3 ms·
One can see why long form writing is becoming less popular: apparently all it takes to be published in The New York Review of Books is a tangent-laden, skin dee
by contingencies 12y ago
One can see why long form writing is becoming less popular: apparently all it takes to be published in The New York Review of Books is a tangent-laden, skin deep romp through the author's limited comprehension of a particular subject (in this case 'Indian' regional cultural influence).
Much known history is ignored, and generalizations phrased as truths quite apart from the historically grounding reality that nation-states are essentially modern creations, particularly amongst the politically fast-flux, linguistically and culturally varied regions of the world such as most of the Himalayan and Brahmaputra-valley borderlands.
PS. And the downvotes begin. "Oh, how wonderful the echo-chamber of junket-laden arts world, and their on-high post-colonial exhibition curators!" I wonder if they scammed a trip to Bali or something. FWIW, I translate original texts in some of the areas discussed and am on personal email contact with at least one of the major authors of the cited texts - the extent to which the author misses the point is amazing.
- youonlyliveonce 12y agoI agree, with most of what you have said but long form is not necessarily a sign of deep understanding or knowledge of a subject.
- throwaway_97 12y ago^ this guy is actually correct.
- indians_pro 12y agoYou are awesome and correct.
- UweSchmidt 12y agoCan you point us to a better article?
- contingencies 12y agoThe second cited source (Wade et al) looks a good read but I would not trust it implicitly. Lumping all South Asian influences on Southeast Asia in to a single text (leaving out China, Tibet, Iran, the Middle East and Africa) seems an exercise in artificial scope. Remember that 'Southeast Asia' itself is a vague distinction, particularly in the north. Half of Vietnam was Hindu until the 15th century, Burma never really existed (and to some extent still doesn't), similarly direct contact from the Pala Kingdom with Nanzhao is well evidenced by surviving images, documents and unmistakably Hindu carvings well within the borders of what is now modern China. Then there are each of the attested or probable seafaring dynasties (eg. Chera, Chola, Gupta, Nanda, Pallava, Pandya) and their various activities and records, in some cases many of which still exist, the establishment of kingdoms or fiefdoms of varying longevity (influentially Funan, but also in Burma, Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia), comments on those from visitors (many in classical Chinese), and the sum of archaeological work. Remember also, quite apart from the textual evidence, that mtDNA evidence now points to the peoples of significant parts of coastal China (eg. Shanghai region) having migrated north from Southeast Asia and not really being 'Chinese' at all, and irrefutable linguistic evidence shows Madagascar was settled by Austronesians who presumably sailed all the way from Southeast Asia. What all this means is that the period of recorded history does not intersect very much with much of the early period of cultural and linguistic exchange, therefore take everything you read with a grain of salt.