12y agoOrdinary people certainly are the ones pushing for home ownership, for the simple reason that when homes are in a serious shortage, it makes a lot of economic sense to own them if you can commit to the mortgage payments. It's the same reason as people with no connection to the UK whatsoever and piles of their own cash to spend think that London property is a good place to park it. The government is buying electoral support with Help to Buy schemes and Right to Buy extensions; the fact the banks also like it is incidental.
- m-i-l 12y agoYes, wanting to put money in a physical asset which has utility value (like a property people can live in), especially when it is in genuine (rather than artificial) and difficult-to-reverse short supply (like property in London), does make financial sense. I think of the Right to Buy as being a bit like giving away the family silver in return for a few transient votes, and in doing so committing your children to a future where they'll have to rent expensive stainless steel cutlery.
- digi_owl 12y agoThere is a claim out there that the US gov have been pushing for homeownership because "homeowners don't riot". Or to put it in other words, when someone is saddled with a property and a family they are more likely to go "yes masta, right away masta".
- crdoconnor 12y ago>Ordinary people certainly are the ones pushing for home ownership, for the simple reason that when homes are in a serious shortage A) No, they're not. B) Home ownership doesn't solve the shortage problem. Actually, it can exacerbate it because it gives landlords an opportunity to gouge you. Building more council housing might help, but is that on the table? No. Banks wouldn't want that. That's rental income that is not being diverted to their pockets. >The government is buying electoral support with Help to Buy schemes and Right to Buy extensions; This is just the most palatable way of giving help to the banks. If electoral support were what they were really after, they would build more homes to offset the shortage. >the fact the banks also like it is incidental. You misspelled 'central'.