4 ms·
Architecture of HP's “The Machine”
- joshuapants 12y agoI'd be interested in seeing whether different hardware paradigms lead to different OS paradigms. He says they're working on Linux for The Machine, but I wonder if that's their endgame or if it's just to have something to run on it for now. Any OS-dev people able to chime in on what they would do?
- walterbell 12y agoNo mention of prior work on memristors? From http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor : "Leon Chua ..argued that the memristor is the oldest known circuit element, with its effects predating the resistor, capacitor and inductor. In 2008, a team at HP Labs claimed to have found Chua's missing memristor.." Imagine an alternate universe where Bell Labs decided to use transistors to build "A Machine", instead of enabling others to construct many possible machines. Hopefully HP research on memristors will inspire the worldwide scientific community.
- spydum 12y agointeresting, so essentially a giant memristor blob store which a bunch of compute nodes can simultaneously leverage? If the memristor promises are to be realized, TB if not PB levels of storage at >SSD speeds, accessed by many compute nodes as shown in diagram, which could also be many cores by themselves. Think of like a hadoop style cluster, self-contained on amphetamines? If any of this is true, why not start in phases where you have memristor replacing SSD/existing system memory.. why this monster design? unless they are trying to leverage their new fancy technology to disrupt the cisco/dell/supermicro enterprise server market?
- techdragon 12y agoBecause that's exactly what HPA want to do, foolishly try and disrupt the market with unproven hardware no one can afford.
- sgt101 12y agoIt might be the opposite, for corporates, this might be hardware that no one can afford not to have. People spend a lot on hardware, and a lot on electricity. If HP can do what others can do, but at 1/4 of the cost, and they charge 1/3 of the price, then money will flow to them like water.
- yitchelle 12y ago> foolishly try and disrupt the market with unproven hardware no one can afford. Sometimes, that is what research is all about. Some work out, some don't. I am actually quite excited about this for HP.
- spydum 12y agonobody objects to that.. the thing is, it sounds as if they have some very cool technology (memristors) which could make other existing products significantly better, but are explicitly withholding because they want to force some paradigm shift.. that seems like a pretty bold bet. What if nobody wants it?
- phkahler 12y ago>> If any of this is true, why not start in phases where you have memristor replacing SSD/existing system memory.. why this monster design? From what I've read, the memristors may not be working at scale. A single device works, but chips packed full of them have not AFAICT worked out yet.
- kahirsch 12y ago> From what I've read, the memristors may not be working at scale. Where have you read this? That sounds interesting.
- anon3_ 12y agoNot to rain on anyone's parade, but where are the hard facts? HP has that solution in The Machine. By discarding a computing model that has stood unchallenged for sixty years, we are poised to leave sixty years of compromises and inefficiencies behind. We’re pushing the boundaries of the physics behind IT, using electrons for computation, photons for communication, and ions for storage. Where is the review of the hardware? The pictures? Prices? I'm glad that you're having fun there, getting your 15 minutes of fame, making a living doing R&D. I'm sure you work hard. I wish that when you publicized - you had something more than a generic PR site with pablum. I'm sincerely interested in what you're doing. Please show actual prototypes, or there's nothing to prove to us it's not Vaporware. I'd be more satisfied your tithe is justified. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8RyKrREzuI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8RyKrREzuI
- cazum 12y agoExcuse my ignorance, but isn't the project a little early in development to have reviews, pictures(not really sure what pictures you expect to see anyway) or pricing? From what I understand, it's still in the POC stages. I agree that the site was very light on details, and quite pr-ey though.
- dang 12y ago> I'm glad that you're having fun there, getting your 15 minutes of fame Your comment's substantive point is squandered by this personal ugliness. That's not ok here.
- anon3_ 12y agoPeople have personalities. If you don't like people's personality, or at least give them the benefit of the doubt and assume good faith - do expect other's to just lobotomize themselves for you? When I said that, it's really my initial impression and feeling. It's a comment. I think, if done civilly, people can be allowed to express themselves without being PC robots. Edit: Oh sorry, When I said "Having fun, getting 15 minutes of fame", I meant those as two separate things. However, it reads as if I'm brushing them off.
- nailer 12y agoIf anyone is wondering: KeithP is Keith Packard of X.org fame - he was the driving force behind forking and advancing an otherwise stagnant xfree86, giving us things like the DAMAGE extension and other good stuff.