3 ms·
Also conservation of energy. Thrust can't vary by velocity because there's no such thing as absolute velocity. So your velocity (relative to whatever) keeps inc
by DennisP 12y ago
Also conservation of energy. Thrust can't vary by velocity because there's no such thing as absolute velocity. So your velocity (relative to whatever) keeps increasing linearly, while kinetic energy increases quadratically. At some point you start getting more energy out than you put in.
For some reason, this disturbs a lot of people more than violating conservation of momentum.
The alternative is that there really is absolute velocity, so the basic assumption of relativity is false. But that makes it a pretty big coincidence that atomic bombs work.
Still can't say I mind them checking just to be sure.
- avian 12y ago> Also conservation of energy. Thrust can't vary by velocity because there's no such thing as absolute velocity. So your velocity (relative to whatever) keeps increasing linearly, while kinetic energy increases quadratically. At some point you start getting more energy out than you put in. Can you explain why photonic rockets are not breaking conservation of energy using this reasoning? They have the same property you describe, but are considered feasible as far as I understand (if unpractical to implement).
- DennisP 12y agoBecause a photon rocket is throwing stuff out the back like any other rocket. It doesn't really matter that it's just photons due to mass-energy equivalence.
- mrfusion 12y agoI'm not understanding this argument. Wouldn't the same amount of thrust get you less and less delta velocity as your velocity increases?
- mrfusion 12y agoYou'd never get more change in kinetic energy than the energy you put into it, right?
- DennisP 12y agoWell that's the point: you would, so that's an argument why the device doesn't likely work.