4 ms·
I have been a paid practitioner of AI since the early 1980s but I have a fundamental difficulty with the creation of a "real AI" that thinks as we do. I follow
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
I have been a paid practitioner of AI since the early 1980s but I have a fundamental difficulty with the creation of a "real AI" that thinks as we do.
I follow the Idealism philosophy (which is the opposite of Materialism) that posits that the fundamental property in the universe is universal mind or consciousness and our individual thoughts and ego are derived from a filtering operation: we as individuals filter out a small part of this collective unconsciousness (to use Carl Yung's term) and that is what gives us our identity while we are alive. All of modern physics would be layered on top of the underlying mind or consciousness.
If these ideas interest you, I suggest reading "Why Materialism is Baloney" by physicist and computer scientist Bernardo Kastrup.
All this said, I think "real AIs" are inevitable (even if far in the future) but I think they will seem very alien to us.
- blueprint 12y agoInteresting to encounter you here. May I humbly ask you one question? How do you define the term, "consciousness"? i.e. what object, range of objects, function, process, etc., do you indicate when you use that term?
- nsomaru 12y ago'not-object, not-function, not-process' (neti, neti). the Knower of these.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoI saw your comment a few hours ago, and I am having some difficulty answering you, that is, defining consciousness. In my experiences from more or less a lifetime of meditation practice (and what is meditation but an attempt to understand our own mind/consciousness/ego) my gut hunch/belief is that consciousness is something that is spread out and not localized in our physical bodies.
- blueprint 12y agoThank you for your consideration and time to reply. May I be frank with you? After I read what you said, I became concerned for you. Although, you probably don't feel like you're in any level of danger at this late stage. However, my sole expression of concern for you might even raise the impetus within you to reject what I'm saying now. I just want to prepare you to notice such thing, if it is happening to you. There's a reason that it would happen, which I'll explain. However, I have some things to say which might sound odd at first or second listen. But I can promise you that they are true, and that the more you try to listen and understand, the more sense it will make. Everything in the world is controlled by what is inside of itself. It's impossible for anything in the world to exist, to come into existence, or to change after having come into existence without this law. What and how things act are determined by the problem made when what a thing keeps in itself contacts what exists in the world, whatever the case may be. That's why to suggest that one's consciousness exists by default outside one's body is like suggesting that the driver of a car stays outside of the car. (Even if a hypothetical external driver gives orders to the car, those orders must be transmitted into some form of controller which exists within the system of the car, by way of direct connection.) If the real owner of the car is outside of the car, then it's quite convenient for any third parties to get into the driver's seat and to drive on their own. How much more convenient for those third parties if the real owner believes that he is currently still the real driver? S/he wouldn't feel a need to lock his/her car door, nor prevent any entrants. Additionally, it's actually quite detrimental to the health of the consciousness of a living person if it stays outside of their body, because it gets weaker very quickly that way. While I don't know you well, I can tell you not only from my continuous verifications, as well as additional research, but from my sufficient understanding of theory (i.e. law of operation) that any practices of meditation taught today make practitioners go in the exact opposite direction from awakening their consciousness and saving themselves, that is, enlightening themselves. In fact, meditation of today is the best way to (i) abandon and lose yourself, and (ii) to invite others' consciousnesses to drive you. After having lost yourself, you won't notice that it is the case because your consciousness exists in a state of dormancy, and what's more, the other consciousnesses who have been able to enter and drive your body intentionally keep your own, original consciousness in that state of dormancy. The others inform you of things instead of allowing you to use your own consciousness to receive (see) things of the world. There are many secrets in the world, and some of them are very profound. But because of the above, meditation is not the way for you to open your eyes to those secrets and to understand them. Meanwhile, it's very convenient for roaming consciousnesses who do not have a body (because they have died already) to use the opportunity provided by your practice of meditation in order to show you things, and to subsequently trick you into believing that what they show you are indeed those secrets that you want to know. Those who are in this state are kept from realizing it. The dead consciousnesses who have to enter humans' bodies have to do so because of their attachment to life, and the problems they couldn't solve while they were alive. After we die, we no longer have a physical body, so it's quite a bit more difficult to change things in ourselves. That's why they look for living people who they can deceive, enter, control, and use in order to express themselves. Indeed, due to your practice of meditation, you probably feel more peaceful. However, if you don't find any way break from their control, you will also encounter extremely difficult phenomena after you pass away, and will have a very hard time finding the way to come back to life as a human being again. Additionally, during your present life, as mentioned, you won't be able to enlighten yourself through your meditation. I'm telling you this in public at the risk of being ridiculed because it is all true (everything in reality is the proof of what I'm saying), and because it's quite possible that no one else has informed you of these truths. In order to confirm or disprove what I've said you've only got to look into facts and check. However, without checking, it will be extremely difficult for you to receive what I say. So, I hope you have an interest in saving yourself!
