4 ms·
> the police were acting on very little else than Goldmans assertion That's a fair statement by the OP. The external criticism has always been there was a lack
by dmix 12y ago
> the police were acting on very little else than Goldmans assertion
That's a fair statement by the OP. The external criticism has always been there was a lack of a full investigation from a neutral position by the state, as investigators depended on Goldman Sachs people to determine the crime.
Outside neutral parties weren't consulted AFAIK. Which is typically the case when sophisticated crimes take place - such as bringing in private industry experts.
Whether or not that would have resulted in different charges or handling by the police is up for debate. But it is certain that the worst of the original charges were found to be baseless, prosecutors were over-aggressive, and most of the evidence was thrown out because they didn't have a proper basis to conduct search warrants.
- tptacek 12y agoCriminal proceedings are adversarial. The defense brings in experts specifically to rebut the charges. The prosecution brings in experts to support them. Where do "neutral experts" fit into this process?
- pyre 12y agoNeutral in that the police and prosecutors verify that the claims by the victim are actually true otherwise anyone could use the police/prosecutors for destroy someone that they didn't like. Much in the same way that ICE has acted like the enforcement arm of the RIAA/MPAA when taking down domains. Barely (or not at all) verifying that the domains were being used for infringement (instead just taking a list given to them by the RIAA/MPAA and acting on it blindly).
- tptacek 12y agoTo the extent that's true, it's not really material to this case, right? His own lawyer stipulated to the facts. The dispute was a matter of law, not of fact. I agree with the prevailing sentiment on HN that (a) it's too easy to get an indictment (the grand jury is supposed to be adversarial against the prosecutors and isn't) and (b) prosecutors bias --- my belief is: primarily bias towards cases they can win easily --- has subverted the goal of prosecutorial discretion. But the facts of this case suggest a theft that could reasonably be valued at extremely high numbers. For it to be heard in court doesn't sound like a miscarriage of justice.
- pyre 12y agoI agree. I'm just stating that I feel like people are unsettled by how it seemed like the victim supplied all of the evidence to the police/prosecutors and there was a general, "oh well, if you say so," feeling to the relationship between them.
- tptacek 12y agoDoesn't that describe basically every theft case ever? Someone breaks into my house and steals my TV, the same thing's going to happen. You don't think maybe people are just reacting knee-jerk to the name "Goldman Sachs"?
- pyre 12y agoIf someone breaks into my house, the police come into the house to investigate. I don't gather all of the evidence for them while preventing them from entering the premises. When has a theft occurred where the police just accepted all of the evidence from the victim, but didn't really do any evidence-gathering themselves?