4 ms·
Your theory here seems to be that one person in the world having an extremely negative outcome validates basically all negative risk perceptions. I think that's
by wpietri 12y ago
Your theory here seems to be that one person in the world having an extremely negative outcome validates basically all negative risk perceptions. I think that's bunk. It makes no more sense than saying that because one person wins the lottery, it validates everybody who buys a ticket and loses. To evaluate risk and reward, you have to look at baskets of outcomes, not crazy outliers.
Suppose he lent his house to a friend who trashed it? Suppose he gave keys to a cleaning service and some reprobate there stole the keys and trashed the house? Suppose an earthquake destroyed his house? No matter what happens, there's always a way to blame people after the fact.
The way this discourages fixing things is that blame never fixes anything. Blame isn't a solution, it's another problem.
If somebody wants to do an integrated risk analysis on AirBnB and make some predictions on that, great. I'd love to read it. But comments like the one I call out are predicting the past. They're not just worthless, they're harmful to useful dialog.
- mikeash 12y agoWhat exactly is the difference between "blame" and analyzing a past problem with the idea of avoiding similar problems in the future, and what makes you put this particular statement on the "blame" side of it?
- wpietri 12y agoFrom Wikipedia: "Blame is the act of censuring, holding responsible, making negative statements about an individual or group that their action or actions are socially or morally irresponsible." This guy didn't "analyze a problem". There was zero intellectual contribution. He called people stupid for taking a risk and then being unhappy when they got a 1-in-a-million negative outcome. If you want a longer version of why blame impedes risk analysis, try the book I recommended upthread. (Or pretty much any book on retrospectives will have a shorter version.) But the short version is that you basically have a choice between the emotional activity of blame or the analytical activity of analysis. Because humans.