- icebraining 12y agoDoes it really change the argument, though? Even if the brain is merely a layer on top of an underlying mind, by making a functionally equivalent synthetic brain, it should also "access" (or however you want to call it) the underlying mind and gain an identity of its own, no?
- mark_l_watson 12y agoNo it does not change the argument. I personally believe that the common western view supporting materialism does not fit the evidence of well documented experiences of collective unconsciousness, experience of meditation, and cases of brain trama victims who have so-called out of body experience. But this argument seems a little like arguing about spirituality (or perhaps religion) in that we have our own beliefs and if people believe in what Deepak Chopra calls the "superstition of materialism" that is fine with me. The universe, physical reality, and consciousness are complex and a deep mystery and I don't feel right criticizing people who don't agree with me.
- deeviant 12y agoPhilosophy is not the right tool to attack AI science, although it has taken itself up to do so. I would sum up my general argument to support this as: "AI has enormous philosophical implications, but philosophical thoughts have very few implications on AI development (other than which research branches get social blessing)." The philosophical lines often seem to boil down into something like, "but even if it was intelligent, it wouldn't know what it's like to think like a human, thus it isn't thinking like a human", but this seems like a really weak line of thought to me. I don't nor ever could know what it's like to be you or any other person, but I can certainly relate and be related to by others as a human. There is over whelming evidence that the brain's operation(and thus it's resultant product: conscious and human though) is a physical process. There is no physics that suggests we can't replicate this process, but using a different substrate(ie electronic computing of some shape or another), and there is no physics that suggests we can't make such a system mimic the physical processes as a human. It seems more likely, in this case, that the differences and difficulty of relating to such a artificial system would be similar to that of just another different human being.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoThere are many theoretical physicists who argue that consciousness is tied in with quantum mechanical effects (e.g., my Dad's friend Henry Stapp; they were in the physics department at Berkeley together, and of course Roger Penrose) that are not supported on conventional computers. My Dad, who is a member of the National Academy of Science, does not agree with me re: Idealism vs. Materialism, but that just makes for more interesting conversations :-)
- blueprint 12y agoHow do you define the term "philosophy"?
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>I follow the Idealism philosophy (which is the opposite of Materialism) that posits that the fundamental property in the universe is universal mind or consciousness and our individual thoughts and ego are derived from a filtering operation: we as individuals filter out a small part of this collective unconsciousness (to use Carl Yung's term) and that is what gives us our identity while we are alive. So why do you ignore all scientific evidence as to the mind being the brain and how cognition works? How can you be a "paid practitioner of AI" if you completely ignore the science of real minds?
- mark_l_watson 12y ago"All scientific evidence" - please cite some. If you have the time and inclination, please read Kastrup's book. He addresses the shortcomings of materialism theories quite well. At least for my work projects (DARPA, Disney, SAIC, Google, etc.) "AI" has been engineering for good results, not mimicking the human brain. I did write up some experiments in training recurrent neural nets using genetic algorithms in a book I wrote for McGraw Hill in the early 1990s, and that is quite frankly just about the only time I have ever thought to model something even remotely like human brain activity.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoI did mention this paper in another comment: http://rspa.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/469/2153/20120683 http://rspa.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/469/2153/2012...
- danmaz74 12y agoA materialistic point of view doesn't contradict the manifestation of something like the "collective unconscious" in the Jungian sense: we all share most of our DNA, and a LOT of our culture/upbringing, material world, and very often language(s). But do you think that an alien life form would share that too?