3 ms·
Someone in the other thread had a genius solution to this: - All domains should now come free with a domain certificate. Seriously, this entire problem set is
by Someone1234 12y ago
Someone in the other thread had a genius solution to this:
- All domains should now come free with a domain certificate.
Seriously, this entire problem set is solved by that one single change. It is one of these ideas that once you hear it you cannot un-hear it. We already know (and as this blog post says) that domain certificates have zero cost associated with creating them, so just bundle it with domain registration and soon competition in that space will force the additional cost to near zero (in particular if it is required).
This is a much better solution to "Let's Encrypt" because it scales better, and we don't have all of our eggs in one basket.
So who do we lobby to make this happen?
PS - Domain registrars won't fight this too hard as their customers will be "forced" to buy a "bundled" domain cert'. I am just hopeful that even if initial prices would be higher, eventually the additional cost will be absorbed into the domain registration itself.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> All domains should now come free with a domain certificate. So, every domain registrar should also be a trusted CA?
- Someone1234 12y agoIf they meet the requirements other CAs meet, sure, why not? But otherwise they'd have to find a CA to do the signing on their behalf.
- danudey 12y agoIt's pretty easy to prove that a given domain was registered by a given registrar, so it's pretty easy to say that e.g. Hover is responsible for example.com, so Hover can request one (!) certificate for .example.com (or re-request it and revoke the old one). Then the only problem is when your registrar is a bad actor, and that's rough because they lose all* their business when people find out that they're screwing over their customers.
- borplk 12y agoThat's just one of the many pieces of the puzzle. Most people don't understand how certificates work and get themselves in all sorts of trouble, so part of the problem is technical and educational. "Let's Encrypt" is much more than just a certificate authority, in fact other CAs can adopt Let's encrypt protocol (ACME). ACME is arguably solving the bigger part of the problem which is automatic configuration and renewal for the vast majority of people who have no clue how any of this works and don't want to have to think about it.
- phantom784 12y agoDoesn't do anything for embedded devices or intranet sites.
- cpach 12y agoHow many embedded devices have public IP addresses?